Our Community Exhibit: Who Was Here, and What Changed?
How can we build a fair, evidence-based exhibit that helps our community understand the first peoples of North America and the changes that followed European arrival?
The mystery: Huge earthen mounds at Cahokia were built by a city of perhaps 10,000 to 20,000 people, as large as many European cities of its time. Why do so few people know its story?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
identify who made a source, when and why, and sort our questions by the kind of source that could answer them.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Imagine two notes about the same school soccer game. One was written by the winning coach. The other was written by a parent from the losing team. Would they tell the story in the same way?
Why might the two notes be different?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A source is anything that gives us information about the past. A primary source was made by someone at the time, such as a letter, a map or a tool. A secondary source was made later by someone studying the past, such as today’s article.
Three sourcing questions. Every time you meet a source, ask: Who made it? When did they make it? Why did they make it? The answers help you decide what the source can teach you, and what it might leave out.
More than writing. The people of Cahokia did not leave us books. So we learn from the things they built and used, which is the work of archeology. Native nations also keep knowledge through oral history, which is history passed down by speaking from one generation to the next.
Worked example 1: sourcing today’s article. Amara asks the three questions. Who? The National Park Service. When? It mentions sites added in 2011, so it was written around then, long after Cahokia. Why? To explain why World Heritage Sites matter. Amara decides it is a secondary source that is useful for basic facts.
Worked example 2: matching a question to a source. Dev asks, “What did people at Cahokia build?” Mounds and post holes can help answer that. Then he asks, “What did they call their city?” Digging may not answer that at all. Dev learns that some questions stay open, and that saying “we do not know” is honest history.
Today’s workshop. We will sort the Wonder Board into four groups: questions for maps, for artifacts and places, for written records, and for the voices of Native nations today.
Use the reading and our three sourcing questions. Talk before you answer.
Source something on your own.
Pick any object in your backpack or classroom. Imagine a historian finds it in 500 years. Who made it, when and why? What could it teach, and what could it not teach?
Our questions are sorted, and we have our three sourcing questions. Next we open the map and meet the land itself.
Exit ticket: why is it important to know who made a source before you trust it? Use today's reading as your example.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, sorting workshop 12, exit ticket 5.
Setup: make a four-column chart: maps; artifacts and places; written records; Native nations’ voices today.
Likely misconceptions: “primary means better”; “people without writing have no history.” Treat oral history as a real source with its own methods. Dates differ across NPS pages (A.D. 1000 to 1350 for the culture, A.D. 700 to 1400 for the site). They describe different things, which is worth pointing out.
Supports: provide a three-box who/when/why organizer. Stretch: ask what the article leaves out about the people themselves.
Answer guide: exit tickets should connect the maker or purpose to how we use the source, for example that the Park Service wrote long after Cahokia and is summarizing others’ research.
National Park Service, Midwest Region's Only World Heritage Site…and a Promise of More to Come · U.S. government work, public domain
This article comes from the National Park Service, a part of the United States government that cares for important places. It explains World Heritage Sites. These are places that UNESCO, an agency of the United Nations, honors as important to all people. The program began with an agreement in 1972.
In the Park Service’s Midwest Region, one site held this honor when the article was written: Cahokia Mounds, near Collinsville, Illinois. Native Americans built and lived at Cahokia from about A.D. 700 to 1400. It is the largest archeological site of the Mississippian culture.
At its height, from about A.D. 1050 to 1200, the community covered more than six square miles. It once had about 120 mounds of many shapes and sizes. After 1200 the city began to decline, and by 1400 its people had left.
Much later, people worked to protect what remained. The land was first set aside as a state park preserve in 1925, and Cahokia became a National Historic Landmark in 1964.
Source: National Park Service, Midwest Region's Only World Heritage Site…and a Promise of More to Come (nps.gov)