use evidence from Jamestown to explain causes and results of a settlement’s struggle, growth and decline.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Suppose you were choosing a place for a new town. List the three things you would look for first.
The English chose Jamestown partly because it was easy to defend. What do you predict was the biggest early danger there?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Settlements are not guaranteed. A town may grow, shrink or vanish. Geographers and historians look for the reasons. Jamestown gives us all three parts of the story: struggle, growth and decline.
Struggle. The site could be defended, but the water made people sick. Colonists depended on Powhatan food, then damaged that relationship by demanding too much during a drought.
Growth. Tobacco gave investors and settlers a reason to stay. More colonists came and took more land. That growth pushed into Powhatan homelands and led to war. It also relied on forced labor.
Decline. Jamestown itself did not stay the center of Virginia. After fires and the move of the capital to Williamsburg in 1699, it stopped being a town. Virginia kept growing elsewhere.
Worked example 1: a cause chain. Hana writes: “Drought made food scarce. The English demanded more food from the Powhatan. Tensions rose.” Each sentence leads to the next.
Worked example 2: growth for whom? Theo reads “the colony grew.” He asks who that helped. He writes, “Growth helped English planters, but it took land from the Powhatan and forced Africans to work.” The same event can have different results for different people.
Put event cards on a class timeline: 1607, 1609–10, 1612, 1619, 1622, 1644, 1676, 1699. Then answer together.
Add to your Investigator’s Log.
Give one reason Jamestown struggled, one reason Virginia grew, and one reason Jamestown itself declined.
How confident are you that you can I can explain why settlements grow or decline.
Tobacco changed Virginia. Next we examine the hard choices behind that crop.
Exit ticket: was Jamestown's growth a success? Answer by naming who gained and who lost.
Materials: dated event cards, class timeline. Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 8, mini lecture 8, timeline and practice 14, log and exit 6.
Accuracy notes: the National Park Service page dates Rolfe’s tobacco to 1612; another park page says 1610. Students can treat this as a real example of sources differing. Avoid detail about the Starving Time beyond hunger and death. Describe 1622 and 1644 as Powhatan responses to invasion and land loss, without excusing or glorifying violence.
Misconceptions: that Jamestown was the only story of Virginia; that the Powhatan disappeared. Powhatan descendant nations live in Virginia today.
Supports: pair cause and result cards. Stretch: compare Jamestown’s decline with Virginia’s growth.
Answer guide: strong exit tickets recognize gains for planters and investors and severe losses for the Powhatan and enslaved Africans.
National Park Service, Historic Jamestowne, “A Short History of Jamestown” · U.S. government work, public domain
In May 1607, 104 English men and boys chose a spot on the James River in Virginia. Water on three sides made it easy to defend, and deep water let ships tie up close to shore. But the river water was salty and dirty, and disease spread quickly.
This was the homeland of the Powhatan people. At times they sent food that helped the colony survive. During a drought, the English demanded too much food, and tensions grew. In the winter of 1609 to 1610, called the Starving Time, most of the colonists died.
In 1612, John Rolfe brought in a new kind of tobacco, and Virginia finally had a crop that earned money. In 1619, the first documented Africans were forcibly captured and brought to Virginia to work in the tobacco fields. Powhatan leader Opechancanough led major attacks against the spreading colony in 1622 and 1644.
Jamestown itself later faded. It was burned in Bacon’s Rebellion in 1676, and in 1699 the capital moved to Williamsburg.
Source: National Park Service, Historic Jamestowne, “A Short History of Jamestown” (nps.gov)