review the unit’s big ideas and skills by using evidence, timelines, maps and sources to answer questions.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Could burned wood from an old campfire tell us when people were in a place? Today’s reading is about a rock shelter in our own part of Pennsylvania.
About how long ago do researchers say people camped at Meadowcroft Rockshelter?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
This is a review lab, not a memory contest. In each round, you will answer a question and prove how you know. If you are unsure, go back to your evidence folder. Good historians check.
Four review stations. Time: order events and explain change. Place: use maps and describe location. People and land: explain adaptation, land change and the roles of different groups. Sources: tell who made a source, use its details and compare viewpoints.
Worked example 1: Grace uses a source as evidence. Question: did people live in western Pennsylvania long before Europeans arrived? Grace answers: “Yes. Charcoal from firepits at Meadowcroft has been dated to about 19,000 calendar years ago. Firepits show that people used the shelter.” She gives a claim, evidence and a reason.
Worked example 2: Yusuf reads a sample table. His practice table is sample data made up for class: Site A, 900 years old; Site B, 2,500 years old; Site C, 300 years old. He orders them from oldest to newest: B, A, C. Then he says what the table cannot tell him: who lived there or why they left.
Use your mistakes. When an answer surprises you, write what you thought, what the evidence says and what you will do differently on the checkpoint.
Rotate through the four stations with your team.
Make your own study guide.
Put five events from our unit in time order. Explain what came before and after one of them.
Write one strength and one skill you still want to practice. What will you do before the checkpoint?
The question that carries us through this unit is simple: how do we know?
Exit ticket: what is the strongest piece of evidence you have collected so far, and why?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 5, stations 20, study guide 6, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that carbon dating gives an exact year; that it can date stone directly; that early sites prove which modern group lived there. Researchers have debated very early dates in the Americas, so keep the language tied to this source.
Supports: pull a small group for the station students found hardest. Offer the frame: claim, evidence, because. Stretch: write a checkpoint question and a scoring guide.
Answer guide: timeline answers should be in correct order with a valid before-or-after statement. Reflections should name a specific next step. Use today’s responses to choose reteaching for 1.24 and the checkpoint.
Heinz History Center, Discover Meadowcroft Rockshelter, Used 19,000 Years Ago (David Scofield) · Copyright Heinz History Center; retold in our own words with a link to the source
Meadowcroft Rockshelter is in Avella, in southwestern Pennsylvania. A sandstone ledge above Cross Creek made a protected place to camp. Today it is a National Historic Landmark.
How do researchers know how old a campsite is? One tool is radiocarbon dating. Living things take in a form of carbon. After they die, that carbon slowly changes at a known rate. By measuring what is left in something like charcoal, scientists can estimate its age.
Charcoal from firepits at Meadowcroft gave dates of about 16,000 radiocarbon years. Radiocarbon years are not the same as calendar years, because the amount of carbon in the air has changed over time. Scientists correct for this using records such as tree rings. The corrected age is about 19,000 calendar years.
Every date also has a range of possible error. That is why careful writers say about. A small piece of charcoal can open a very long story, if we ask good questions.
Source: Heinz History Center, Discover Meadowcroft Rockshelter, Used 19,000 Years Ago (David Scofield) (heinzhistorycenter.org)