use evidence from the unit to explain what changed and what continued after European arrival, and choose big ideas for our exhibit.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back through your notebook and the Wonder Board. Which question from the start of the unit can you now answer? Which one still needs more evidence?
Which sentence best fits what we have learned about Native nations?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Change and continuity. Change is what becomes different over time. Continuity is what lasts. Strong historians look for both, because focusing on only one tells half the story.
Change we can prove. New diseases brought terrible loss. European claims and land deals pushed nations from their homelands. Slavery forced African people into the Americas. New animals, crops and tools changed daily life.
Continuity we can prove. Pueblo and Hopi communities carry on the history of Mesa Verde. The Haudenosaunee Confederacy continues. The Delaware Nation and other Lenape nations remain sovereign peoples.
Worked example 1: a change claim. Anika writes, “European arrival changed who controlled the land. The Walking Purchase took more than a million acres from the Lenape.” She used a specific case, not just a big statement.
Worked example 2: a continuity claim. Ben writes, “Native nations endured. Today the Haudenosaunee live in communities in New York, Wisconsin, Oklahoma, North Carolina and Canada.” He uses the present tense on purpose.
From evidence to exhibit. Our exhibit asks Who was here, and what changed? Today your team will choose three big ideas. Each needs a claim, two sources and a place on the map or timeline. In the next part of the unit you will build them.
Use the reading and your notes from the whole unit.
Fill in your team’s Exhibit Evidence Plan.
For each of three big ideas, write a claim, two sources (who made each one) and one map or timeline connection. At least one idea must center Native nations today, and one must include African people's experience.
How did people's relationship with the land help shape one big idea? Use one example from Cahokia, Mesa Verde, the Monongahela region or Lenape homelands.
You have gathered evidence and made sense of it. Next you start building an exhibit our community can trust.
Exit ticket: finish this sentence for our visitors: “Before you leave this exhibit, we want you to know that…”
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 7, practice 8, planning 12.
Likely misconceptions: that disease alone explains everything (violence, displacement and policy also mattered); that continuity means nothing changed; that Native cultures are frozen in the past.
Accuracy: the Hispaniola figures are the Library of Congress’s estimate and should stay labeled as an estimate. Keep Cahokia’s wording from 1.10: similar in scale to many European cities of its day.
Supports: provide a plan template and a bank of sources from 1.01–1.13. Stretch: identify a gap in the evidence and how the exhibit will state it honestly.
Answer guide: a strong plan has specific claims, named sources and map or timeline links, includes Native nations in the present tense and treats slavery directly. Keep the plans for Part 2.
Library of Congress, 1492: An Ongoing Voyage, Europe Claims America · U.S. government work; Library of Congress exhibition text
After 1492, European powers claimed lands across the Americas. Hernando Cortés conquered the Mexica empire between 1519 and 1521. Francisco Pizarro’s forces seized the Inca ruler Atahualpa in 1532.
Europeans brought diseases that Indigenous peoples had no defenses against. On the island of Hispaniola, the Native population is estimated to have fallen from about one million to 30,000 within 20 years. Disease, mistreatment, flight and disrupted farming all played a part.
Europeans also brought guns, iron tools, horses, cattle, wheat and sugarcane. Enslaved Africans were brought to Hispaniola as early as 1502.
Native peoples responded in many ways. Some shared food and taught survival skills. Some became allies of Europeans against old enemies. Others fought back: Timucua and Calusa resistance stopped Ponce de León’s expeditions in Florida. In 1531, the people of Huejotzingo in Mexico even brought a legal case over unfair Spanish demands.
Source: Library of Congress, 1492: An Ongoing Voyage, Europe Claims America (loc.gov)