compare viewpoints in two Pennsylvania events and explain how beliefs and trade-driven land hunger changed people’s lives.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. The Golden Rule says to treat others as you want to be treated. Where have you seen people try to live by it? Where have you seen it ignored?
In 1688, four people in Germantown, Pennsylvania, wrote a protest against slavery. How do you predict their religious leaders responded?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Point of view. People who live through the same event may see it very differently. Historians compare viewpoints and ask what each person knew, wanted and risked.
A protest ignored. The Germantown writers looked at slavery and called it wrong. Other Quakers in the same colony did not act, and slavery continued in Pennsylvania. People of the same faith could disagree deeply.
The Walking Purchase. After William Penn died, his sons wanted more land to sell. In 1737, officials showed Lenape leaders a deed they said dated from 1686. The original could not be produced. The boundary was to run as far as a man could walk in a day and a half.
A walk that was not fair. Officials hired fast walkers and prepared the way. The Lenape complained that the men did not “walk fair.” The boundary was then drawn to take in even more land. In 1741, the Lenape were forced to leave, and most moved west. Years later, Lenape fighters struck the Pennsylvania frontier.
Worked example 1: comparing viewpoints. Kira makes two columns. Penn’s sons: wanted land to sell and pointed to a deed. Lenape leaders: knew of no such sale and said the walk was unfair. She adds, “The missing original deed makes the first side weaker.”
Worked example 2: cause and result. Dev writes, “Because the Lenape lost their land through an unfair deal, anger grew. That helps explain the later attacks on the frontier.” He says helps explain, because events often have more than one cause.
Discuss each viewpoint from the evidence. We analyze what people said and did, and we do not act out these events.
Write in your Investigator’s Log.
Write a claim about either the petition or the Walking Purchase. Support it with one fact, and tell whose viewpoint your evidence comes from.
How confident are you that you can I can explain how beliefs or land changed life in early America.
We now have evidence from land, trade and people’s choices. Next time we answer our tea puzzle with a full written argument.
Exit ticket: what would be lost if our showcase told only one viewpoint on Pennsylvania's past?
Pacing: warm-up 5, reading 7, mini lecture 9, practice 13, log and exit 6.
Sources: Walking Purchase facts come from the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, “The Walking Purchase,” and the Delaware Nation history used in 2.09. The commission calls the link between the purchase and later raids probably valid.
Do not stage the walk as a race or game, or act out either event.
Misconceptions: that all Quakers opposed slavery in 1688; that the Lenape simply agreed to leave.
Answer guide: the viewpoints of enslaved people and of Lenape people are often underrepresented because colonists created and kept most written records. Accept responses grounded in the evidence.
National Park Service, “Germantown Quaker Petition Against Slavery” · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1688, in Germantown, Pennsylvania, a young German lawyer named Francis Daniel Pastorius and three other Quakers wrote a protest against slavery. The National Park Service calls it the first protest against the slavery of African Americans made by a religious body in the English colonies.
Their argument came from the Golden Rule: treat others as you want to be treated. They said every person has rights, no matter their beliefs, color or background.
They took the petition to their local Quaker meeting. It then went to larger and larger meetings. Each group was unwilling to decide such a big question, so it was passed along, and nothing was done.
The paper was set aside and forgotten. In 1844, it was found again and used by people working to end slavery. Later it was lost once more, until it turned up in 2005 in a Philadelphia vault, badly worn. After careful repair, it is now kept at Haverford College.
Source: National Park Service, “Germantown Quaker Petition Against Slavery” (nps.gov)