use peer feedback and a primary source to revise our map, stalls and panels.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Compare two comments: “Good job” and “Your rice arrow needs a source.” Which one helps more? Why?
Which feedback is the most useful?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Junior historians, strong work gets revised. Today, another team reads your showcase as a visitor would. Their job is to help your work meet our criteria.
Our protocol. Presenters explain for two minutes. Reviewers read silently. Then reviewers use three starters: “I learned…”, “I need evidence for…” and “What if…”. Presenters listen and write notes.
Check people first. Are enslaved people described as people? Are Native nations named? Is any person shown as a good, token or price? Fix those problems before anything else.
Worked example 1: Elena’s revision. Feedback said, “I need evidence for ‘Pennsylvania was against slavery.’” Elena checked the Germantown protest and the 1684 Isabella entry. She revised it: “Slavery existed in Pennsylvania, and some Germantown Quakers protested it in 1688.”
Worked example 2: Kwame’s region fix. Kwame’s stall said all colonies grew the same crops. A reviewer asked about climate. He revised it to show New England fish and timber, Middle Colony wheat, and Southern tobacco, rice and indigo grown with enslaved labor.
Keep a revision log. Write what changed, why it changed and which source supports it.
| Showcase criterion | What it looks like | Our evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accurate | Every label names a source. Sample data says sample. | |
| Complete | Regions, goods, routes, and why places traded. | |
| Honest about people | Slavery is told directly. Resistance and named Native nations are included. | |
| Respectful | People are never goods: no cargo labels, tokens, prices or game pieces. | |
| Clear | A neighbor can understand it without help. |
Run the critique protocol, then answer.
Revise and record your changes.
Make at least two revisions. For each: what changed, why, and what source supports it?
Use the Germantown protest or another source to strengthen one panel. Explain what it adds.
Your showcase is growing stronger. Next, we review the whole unit.
Exit ticket: which revision made your work more honest or accurate?
Flex lesson: this is the unit’s revision lesson. Extend it if teams need more time.
Pacing: warm-up 3, reading 6, lecture 5, critique 14, revision 12 minutes.
Language note: the optional quotation keeps its 1688 spelling. Read it aloud and explain it. The full petition uses harsh period language, so preview it before sharing beyond this excerpt.
Misconceptions: revision means neat copying; one protest means a whole colony opposed slavery.
Answer guide: strong logs connect each change to a criterion and a named source.
National Park Service, Germantown Friends' First Protest Against Slavery, 1688 · U.S. government work, public domain
On April 18, 1688, four men in Germantown, Pennsylvania, wrote a protest against slavery. They were Garret Hendericks, Francis Daniel Pastorius, Derick op de Graeff and Abraham op den Graef. They were Quakers, members of a Christian group also called Friends. The National Park Service describes their petition as the first protest of its kind in the British North American colonies.
A petition is a written request to people in power. This one argued that people should treat others as they want to be treated. It said this applied no matter a person’s descent or color. It also spoke against separating families.
What happened next matters too. The local meeting said the question was too weighty to decide and passed it on. It moved to larger meetings. At last, the Yearly Meeting in Burlington, New Jersey, set it aside without taking a position. The protest was brave, but it did not end slavery. A source can show both hope and limits.
“There is a saying that we shall doe to all men licke as we will be done ourselves; macking no difference of what generation, descent or Colour they are.” Germantown protest, 1688
Source: National Park Service, Germantown Friends' First Protest Against Slavery, 1688 (nps.gov)