define scarcity and opportunity cost, and use them to explain how tobacco shaped the Chesapeake region and at whose expense.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. You have one free hour after school and three things you want to do. Write what you would choose and what you would give up.
A farmer plants every field with tobacco to sell. What is most likely to be given up?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Scarcity. Scarcity means people want more than there is. Time, land, tools and money are all limited. Because of scarcity, communities must decide how to use what they have.
Opportunity cost. When you choose one thing, the best thing you gave up is the opportunity cost. It is not always money.
Worked example 1: a choice today. Noor has five dollars. She can buy a book or a pizza slice and a drink. She buys the book. Her opportunity cost is the pizza and drink, the next-best choice she gave up.
Worked example 2: a choice in Virginia. A planter has one good field. He can plant corn to feed his household or tobacco to sell. Caleb explains, “If he plants tobacco, the opportunity cost is the corn that field could have grown.”
Tobacco grew fast. Virginia’s tobacco output climbed to about 29 million pounds a year by 1709. Because old fields wore out, planters kept wanting new land, and that land was the homeland of Native nations.
Who paid the cost? Planters saw workers as scarce. At first many relied on indentured servants, who worked for a set number of years. Over time they turned more and more to slavery. Virginia’s laws hardened step by step, and a 1662 law said a child’s status followed the mother’s. By 1700 slavery was firmly established.
A hard truth. Scarcity explains why planters wanted workers. It does not excuse what they did. Enslaved people were human beings, not a resource, and they paid a cost they never chose.
Use the reading as your evidence. Talk first, then answer.
Add to your Investigator’s Log.
Describe a choice your school or family must make because something is scarce. Name the opportunity cost.
How confident are you that you can I can explain how tobacco shaped the Chesapeake region.
Tobacco shows that an economic choice can carry a huge human cost. Next we travel south to rice country and meet the skilled people behind that crop.
Exit ticket: who chose to grow tobacco, and who paid costs they did not choose?
Pacing: warm-up 5, reading 7, mini lecture 9, practice 13, log and exit 6.
Sources: output, labor-law dates and the indenture system come from the National Park Service, “Rise of the Colonial Plantation System,” and “Tobacco and the Atlantic World” (Historic Jamestowne).
Do not run a profit activity where students choose to use enslaved labor. Keep opportunity-cost practice to land, time and everyday choices.
Misconceptions: opportunity cost means every option lost (it is the next-best one); indentured servitude and slavery were the same. Servants had time limits and some legal standing; enslaved people were held for life and so were their children.
Answer guide: worn-out fields led planters to seek new land, pressing into Native homelands. Exit tickets should distinguish planters’ decisions from costs forced on enslaved people and Native nations.
National Park Service, Historic Jamestowne, “Tobacco: Colonial Cultivation Methods” · U.S. government work, public domain
Growing tobacco took most of the year. Planters started seedbeds in the middle of winter. In May, young plants went into the fields. Harvest came in late summer. Then the leaves were dried for weeks, sorted, tied into bundles and packed into giant barrels called hogsheads, which held about 1,000 pounds.
The work was exhausting. Making the small hills of soil for the plants was the hardest job, and a skilled adult could make only about 500 in a day. Most field work was done by indentured servants and enslaved Africans.
Tobacco also wore out the land. It took so much from the soil that old fields were nearly useless except for grazing animals, and they needed years to recover.
The crop could bring large sales. By 1640, London was bringing in nearly 1.5 million pounds of Virginia tobacco each year. But prices rose and fell sharply, and many planters fell into debt to the agents who sold their crop overseas.
Source: National Park Service, Historic Jamestowne, “Tobacco: Colonial Cultivation Methods” (nps.gov)