separate legend from evidence and compare viewpoints on William Penn, his family and the Lenape people.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A painting from the 1770s shows William Penn meeting Lenape people in peace under a tree. It was made about 90 years after the meeting it shows. Write one question you would ask before trusting it.
Who paid for this famous painting to be made?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Legend and evidence. A legend is a popular story about the past that may include some truth but cannot be fully proven. Evidence is something we can check. Good historians can enjoy a famous story and still ask, “How do we know?”
Source A: Benjamin West’s painting, 1771–1772. Penn’s Treaty with the Indians shows a meeting at Shackamaxon on the Delaware River. Thomas Penn, William Penn’s son, commissioned it. The Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts calls the meeting legendary and says the scene is symbolic rather than historical.
Source B: the Delaware Nation’s history. Today’s reading tells the story from a Lenape nation’s point of view. It calls the Walking Purchase fraudulent. The National Park Service also notes that the family claimed a 1686 treaty gave them 1.2 million acres, and that the treaty remains disputed.
Worked example 1: comparing makers. Grace notices that the painting’s patron came from the family that benefited from Pennsylvania land. “That does not make every detail false,” she writes, “but it gives a reason the painting shows peace and leaves out conflict.”
Worked example 2: putting events in order. Malik lines up the dates: Penn’s charter in the early 1680s, the Walking Purchase in 1737, West’s painting in 1771–1772. He sees that the peaceful image was painted decades after the Walking Purchase. The order of events changes how he reads it.
Be fair and exact. William Penn and his sons are different people. The Walking Purchase came after William Penn’s death. Our exhibit should name who did what.
Use the reading and both sources in the lesson. Point to your evidence.
Write for our visitors.
Write a claim, evidence and reasoning paragraph: What should our exhibit tell visitors about the painting? Use evidence from both sources, and say what is legend and what can be supported.
Who tells the story matters. Next we study people forced into this history from across the Atlantic, and what they did to keep their humanity and fight for freedom.
Exit ticket: why should a Pennsylvania exhibit include the Lenape nation's own account?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 9, practice 10, writing 8.
Important: do not re-enact or race the walk, and do not turn it into a contest. It was a tool of dispossession.
Sources: Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts collection page (pafa.org/museum/collection/item/penns-treaty-indians); NPS Independence timeline (nps.gov/inde/learn/education/timeline-early-black-philadelphia-nation.htm). The NPS timeline says the treaty is disputed; the Delaware Nation calls it fraudulent. Teach the difference in wording as part of point of view. Acreage figures differ among sources, so say “more than a million acres.”
Likely misconceptions: that all Penn family actions were the same; that Lenape history ended in Pennsylvania.
Supports: provide a two-source chart. Stretch: compare “disputed” and “fraudulent” as word choices.
Answer guide: the painting shows harmony and was commissioned by Thomas Penn; the Delaware Nation stresses land loss and survival. Strong writing labels the meeting as legendary and does not claim that nothing peaceful ever happened.
Delaware Nation, History · Delaware Nation website; no open license stated; summarized in our own words with a link
Lenape means “the people.” The Lenape homelands included eastern Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware and parts of New York, Connecticut and Maryland. “Delaware” is a European name that came from the river.
King Charles II gave William Penn a charter for the colony that became Pennsylvania. Penn is said to have made the Treaty of Shackamaxon with the Lenape leader Tamanend, but no paper record of it survives.
After Penn died, his sons and colonial officials planned to take more land. In the Walking Purchase of 1737, they used an old claim that a boundary reached as far as a man could go in a day and a half. They hired the fastest walkers and runners they could find, offered prizes and cleared a path. The Lenape lost more than a million acres.
Forced moves followed, again and again. The 1778 Treaty of Fort Pitt was the first treaty the United States made with a Native nation, and the first it broke.
Lenape nations are still here. The Delaware Nation is a sovereign nation based in Anadarko, Oklahoma.
Source: Delaware Nation, History (delawarenation-nsn.gov)