write an evidence-based explanation of how land, trade and choices connected distant places and who gained or lost.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at your first exit ticket from lesson 2.01. What can you explain now that you could not explain then?
Of all the Africans forced across the Atlantic, where do you predict the smallest share was taken?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Time to answer. We began with one cup. Now we can explain it with evidence. Scientists and historians both use claim, evidence, reasoning, or CER.
Claim. Your claim answers the question directly. Evidence. Your evidence gives specific facts from sources, such as names, places, dates and numbers. Reasoning. Your reasoning explains how the evidence supports the claim.
Worked example 1: a model about rice. Lucia writes: Claim: Rice made some Lowcountry planters rich through the stolen labor and knowledge of enslaved Africans. Evidence: The National Park Service reports that West Africans brought deep rice knowledge, and that their work helped make Charleston very wealthy. Reasoning: The wealth came from people who were forced to work and were never paid, so planters gained what enslaved people lost.
Worked example 2: improving reasoning. Aiden writes, “New England traded fish because it had fish.” His team pushes further. He revises: “Thin soil limited farming, but the sea offered cod, so New England specialized and traded for goods it lacked.” Now land, specialization and trade connect.
Gained and lost. Merchants, planters and many consumers gained. Enslaved Africans and their families lost freedom, homes and often their lives. Native nations lost land. Be specific, because a general statement can hide who did what.
From argument to exhibit. Your CER will become the base for your exhibit panels in the next part of this unit.
Gather your Investigator’s Log, map and readings. Build an evidence bank as a team before you write alone.
Write your Tea Puzzle CER. Use at least three sources.
How could one cup of sweetened tea connect farms, ships and forced labor across continents, and who gained or lost? Write your claim, at least three pieces of evidence, and your reasoning.
How confident are you that you can I can explain who gained and who lost from colonial trade.
You have solved the puzzle with evidence, and you have done it with respect for the people in the story. Next we turn your findings into a map and showcase for our community.
Exit ticket: what is the most important thing a visitor should understand from our showcase, and why?
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 7, mini lecture 6, evidence bank 8, writing 12, exit 3. Writing may continue into the start of Part 2.
Rubric (4 points each): clear claim; accurate, specific evidence from at least three sources; reasoning that connects evidence and claim; respectful, precise language about enslaved people and Native nations.
Accuracy notes: the 4 percent figure and regional totals are from the National Park Service page and cover about 1560–1850. Avoid graphic detail beyond the reading. The tea and sugar routes should remain distinct: forced labor is documented here for the sugar.
Supports: CER frame and evidence cards. Stretch: add a counterargument or a source that disagrees.
Answer guide: strong responses trace tea from China through British trade and sugar from Caribbean plantations worked by enslaved Africans, connect regional land and specialization, and name specific winners and losers.
National Park Service, Boston African American National Historic Site, “The Middle Passage” · U.S. government work, public domain
The Middle Passage was the forced voyage of captive Africans across the Atlantic Ocean. From the 1500s to the 1800s, merchants carried about 12 million African people across the ocean and treated them as property.
About 4.8 million were taken to Brazil and 4.7 million to the Caribbean. At least 388,000 were taken to North America.
The crossing lasted about 80 days. People were crowded together with little air or water, and about 15 of every 100 died. They had been torn from their families, homelands and languages.
We know about this partly because survivors told the truth. Olaudah Equiano and Ottobah Cugoano wrote about what they lived through.
Northern ports were part of this system. About 166 voyages left from Boston alone. Boston also shipped rum, probably made from Caribbean sugar, which was sometimes traded for captives. Enslaved people in Massachusetts later petitioned for their freedom.
Source: National Park Service, Boston African American National Historic Site, “The Middle Passage” (nps.gov)