explain who made an early American object or document, when and why, and why it belongs in our exhibit.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Many people think a written paper is the only kind of agreement that counts. Read about wampum. As you read, look for how a people can keep a record without writing it on paper.
According to the reading, what did wampum belts help people do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Every object on our wall must earn its place. Museums do not show things just because they are old. They choose items that help visitors understand a big idea. Today you will choose one object or document for your panel and prove that it matters.
Ask four sourcing questions. Who made it? When? Why? What can it tell us, and what can it not tell us? These questions keep us from guessing. They also show us when we need to say, “Historians are not sure.”
Listen to the people connected to it. The meaning of the Two Row belt comes from Haudenosaunee tradition, so our label should say so. Oral tradition is a kind of evidence: knowledge carefully passed from one generation to the next.
Worked example 1: Jamal’s document card. Jamal writes: “Two Row belt. Made by: the Haudenosaunee. When: tradition links it to 1613. Why: to record how two peoples would live side by side. Why it matters: it shows Native nations making agreements as independent peoples.” He does not draw or craft a copy. He describes it in words and credits his source.
Worked example 2: Leila’s artifact card. Leila studies the Bird Man Tablet, a sandstone carving about four inches tall found near Monks Mound in 1971. The Illinois State Museum says it shows a person in a bird costume, perhaps an eagle or falcon. Leila writes what she can support: “We know where it was found. We can only suggest what it meant.” Careful wording is part of good history.
Our exhibit rule. Some things should not be displayed by us at all. We will not show human remains or sacred objects, and we will not make copies of them. The case study explains why.
Use the reading, the worked examples and the case study.
Draft your object or document card.
Write your card in 40 words or fewer: name, maker, date, and why it matters to your big idea.
What is one thing your object or document cannot tell us? Explain why that limit matters.
For many years, museums and collectors held Native American human remains and sacred items, often without the agreement of the people connected to them. In 1990 the United States passed a law called the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act, or NAGPRA.
The law covers human remains, funerary objects (items placed with burials), sacred objects and objects of cultural patrimony (items that belong to a whole community). Federal agencies and museums that receive federal money must consult with descendants, Tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations. They must list what they hold, give notice and return items to the people they belong to.
The National Park Service says that human remains must always be treated with dignity and respect. Our class exhibit follows that same spirit.
Think about it: Why might a Native nation want to decide what happens to its sacred objects? What does our exhibit rule do to show respect?
An object speaks only when we ask careful questions and listen to the people connected to it.
Exit ticket: why does it matter that the meaning of the Two Row belt is credited to Haudenosaunee tradition?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 8, case study 6, guided practice 11, card draft 6, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that wampum was simply money; that only written records count; that a museum may display anything it owns. The 1613 date comes from Haudenosaunee tradition, and some historians have questioned it. Present this as a difference between kinds of evidence, not as proof the tradition is wrong.
Supports: provide a four-box sourcing organizer. Do not have students bead, draw or build replica belts or any sacred item. Stretch: compare what a belt and a written treaty each preserve.
Answer guide: cards should name maker, date (or “not known”), and a reason linked to the big idea. Exit tickets should say that the Haudenosaunee are the keepers of this history and that credit shows whose knowledge it is. Bird Man Tablet details come from the Illinois State Museum page (story.illinoisstatemuseum.org/content/cahokia-mounds-bird-man-tablet).
Friends of Ganondagan (Ganondagan State Historic Site), Wampum · Copyright Friends of Ganondagan; retold in our own words with a link to the source
Wampum are beads made from shells. Purple beads come from the quahog clam, and white beads come from whelks, a kind of sea snail. The shell is hard and breaks easily, so making beads takes great skill and time.
Wampum was not simply “Indian money,” as people sometimes say. For the Haudenosaunee and other Native nations of the Northeast, belts carry important messages. Their colors and designs help people remember history, traditions and laws.
The Hiawatha Belt records five nations agreeing to live in peace. The Two Row belt is linked, in Haudenosaunee tradition, to a 1613 agreement with the Dutch. Two purple rows stand for a Haudenosaunee canoe and a European ship traveling side by side down a river. Neither tries to steer the other. Each people keeps its own laws and ways. Three white rows stand for friendship, peace and respect.
The Haudenosaunee consider this agreement the basis of later treaties, including the Canandaigua Treaty of 1794.
Source: Friends of Ganondagan (Ganondagan State Historic Site), Wampum (ganondagan.org)