distinguish facts, opinions and claims in a primary source and explain how an author’s purpose affects what we can trust.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A cereal box says, “The best breakfast in the world!” and “Contains 10 grams of fiber.” Which could you check with evidence? Which is someone’s judgment?
William Penn wrote a pamphlet in 1681 to attract settlers. What would you expect it to do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Fact. A fact is a statement we can check with evidence. “Penn’s pamphlet was printed in 1681” is a fact.
Opinion. An opinion tells what someone thinks, feels or judges. “This is the best colony” is an opinion. Words like best and good are clues.
Claim. A claim says something is true. Some claims can be tested and may turn out to be false. A statement is not automatically true just because it sounds factual or appears in an old document.
Worked example 1: testing a line. Zoe reads, “it may be a good and fruitful Land.” She notes the words may and good. She writes, “This is a hopeful judgment, not a measured fact.”
Worked example 2: testing a claim. Ben reads that land would be “free from any Indian encumbrance.” An encumbrance is a claim or burden on property. Ben asks, “Free according to whom?” The Lenape lived on this land and had their own understanding of it. Penn’s phrase tells us what he promised buyers, not the whole truth about the land.
Purpose matters. Advertisers choose what to say. Penn’s warning about hard years may have made him seem honest, and it could also have been truly useful. We ask: who wrote this, for whom, and why?
Read the short quotations in the reading aloud. Old spelling and capital letters are normal. Sort each one as a team.
Write in your Investigator’s Log.
Write one fact and one opinion for our trade map about any colonial region. Label each and tell how you could check the fact.
How confident are you that you can I can ask who wrote a source, for whom, and why.
Penn’s pamphlet gave one point of view. Next we compare voices that disagreed strongly about what was right.
Exit ticket: why must our showcase check claims in old documents instead of just repeating them?
Pacing: warm-up 5, reading and quotations 10, mini lecture 7, practice 12, log and exit 6.
Source note: quotations are from the EarlyPrint transcription, which partly regularizes spelling, of a 1681 pamphlet. “600 miles” is Penn’s estimate; older students could test it using latitude.
Misconceptions: that fact means true and opinion means false. Stress that a checkable claim may be wrong, and opinions can be supported or weak.
Supports: offer plain-language versions of each quotation. Stretch: find what the reading says about trade with the “Southern Plantations” and connect it to slavery.
Answer guide: honest warnings can build trust and help settlers prepare. Exit tickets should mention bias, purpose or missing voices.
William Penn, <em>Some Account of the Province of Pennsilvania in America</em> (London, 1681), EarlyPrint text at Distant Reader · Published 1681, public domain
In 1681, William Penn published a pamphlet in London about the land he had just been granted. He wanted people to buy land and move there.
Penn gave details. He compared the colony’s location with places in Europe, and described rivers that ships could use. He listed what the land produced or might produce, such as wheat, barley, beef, wool and furs. He explained that colonists traded food and barrel wood to the “Southern Plantations.”
He also named prices. A buyer could get 5,000 acres for 100 pounds. A servant would receive 50 acres after finishing a term of work. The trip would cost at most 6 pounds for a master or mistress and 5 pounds for a servant.
Penn promised that laws and taxes would need the people’s consent. And he gave a warning: new settlers should expect two or three hard years without the comforts of home.
Notice whose voice is missing. Penn wrote about land for sale, but Lenape people lived there, and they did not write this pamphlet.
“The Place lies 600 miles nearer the Sun than England”
“it may be a good and fruitful Land”
“free from any Indian encumbrance”
“they must look for a Winter before a Summer comes”
Source: William Penn, <em>Some Account of the Province of Pennsilvania in America</em> (London, 1681), EarlyPrint text at Distant Reader (distantreader.org)