write a historical question that evidence can answer and sort the sources we will use into primary and secondary.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Remember the cup of sweetened tea on a colonial table. Write one thing you still want to know about how that sugar reached the cup.
Which question can a historian answer with evidence?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Junior historians, the Build phase begins today. In Part 1 you investigated land, goods and choices in the colonies. Now you will turn that work into The Colonial Trade Map and Market Showcase for our families and neighbors.
Our showcase has three parts. The Goods Layer is a map with arrows that carry goods only. The Market Stalls are four display tables about New England, the Middle Colonies, the Southern Colonies and the West Indies. Nothing is bought or sold at them. The Human Story Panels tell the truth about slavery, resistance and Native nations.
One rule never bends: people are never goods. Enslaved people were human beings with names, families and homelands. They will not appear on our project as cargo, tokens, prices or game pieces.
Strong questions come first. A historical question can be answered with evidence. It often begins with who, what, where, when, why or how. Opinion questions, such as “What was the coolest colony?”, cannot be settled by records.
Worked example 1: Amara’s question. Amara first wrote, “Was trade good?” That is too wide, and it asks for an opinion. She changed it to, “Who gained and who was harmed when New England traded fish for West Indies sugar?” Now she knows what evidence to find.
Worked example 2: Theo’s source sort. Theo found a merchant’s invoice book from the 1730s. It was made at the time, so it is a primary source. He also found a modern park article that explains the book. It was written later by someone studying the record, so it is a secondary source. He will use both.
Facts and opinions. A fact can be checked. “Boston ships carried fish to the West Indies” can be checked in records. “Boston had the finest merchants” is an opinion, even if someone wrote it long ago.
| Showcase criterion | What it looks like | Our evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accurate | Every label names a source. Sample data says sample. | |
| Complete | Regions, goods, routes, and why places traded. | |
| Honest about people | Slavery is told directly. Resistance and named Native nations are included. | |
| Respectful | People are never goods: no cargo labels, tokens, prices or game pieces. | |
| Clear | A neighbor can understand it without help. |
Use the reading and the criteria table with your team.
Start your team’s Showcase Plan.
Write two historical questions your part of the showcase will answer. Underline the word that makes each one answerable.
List one primary and one secondary source you could use from Part 1. Explain how you know which is which.
Questions point us to evidence. Next, we put real goods and routes on the map.
Exit ticket: why does our rule “people are never goods” matter for an honest exhibit?
Pacing: warm-up 5, reading 7, lecture 8, guided practice 12, plan and exit 8 minutes.
Misconceptions: “old means true”; “primary means most important.” Set the project rule clearly today. Stalls are displays. Do not add play money, selling or character roles.
Supports: question stems (Who gained when…? Why did…?). Stretch: name a question your sources cannot answer.
Answer guide: a strong rewrite names people, place or time, such as “Who did the work of making West Indies sugar, and who earned money from it?” The exit ticket should say that enslaved people were human beings and that treating them as objects repeats the harm of slavery.
National Archives, History in the Raw · U.S. government work, public domain
The National Archives keeps records of the United States. Its guide for teachers is called “History in the Raw.” A primary source was made by someone who took part in an event or saw it. Diaries, letters, drawings, photographs, official records and memoirs can all be primary sources.
Why bother with them? A textbook is one person’s explanation of the past. When you read original records yourself, you can see that written history is an interpretation, which means a careful explanation of what the evidence shows. Primary sources also make the past personal. Ordinary people appear, not only famous leaders.
The guide gives a warning, too. Every record reflects the views of the person who made it. Even a report that sounds fair was written by someone with a point of view. Sources can leave things out or disagree with one another. So a good investigator asks who made a source, and why, and then checks it against other evidence.
Source: National Archives, History in the Raw (archives.gov)