compare how sources show different viewpoints and use peer critique to make our exhibit more accurate and fair.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Two people describe the same deal. One says, “It was legal. We have a paper.” The other says, “You tricked us.” What would you need to know before deciding who is right?
What is the best first step when two accounts of an event disagree?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A document can be real and still be unfair. The 1737 deed is a real source. It shows what colonial officials wanted on paper. But it does not tell the whole story of pressure, trust and loss. To understand it, we compare it with what Delaware people said and did.
Compare with three questions. Who made or reported this source? What did that person want? What does the source leave out? A viewpoint is not just an opinion. It comes from a person’s position, goals and experience.
Worked example 1: Zoe compares two sources. Source A: the deed says Delaware leaders gave up their claim to the land. It presents the deal as final. Source B: the state history page reports Delaware complaints that the walkers did not “walk fair” and that the deal was a fraud. Zoe concludes: the deed shows the official result, while the complaints show why Delaware people rejected it.
Worked example 2: Tomas gives a useful critique. A panel says, “Settlers bought land from the Indians.” Tomas does not just say “bad.” He says: “Which nation? Who bought it? Your source says Delaware leaders were pressured. Could you write, ‘The Penn family’s agents used a disputed deed to take Delaware land’?”
Today’s critique: two stars and a fix. Visit another team’s panel. Name two strengths tied to our criteria. Offer one specific fix. Be kind to the people and tough on the evidence.
Use the reading first. Then use the same thinking during critique.
Use your critique notes.
Compare two sources or viewpoints on one event in your section. How are they different, and why?
Choose one suggestion you received. What will you change on your panel, and which criterion will it improve?
A fair exhibit does not hide disagreement. It helps visitors see why people saw events so differently.
Exit ticket: what makes the Walking Purchase an important story to tell in Pennsylvania?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 7, guided practice 9, gallery critique 12, revision notes 4.
Boundaries: do not reenact the walk or turn it into a race or game. Treat it as a serious land loss.
Likely misconceptions: that a signed paper proves fairness; that all Native nations acted as one group (the source shows Iroquois leaders and Delaware leaders in very different positions); that the Lenape disappeared. Delaware and Lenape nations continue today.
Supports: provide feedback stems: “Your evidence is strong because ___.” “Could you add ___?” Stretch: read the deed excerpt and identify words that make the claim sound final.
Answer guide: officials wanted clear title and more land to sell, and cited a deed. Delaware people did not know of the 1686 sale, objected to the walk, called the deal a fraud and refused to leave. Strong comparisons explain how position and goals shaped each view.
Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage, The Walking Purchase · Pennsylvania state agency page (archived); the 1737 deed is public domain; commentary retold in our own words
William Penn bought land from Native people before selling it to colonists. After he died in 1718, his sons and their official, James Logan, wanted the upper Delaware and Lehigh valleys. They showed Delaware (Lenape) leaders a deed, a land paper, and said Penn had bought the land in 1686. The leaders knew nothing of that sale. The state’s history page says it very likely never happened.
Pressured and without allies, Delaware leaders signed in 1737. The boundary would run as far as a man could walk in a day and a half. Logan hired fast walkers, and a path was cleared ahead of them. Delaware people who walked along left in disgust and complained that the men did not “walk fair.” The boundary was then drawn to take far more land than Delaware leaders expected.
The Delawares called the deal a fraud and refused to leave. In 1741, Pennsylvania officials had the Iroquois force them out. Most moved west. Their anger helped lead to later conflict.
“as far as a Man could walk in a day and half” Deed of August 25, 1737, as quoted by the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission
Source: Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage, The Walking Purchase (phmc.state.pa.us)