use our survey results to improve the guide one more time, or plan a survey of a new place.
Phase 5: Prove It
Good designs keep getting better. Look at your survey chart and your notes from Share Day.
Scientists change their plan after years of counting. Why?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Survey scientists, today you choose. Path 1: improve one more part of the guide. Path 2: plan a survey of a new place.
Use evidence. The treefrog scientists changed their plan because of what their counts showed. Your change should come from our survey chart or from Share Day feedback.
Path 1: Version 3. Find the weak spot. Sketch a fix. Tell how its shape or layout helps.
Worked example 1: Aria’s Version 3. On Survey Day, Aria’s team missed the pond bottom. She sketched a white card to hold behind the pond jar so tiny things on the bottom are easier to see. She labeled it: “White, so the bottom shows up.”
Path 2: a new place. Pick a third place, like a garden bed or a patch under a tree. Plan how to use the same ring and card there.
Worked example 2: Theo’s new place. Theo planned a survey of the patch under the big tree. He added a “look up” box, because birds and insects may be in the branches. He kept the same ring so the count stays fair.
| Path | What I will change or plan | Evidence for it | How the shape or layout helps |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Version 3 | |||
| 2 New place |
Pick your path. Then answer.
Explain your choice.
What evidence told you to make this change or try this place? Write one sentence.
Write how our guide is better now than Version 1. Name one thing that is good and one thing that is still not so good.
Unit 2 is done, survey scientists! Our guide can help our school compare life in many habitats.
Exit ticket: what is the most important thing you learned about comparing habitats?
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 7, mini lecture 6, path work 15, writing and exit 8 minutes.
Grouping: students who need review from 2.25 take Path 1 with teacher support; others choose freely. Path 2 can be done outdoors if staffing allows.
Misconceptions: “a new design is always better”; it is better only if evidence shows it meets a must-have better.
Supports: a half-sheet sketch frame with a label line.
Answer guide: evidence sentence names a result (“we missed the pond bottom”). Better-now answer names a feature added since Version 1 and an honest remaining weak spot.
Frontiers for Young Minds, Scientists Spy on Treefrogs Using Plastic Pipes in Trees · Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0)
Remember the treefrog pipes? The scientists checked 52 pipes every month for several years. Then, in 2018, they changed their plan.
They added a second place with pipes. That doubled the number of pipes. They checked both places every other month. They looked most in winter. Frogs used the pipes much more in winter than in summer. Two summer months had no frogs at all! One winter check found 80 frogs in under 4 hours.
Later, the scientists added more things to measure. They measured how warm it was inside each pipe and outside. They measured how deep the water was in a nearby pond or lake.
Why do frogs crawl in when it is cold? The scientists think the pipes hold in warmth. In warm weather, the frogs rest out on branches and leaves.
One kind of treefrog was so rare that it was not counted until 2018.
Source: Frontiers for Young Minds, Scientists Spy on Treefrogs Using Plastic Pipes in Trees (kids.frontiersin.org)