use our plant chart to explain whether plants need sunlight and water to grow.
Phase 3: Make Sense
The big reveal. Your teacher brings out all four plant groups. Line them up: 1, 2, 3, 4. Look at them quietly for one minute.
Which plant looks the most green and strong?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading our chart. We checked our plants many times. Now we look at all the checks together. We look for a pattern.
Compare one change at a time. First compare Group 1 and Group 2. The only difference was light. Then compare Group 1 and Group 3. The only difference was water. Last, look at Group 4, which had neither.
| Group | Day 1 | Last day | What we saw |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Sun and Water | 4 cubes, green | 7 cubes, green | Grew taller, stayed green and strong |
| 2 Water Only | 4 cubes, green | 7 cubes, pale yellow | Tall and thin, leaves pale and weak |
| 3 Sun Only | 4 cubes, green | 4 cubes, brown edges | Drooped and dried out |
| 4 Neither | 4 cubes, green | 4 cubes, yellow-brown | Drooped, pale and dry |
These are sample data. Use your own class chart.
Worked example 1: Yara compares light. Yara looked at Groups 1 and 2. “Group 2 got taller, but it turned pale and weak. Group 1 stayed green and strong. Without light, the plant did not grow well.”
Worked example 2: Cole compares water. Cole looked at Groups 1 and 3. “Group 3 drooped and dried out. Group 1 did not. Without water, the plant did not grow well.”
Our answer. Plants need both sunlight and water to grow well. The Sun and Water plant did best. We used our data to say so.
Use the class chart to answer.
Write your conclusion.
Finish: "Plants need ___ and ___ to grow. My evidence is ___." Use one group from our chart.
Draw Group 1 and Group 3 side by side. Label how they look different.
Our plants answered our big question. The garden club’s flowers will need sunlight and water in the bare corner. Next time we build a pollinator model.
Exit ticket: what should the garden club give the flowers in the bare corner? Use our evidence.
Materials: all four plant groups, the class plant chart, chart paper for the conclusion.
Pacing: 5 min reveal, 8 min reading, 12 min chart talk, 10 min guided practice, 5 min writing. Run at least 7 days after 1.04.
Real results vary: the dark plant often stretches tall and pale; the dry plant wilts. If a result is unclear, say so and compare with the sample chart; honest data matters more than a neat answer.
Listen for: “the dark plant won because it is tallest.” Return to color and strength. Keep comparisons one change at a time (assessment boundary).
Support / stretch: sentence frame on the board. Stretch: ask what might happen if Group 3 got water again tomorrow, then try it.
Answer guide: “Plants need sunlight and water. Group 3 had no water and it drooped, but Group 1 had water and stayed strong.”
NASA Science, Biological and Physical Sciences, Growing Plants in Space · NASA content; NASA material is generally not subject to U.S. copyright
NASA scientists run tests to learn how plants grow in hard places, like space.
Plants need food, water, air, light and room. NASA studies how to give plants these things far from Earth.
Their tests show that plants can grow in space. Plants still grow even when gravity and air are different there.
Scientists say more tests are needed. They want to try many kinds of plants.
NASA compares places to grow. On Earth, plants grow inside or outside. Bugs and weather can hurt them. On the Moon, plants would grow in closed rooms. On the space station, they grow in closed boxes with very little room.
What NASA learns can help astronauts grow their own food. It can also help people grow crops on Earth in places that are hard for plants.
Source: NASA Science, Biological and Physical Sciences, Growing Plants in Space (science.nasa.gov)