show what I know about comparing kinds of living things in different places and about designing, testing and improving a tool.
Phase 5: Prove It
Warm up your brain. Tell a partner one thing our survey showed and one way we improved our guide.
Different places can have different kinds of living things.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Survey scientists, this checkpoint shows what you know. Read each question twice. Use our charts and your notebook.
Big idea 1: kinds in places. Different places have different kinds of living things. We compare places by counting kinds in same-size patches.
Big idea 2: designing a tool. We named a problem. We sketched plans. We built a ring whose shape keeps patches the same.
Big idea 3: testing and improving. We tested two cards, put the data in a chart and found a pattern. Then we improved one part.
Worked example 1: a stream chart. Ruby’s sample chart: clean stream, 8 kinds of stream bugs; dirty stream, 3 kinds. She wrote, “The clean stream has more kinds.” These are sample numbers.
Worked example 2: a design choice. Ben compared two nets for looking at stream bugs, then letting them go. The wide net found 6 kinds. The small net found 3 kinds. He picked the wide net for finding kinds, but said the small net is easier to carry. These are sample numbers.
| Place (sample) | Kinds of living things |
|---|---|
| Clean stream | 8 |
| Dirty stream | 3 |
| Grass patch | 5 |
Part A: answer on your own.
Part B: draw and write.
Use our class chart. Write two sentences that compare the grass patch and the pond patch. Use numbers.
Draw one part of our guide. Label its shape. Tell how it helps. Then tell one change you would make next and why.
Checkpoint done! The next two lessons help everyone review and make our guide even better.
Exit ticket: circle the big idea that felt easiest. Star the one you want to practice.
Pacing: warm-up 3, reading 7, review 6, Part A 12, Part B 10, exit 2 minutes.
Use the results: sort students into flex groups for 2.26 (review: counting kinds, reading charts) and 2.27 (revise and extend).
Misconceptions: adding individuals; “the best design has no trade-offs”.
Supports: read items aloud. Accept labeled drawings and dictated answers in Part B.
Answer guide: chart sentences use both numbers and the word “more” or “fewer”. Drawing: “stiff, round ring keeps patches the same size”; next change backed by a reason from data or feedback.
Frontiers for Young Minds, The Wild and Wonderful World of Stream Bugs · Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0)
Streams are full of small animals with no backbone. Scientists call them invertebrates. Many of them are stream bugs.
Most stream invertebrates are water insects. Some are mayflies, stoneflies and caddisflies. Others are water striders, backswimmers and young dragonflies. There are also worms, snails, clams, crayfish and mites.
Most of them live among the rocks or in the mud at the bottom. Invertebrates live in almost every stream or lake on Earth. Some live in cold, clean water. Some live in warm, dirty water. Some even live in hot springs or in desert puddles that do not last.
Each kind needs its own kind of home. So the mix of kinds in a stream tells scientists how healthy the stream is. If a stream gets dirty or damaged, some kinds go away. Other kinds can stay. Scientists look at which kinds are there. This helps them find the problem and plan how to fix it.
Source: Frontiers for Young Minds, The Wild and Wonderful World of Stream Bugs (kids.frontiersin.org)