describe how we will test plants with sunlight and water, water only, sunlight only, or neither, and help plan which plants to use.
Phase 2: Investigate
Meet our plants. Your teacher shows a tray of young bean plants. They are all the same kind. They are all about the same size. Each one has two leaves.
Why should all our test plants be the same kind and size?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A plan comes first. Scientists plan a test before they start. A plan tells what we will do and what we will look for.
Our four plant groups.
One change at a time. We compare each group with Group 1. Group 2 is missing only light. Group 3 is missing only water. That way we know which change made the difference.
Keep the rest the same. Every plant is a bean plant. Every plant starts about the same size. Every pot has the same soil. Every room spot is about as warm.
Worked example 1: Ben’s plan. Ben wrote, “Group 2 gets water but no light. We will put it in a box with a lid.” He told what the plant gets and what it does not get.
Worked example 2: Rosa fixes a plan. Rosa saw a problem. One team wanted a tiny plant for Group 1 and a big plant for Group 3. Rosa said, “Let’s use plants that are the same size. Then the test is fair.”
What we will look for. We will check how tall each plant is, what color the leaves are, and if the plant stands up or droops.
Look at our four groups chart as you answer.
Draw our plan in your notebook.
Draw the four plant groups. Under each one, write what it gets: sun, water, both, or neither.
Write one way we will keep our test fair.
Our plan is ready. Next time we set up our plants and start our plant chart.
Exit ticket: Group 3 gets sun but no water. What will we learn by comparing it with Group 1?
Materials: one tray of bush bean seedlings, about one week old with two leaves (start them 7–10 days before this lesson), a four-groups chart, a cardboard box with a lid for the dark groups.
Pacing: 5 min plant look, 8 min reading, 12 min plan talk, 10 min guided practice, 5 min notebook.
Why seedlings: seeds sprout without light because they carry food inside, so starting from seeds can confuse the light test. Young plants show light and water needs within about a week.
Listen for: students wanting to change two things at once. Keep the boundary: compare each group with Group 1, one change at a time.
Support / stretch: act out the groups with picture cards. Stretch: ask what we would need to keep the same for temperature.
Answer guide: exit ticket: “We will learn if a plant needs water, because water is the only thing that is different.”
NASA eClips, Spotlite: Do Plants Need Soil? · NASA content; NASA material is generally not subject to U.S. copyright
What do plants really need to grow? A student made a short NASA video to find out.
Many people think plants can grow only in soil. Soil is the dirt that plants grow in. The student wanted to test that idea.
The test used simple things from home. The student used a cup and some cotton balls. There was no soil at all.
What happened? The seeds sprouted! To sprout means to start growing. So seeds can start to grow without soil.
The video tells what plants need to grow. They need water. They need light. They need air. They need nutrients, which are like vitamins for plants.
Soil can help a plant. It holds water and nutrients for the plant. But soil is not the only way a plant can start to grow.
NASA invites you to try the test yourself, to see how plants grow.
Source: NASA eClips, Spotlite: Do Plants Need Soil? (science.nasa.gov)