test Version A and Version B the same way 5 times each and record the results in a tally chart.
Phase 4: Build
Let’s be fair. Two runners race. One runs on flat grass. One runs up a hill. Is that a fair race?
How do we make our test fair?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Test day, plant helpers! A test tells us how well each version works. We collect data. Data are facts we count or see.
Our test rule. Each version gets 5 tries. Everything stays the same: the same Old Plant, the same New Garden circle two big steps away, the same 10 seeds or the same chalk flower. Only the version changes.
Seed Spreaders. Press the model on the Old Plant. Walk to the New Garden. Tap the model 3 times. Count the seeds that land inside the circle. Write the number. Put all 10 seeds back for the next try.
Pollen Carriers. Touch Flower 1. Then touch Flower 2. Look at Flower 2. Is there new color? Write a check if yes. Wipe Flower 2 clean for the next try.
Worked example 1: Grace’s seed test. Grace tested Version A. She wrote 3, 4, 2, 3, 3. She added them up: 15 seeds in all. She did the same for Version B.
Worked example 2: Luis’s pollen test. Luis tested his bee. Flower 2 got color on tries 1, 2, 4 and 5. He wrote 4 checks out of 5.
| Design | Try 1 | Try 2 | Try 3 | Try 4 | Try 5 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Version A | ||||||
| Version B |
Seed Spreaders write how many seeds landed in the New Garden circle. Pollen Carriers write a check if Flower 2 got colored pollen.
Run your test. Answer each check between tries.
Finish your tally chart.
Copy your team's tally chart neatly. Add the totals.
Draw a star next to anything strange that happened during a try, like a seed rolling away.
Great testing, plant helpers! Next time, we read our data and look for patterns.
Exit ticket: Which version got the bigger total? Write the two numbers.
Pacing: warm-up 3 min, reading 6 min, mini lecture 6 min, testing 20 min, chart 3 min, exit 2 min.
Setup: tape the Old Plant and New Garden spots on the floor so they do not move. Assign roles: Tester, Counter, Recorder, Reset. Pollen Carriers need a damp paper towel to wipe Flower 2 between tries.
Misconceptions: students may want to redo a “bad” try. Every try counts; that is honest data. Also watch for teams pressing harder with the version they like.
Supports: number lines for adding totals; a pre-filled chart with boxes. Students who finish early can test a third time with a partner team.
Answer guide: exit tickets give both totals and name the larger one, for example “A got 15, B got 22. B is bigger.”
NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory Education, Engineering Design Process Flow Chart · Courtesy NASA/JPL-Caltech; retold in our own words for classroom use, no text copied
Engineers at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory build robots and spacecraft. They solve problems with a plan called the engineering design process. Their chart shows the steps.
First, they find the problem. Next, they think of many ideas. This is called brainstorming. Then they pick one design to try.
After that, they build a model. A first model is called a prototype. Then comes a big step. They test it and look closely at how well it works.
What if the design does not work yet? The engineers do not quit. They go back. They build again and test again. They keep making the design better. The chart shows build, test and improve as a circle, because engineers go around it more than once.
When the design works, they share it with others.
We are doing the same steps. We found our problem. We sketched ideas. We built Version A and Version B. Today we test.
Source: NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory Education, Engineering Design Process Flow Chart (jpl.nasa.gov)