tell the must-haves and the limits of our survey guide, and sketch two plans for its tally card.
Phase 4: Build
Welcome to Build, survey scientists! Picture a small patch of grass and a small patch of pond. Both are full of life. Our school wants to know which one has more kinds of living things. Today we start building the tool that will tell us.
You count one patch and a friend counts a bigger patch. Is that fair?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Survey scientists, now we build. In our last lessons, you found that different places have different kinds of living things. Now we will design a survey guide. A survey guide is a tool that helps people look, count and write down what they find.
Our must-haves. In Make Sense we wrote our Must-Have List. Engineers call must-haves criteria. Here they are again. Must-have 1, Count kinds: the guide helps people count the kinds of living things, not just how many, inside the same-size hoop. Must-have 2, Land and water: it works for a land habitat and a water habitat. Must-have 3, Compare: it has a page to compare two places. Must-have 4, Easy for kids: young kids can use it, with pictures.
Our limits. Engineers call limits constraints. We use only things our school has: a hoop or a string circle, a timer, a clipboard and a tally chart. Every survey takes the same 10 minutes. We look, but we do not touch or take living things. That keeps people and animals safe.
Our guide plan. It has a safety page, a hoop page and a 10-minute timer step. Our hoop is the survey ring that marks one small patch. It has a tally card, where we mark each kind of living thing. It has a compare page that shows a land place and a water place side by side.
Worked example 1: Plan A, the Word List. Mateo’s plan is a list of words: grass, flower, ant, worm, bird. Next to each word is a line for tally marks. It is quick to make. But a word like “bug” can mean many kinds, and new kinds have no spot.
Worked example 2: Plan B, the Picture Card. Hana’s plan has small pictures in boxes. Each box has room for tally marks. At the bottom are empty “new kind” boxes. She can draw a new kind there. It takes longer to make. But readers who cannot read every word can still use it.
Engineers sketch two plans. Then they test both. Today you will sketch a word plan and a picture plan for your team’s tally card.
| Check | What it means | Yes or not yet |
|---|---|---|
| Must-have 1 Count kinds | We count kinds in one hoop | |
| Must-have 2 Land and water | It works in both habitats | |
| Must-have 3 Compare | A page compares two places | |
| Must-have 4 Easy for kids | Pictures help young kids use it | |
| Limits | School things, 10 minutes, look but do not touch |
Read each question with your partner. Pick the best answer.
Think about your two plans.
Write one sentence. What problem does our survey guide solve?
Circle the plan you like best. Write one reason. Use a must-have or a limit in your reason.
Great plans, survey scientists! Next time we design the survey ring and see how its shape helps it work.
Exit ticket: name two must-haves and one limit of our guide. Use a word or a picture for each.
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 7, mini lecture 9, checks 10, sketching and exit 10 minutes.
Misconceptions: students may count every ant instead of kinds. Say it often: we count kinds, not how many of each. Some think a bigger patch is “better”; the point is the same size every time.
Supports: post the four must-haves with icons: a hoop, a land and water picture, a bar chart and a picture card. Give a half-sheet frame with four empty boxes for each plan.
Answer guide: problem sentence: “Our school needs a tool to compare how many kinds of living things live in different places.” A strong reason names a must-have, such as “Plan B has new-kind boxes, so we can count every kind.”
Frontiers for Young Minds, A Recipe for Plant Diversity in Subarctic Alaska · Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0)
Some scientists study plants. They are called plant ecologists. They want to know how many kinds of plants grow in a very big park. The park is too big to check every spot. So they study small “bites” of land. Each bite is called a plot. A team can check one plot in a few hours.
The team lays tapes across the ground to mark the plot. Inside a circle, they look for plants. They keep a tally, or count, of every kind of plant they find.
They also write facts about the place. Is the land high or low? Is it steep? Which way does the land face? How warm is the soil?
Here is the big idea. The team measures every plot in the same way. That way, they can compare one plot with another. They can also come back in later years and measure again. The team has visited more than 1,000 places!
Source: Frontiers for Young Minds, A Recipe for Plant Diversity in Subarctic Alaska (kids.frontiersin.org)