test two tally cards on the same practice patch and record the results in a chart.
Phase 4: Build
Two tally cards, one patch. Today we find out which card helps us count better. To make it fair, both cards look at the same patch for the same time.
Which card do you think will find more kinds?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Survey scientists, today is test day. We have two tally cards: the Word List and the Picture Card. We will test both on the same practice patch.
The practice patch. It is a big picture of a grassy patch, with our ring drawn on it. Your teacher knows there are 8 kinds of living things inside the ring.
Keep it fair. Same patch. Same time: 3 minutes. One partner uses the Word List. Then switch. The other partner uses the Picture Card on a fresh copy.
What we measure. How many kinds did the card help you find? Did you know where to mark each kind? We write the answers in a chart.
Worked example 1: Jayden’s Word List. Jayden found 5 kinds. He saw a beetle, but the list only said “ant”. He did not know where to mark it. He wrote “5” in the chart. These are sample numbers.
Worked example 2: Sofia’s Picture Card. Sofia found 7 kinds. She drew the beetle in a “new kind” box. She wrote “7” in the chart. These are sample numbers, too.
| Card | Kinds found (out of 8) | Knew where to mark? (yes or no) | Time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Word List | 3 minutes | ||
| Picture Card | 3 minutes |
Run both tests. Then check your thinking.
Look at your chart.
Which card found more kinds for you? Write the two numbers.
Draw one living thing you were not sure where to mark. Tell how you marked it.
Great testing! Next time we look at the whole class chart and look for patterns.
Exit ticket: put a sticky dot on the class chart for the card that worked better for you.
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 7, mini lecture 7, two 3-minute tests plus setup 12, checks and exit 10 minutes.
Materials: copies of one large practice-patch picture with exactly 8 kinds inside a drawn ring (for example grass, dandelion, clover, ant, beetle, worm, snail, robin), Word List and Picture Card copies, a timer, a class chart.
Misconceptions: counting every ant as a new kind. Ask: “Is this a new kind, or another one of a kind you already marked?”
Supports: pair a strong reader with the Word List first. Read the list aloud for students who need it.
Answer guide: two numbers out of 8; most students find more kinds with the Picture Card because new kinds have a place to go.
Frontiers for Young Minds, Millions of Monarch Butterflies and the Quest to Count Them · Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0)
Monarchs are orange and black butterflies. Many monarchs fly a long way to spend the winter in a few forests. There, they hang on the trees in huge groups. The groups look like blankets over the trees! That makes them very hard to count.
Scientists use more than one way to learn about monarchs. In one way, people catch a monarch with a butterfly net. They put a tiny numbered sticker on it. Then they let it go. Anyone who sees a tagged monarch can report the number. This shows where each butterfly went. But it cannot tell how many monarchs there are in all.
In a newer way, scientists scan the trees with a laser. They scan once with no butterflies and once when the trees are covered. They compare the two scans to figure out how many butterflies there are. This new way gives a better count than the older ways.
Why count? Good numbers show if helping monarchs, like planting milkweed, is working.
Source: Frontiers for Young Minds, Millions of Monarch Butterflies and the Quest to Count Them (kids.frontiersin.org)