describe what our Seed-Spreader Model should be like and what it must do, using what we know about animals, seeds, pollen and materials.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Read our problem. Read the class problem statement on the wall together. Then look at a box of materials: felt, pipe cleaners, cotton balls, Velcro dots, cups, tape and paper.
Which material is most like the hooks on a burr?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Ask, then Imagine. We have asked questions and described our problem. Now we imagine what our Seed-Spreader should be like.
What it must do. Our model must move seeds or pollen the way an animal does. It must pick seeds up, carry them, and drop them in a new spot. It must be easy for garden club helpers to use.
What it should be like. It could copy an animal part. Fur or felt can carry burrs. A fuzzy body can carry pollen. A cup can carry seeds like a squirrel’s cheeks.
Worked example 1: Sam’s description. Sam wrote, “Our tool is a felt dog tail. Seeds with hooks stick to it. A helper drags it across the corner and seeds fall off.” He used science about fur and burrs.
Worked example 2: Zara checks her idea. Zara wanted a tool that drops seeds on the sidewalk. Then she remembered: plants need soil, sunlight and water to grow well. She changed it to drop seeds in the sunny soil of the corner.
Our must-do list. Our class list has four parts. One: Copy an Animal. It copies a real animal part, like fur, feathers, a fuzzy bee body or a long beak. Two: Pick Up, Carry, Drop. It picks up seeds or pollen, carries them and drops some in a new spot. Three: Easy to Use. A garden club helper can use it without trouble. Four: Show and Tell. We can point to the animal part and the plant part and tell how they work together. Our limits: only things from our class supply box, small enough to hold in one hand, and nothing near a mouth. Next part, you will plan, build and test your Seed-Spreader Model.
Help make our must-do list.
Imagine your Seed-Spreader.
Draw one idea for a Seed-Spreader Model. Label the animal part it copies and the materials you would use.
Write two things your Seed-Spreader must do.
We know the problem and what our tool must do. Next part, we plan, build and test our Seed-Spreader Models.
Exit ticket: which animal will your Seed-Spreader copy, and why?
Materials: a materials box (felt, fake fur, pipe cleaners, cotton balls, Velcro dots, paper cups, tape, paper), the class problem statement, chart paper for the must-do list.
Pacing: 5 min warm up, 8 min reading, 10 min mini lecture, 10 min guided practice, 7 min drawing.
Must-do list to aim for (use these exact names): 1 Copy an Animal; 2 Pick Up, Carry, Drop (seeds land where there is soil, sun and water); 3 Easy to Use (a garden club helper can use it); 4 Show and Tell (point to the animal part and the plant part). Limits: Class Box (class supply box only) and One Hand (small enough to hold in one hand); nothing near a mouth. Part 2 posts these on the Design Card as the criteria for testing and comparing designs (K-2-ETS1-2, K-2-ETS1-3).
Listen for: designs with no link to an animal, or seeds dropped where they cannot grow. Ask, “Which animal does it copy?” Do not build yet; building is in part 2.
Support / stretch: picture menu of animal parts and matching materials. Stretch: describe a tool that moves pollen instead of seeds.
Answer guide: “My Seed-Spreader copies a dog’s fur because hooked seeds stick to fur and drop off in a new place.”
NASA STEM Engagement, Explore to Flight: Educators Launch a Lunar Buggy Through the Engineering Design Process · NASA content; NASA material is generally not subject to U.S. copyright
NASA helps teachers learn the engineering design process. These are the steps engineers use to solve problems. The steps are Ask, Imagine, Plan, Create, Test, Improve and Share.
A group of teachers tried it themselves. Their challenge was to design and build a model moon buggy. A buggy is a small car. Theirs had to carry equipment and astronauts on the Moon.
Each person in a group had a job. The groups followed the design steps.
After the first three steps, one team member got the materials. The materials were things like plastic bottles, straws, wheels and rubber bands.
Then each group tested its buggy on a ramp. They made changes to make it work better. At the end, the groups shared what they learned.
The leader said young students love to ask questions and use their imagination first. One teacher said planning and building the buggy was an amazing experience.
Source: NASA STEM Engagement, Explore to Flight: Educators Launch a Lunar Buggy Through the Engineering Design Process (nasa.gov)