describe the problem our survey guide solves and what the guide must have to help people and living things.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Pretend you are a first grader. Your teacher hands you a hoop and a clipboard and says “Go survey!” and nothing else.
Would a first grader know what to do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Say the problem clearly. Our problem: classes at our school have no shared way to survey and compare habitats. So we cannot tell which places have more kinds.
Must-haves. A must-have is something the guide has to do. If it does not do it, the guide does not work.
Our Must-Have List. Must-have 1, Count kinds: the guide helps people count kinds, not just how many, inside the same-size hoop. Must-have 2, Land and water: it works for a land habitat and a water habitat. Must-have 3, Compare: it has a page to compare two places. Must-have 4, Easy for kids: young kids can use it, with pictures.
Our limits. We use only things our school has: a hoop or a string circle, a timer, a clipboard and a tally chart. Every survey takes the same 10 minutes. We look, but we do not touch or take living things, so people and animals stay safe.
Worked example 1: Mia’s must-have. Mia wrote, “The guide must show the hoop size, so every place is the same.” That uses what we learned about fair surveys.
Worked example 2: Owen’s must-have. Owen wrote, “The tally chart must have a picture box for each kind, so kids who can’t read every word can still use it.” That helps people.
Build our Must-Have List together. Then answer.
Fill in your Must-Have sheet.
Finish: “Our guide must help us count ____. It must work on land and in ____. It must have a page to ____ two places. It must be easy for ____ to use.” Then write one limit.
We know what our guide must do. Next time, we put our claim and our plan together.
Exit ticket: write our problem in one sentence.
Pacing (40 min): warm-up 4, reading 7, mini lecture 9, guided practice 11, Must-Have sheet 7, exit 2.
Materials: Must-Have List chart with four colored sections (1 Count kinds, 2 Land and water, 3 Compare, 4 Easy for kids) and a Limits box (school things only, same 10 minutes, look but do not touch); our fair-and-kind list from 2.12. Part 2 (2.15) restates this exact list as the design criteria.
Misconceptions: confusing must-haves with nice-to-haves (shiny cover). Keep the reading’s threats light; we do not assess extinction or invasive species.
Supports: must-have frames; picture icons for each section. Stretch: sort a list into must-have and nice-to-have.
Answer guide: problem: “Classes have no shared way to survey and compare habitats.” K-2-ETS1-1:4a: must-haves name counting kinds, land and water, a compare page and pictures for young readers; limits name school materials, the same 10 minutes and no-touch safety.
National Park Service, Biodiversity: The Web of Life · U.S. government work, public domain
Remember the painting made of dots? The Park Service page uses it to explain life on Earth. Let’s read more of the page.
The page says the kinds of living things are connected. They depend on each other. Together they make a web of life.
A web can break. If many kinds are lost, the whole picture can change. It is like taking many dots out of the painting.
The page names some things that can hurt the web. When a place is changed for other uses, living things can lose their homes. Kinds that are brought in from far away can push out the kinds that belong there.
Here is what our class thinks. You have to know what lives in a place before you can notice a change. So counting kinds is a good first step.
Our guide will help our school know the kinds that live in our schoolyard.
Source: National Park Service, Biodiversity: The Web of Life (nps.gov)