use our data to tell what is good and not so good about each version and choose the better one.
Phase 4: Build
Let’s be kind. A friend shows you a drawing. How can you help without hurting feelings?
Which is kind and helpful feedback?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Plant helpers, every design has good parts and weak parts. A strength is something that works well. A weakness is something that does not work well yet.
Use data to choose. Look at your totals and your pattern. The better design is the one that moved more seeds or pollen and still meets our Design Card.
Check the Design Card, too. A model might move lots of seeds but not copy an animal. Or it might be too big for one hand. It must meet the criteria and the limits.
Worked example 1: Zoe’s team. Version A, a feathered bird, got 14 seeds. Version B, a faux-fur fox, got 25. Strength of B: lots of fur to catch hooks. Weakness of B: some seeds stayed stuck and never dropped. Zoe’s team chose B and wrote one idea: tap harder at the New Garden.
Worked example 2: Marcus’s team. Their two bees tied, 4 checks each. Version A is a small pipe-cleaner bee. Version B is a cotton-ball bee that is too big to hold in one hand. Marcus says, “They both work. But A meets our One Hand limit. A is better for us.”
Kind critique. Visit another team. Say: “I like ____. I wonder ____. What if ____?”
Talk with your team. Then do a critique visit.
Choose and give feedback.
Write: We chose Version ____ because our data shows ____.
On a sticky note for another team, write: I like ____. I wonder ____.
You chose your best design. Next time, we meet real people who study seeds and pollinators.
Exit ticket: Write the best idea another team gave you.
Pacing: warm-up 3 min, reading 6 min, mini lecture 7 min, team talk 8 min, critique visits 10 min, writing 4 min, exit 2 min.
Setup: teams display both versions and their tally chart. Each student gets 2 sticky notes. Model one critique with a teacher-made model first.
Misconceptions: “the winner has no weaknesses.” Every design has trade-offs. Also, a tie is a real result; teams then choose by the Design Card.
Supports: post the critique frame with icons: a heart (I like), a question mark (I wonder), a light bulb (What if).
Answer guide: “We chose B because our data shows it moved 25 seeds and A moved 14. Weakness: some seeds stay stuck.”
NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory Education, Engineering Design Process Flow Chart · Courtesy NASA/JPL-Caltech; retold in our own words for classroom use, no text copied
Let’s look at the NASA engineering chart again. This time, look at the end of the steps.
Engineers do not build just one thing. They brainstorm many ideas. Then they select a design. Select means choose. They choose the design that seems best for the problem.
Next, they build it and test it. They evaluate the test. Evaluate means decide how good something is. Did it solve the problem? What worked? What did not?
If it did not work well enough, the chart says to go back. The engineers build and test again. The chart shows a loop for this part. Around and around, the design gets better each time.
When they reach a good solution, they share it with others.
Today we evaluate our two versions. We choose the better one. We give kind ideas to other teams. Those ideas help us loop back and make a Version 2 later.
Source: NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory Education, Engineering Design Process Flow Chart (jpl.nasa.gov)