read our tally chart, find a pattern and connect it to a feature of each version.
Phase 4: Build
Let’s look. Here is sample data from a pretend team. Version A: 2, 3, 2, 3, 2. Version B: 5, 6, 5, 6, 6.
What pattern do you see in the sample data?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Plant helpers, data can talk. But we have to listen. We look for a pattern. A pattern is something that happens again and again.
Step 1: Compare totals. Which version got the bigger total? That version moved more seeds or pollen.
Step 2: Look at every try. Did one version win every time? Or did they take turns? If one wins almost every try, that is a strong pattern.
Step 3: Connect to a feature. What was different about the winner? Was it bigger, fuzzier or longer? That feature may be the reason.
Worked example 1: Hana’s sample data. Version A, a small felt mitt, got 2, 3, 2, 3, 2. Total 12. Version B, a big felt mitt, got 5, 6, 5, 6, 6. Total 28. B won every try. Hana says, “The bigger fur patch caught more seeds.”
Worked example 2: Omar’s sample data. Omar’s short-beak bird got 2 checks out of 5. His long, fuzzy-tip beak got 5 out of 5. Omar says, “The long beak reached the pollen deep in the tube flower.”
Nature does this, too. In the reading, the nutcracker spreads seeds far and the squirrel does not. Scientists used a pattern to tell which helper the pine trees need.
Use your own tally chart and the sample data.
Tell what your data shows.
Finish this: Version ____ moved more because it had ____.
Draw a simple bar for each total: color one square for each seed or check.
You found patterns! Next time, we decide which design is best and give kind feedback.
Exit ticket: Name the feature that you think made the difference.
Pacing: warm-up 4 min, reading 7 min, mini lecture 8 min, guided practice 11 min, independent 8 min, exit 2 min.
Setup: post the sample data large and label it SAMPLE. Give each student square grid paper for the bar drawing.
Misconceptions: one high try does not make a pattern. Teach “look at every try.” If totals are close, it is fine to say “they worked about the same.” In the reading, students may think the bird plants trees on purpose; it buries food and some seeds are left.
Supports: pair a strong adder with each Recorder; a frame “___ is bigger than ___.”
Answer guide: “Version B moved more because it had more fuzz.” Accept “about the same” when the data shows it, with both totals.
National Park Service, Rocky Mountain National Park, The Pine Seed War · U.S. government work, public domain
High in the mountains, some pine trees make big seeds. The seeds have no wings. They cannot ride the wind. So how do they get to new places?
A bird called the Clark’s nutcracker helps. It eats pine seeds. It carries several seeds at once in a special pouch in its throat. Then it buries the seeds to eat later. It often buries them far from the tree.
Here is the important part. The bird eats only about one out of every three to five seeds it buries. The rest stay in the ground. Some of them sprout into new trees far away. The bird gets food. The tree gets new places to grow. Both are helped.
Red squirrels eat these seeds, too. But squirrels hide cones near the parent tree, and they bury them deep. Most of those seeds get eaten or ruined.
So scientists found a pattern. The bird spreads seeds far. The squirrel mostly does not. Scientists think these pines grew to fit the birds, which move their big seeds.
Source: National Park Service, Rocky Mountain National Park, The Pine Seed War (nps.gov)