find patterns in our test chart and tell what is good and not so good about each tally card.
Phase 4: Build
Look at our class chart. Each sticky dot is one scientist’s vote. Each number is one test.
What is a pattern?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Survey scientists, numbers can tell a story. The plant scientists compared 45 kinds and 11 kinds. The pattern told them where more kinds grow. Our chart can tell us which tally card works better.
Step 1: look across. Find each card’s numbers. Which card usually has the bigger number?
Step 2: look for why. Connect the card’s features to its results. A feature is a part of the design, like pictures or new-kind boxes.
Worked example 1: Ming reads the chart. Ming saw that 9 of 12 Picture Card tests found 7 or 8 kinds. Only 3 of 12 Word List tests did. She said, “The pattern is that the Picture Card finds more kinds. The new-kind boxes help.” These are sample numbers.
Worked example 2: Caleb finds a trade-off. Caleb noticed that the Word List was faster to make. It fits more words on one page. He said, “The Word List is good for making lots of copies. The Picture Card is good for counting every kind.” A trade-off means each design has a good side and a not-so-good side.
Choose the best for our must-haves. Must-have 1 is to count kinds. Must-have 4 is easy for kids. We pick the card that does those best.
| Card | Good about it | Not so good | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Word List | |||
| Picture Card |
Use the class chart to answer.
Write about the two cards.
Write the pattern you see in our chart in one sentence.
Which card will our guide use? Give one reason from the chart.
The data chose our card! Next time we build the land page and the water page of our guide.
Exit ticket: name one good thing and one not-so-good thing about the card we did NOT pick.
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 7, mini lecture 9, chart work and checks 12, writing and exit 8 minutes.
Misconceptions: one high score decides the winner. Point students to what happens most of the time. If the class data favor the Word List, accept that and ask why; the reasoning matters more than the winner.
Supports: color the chart: green for Picture Card, blue for Word List. Frame: “Most of the time, the ___ found more kinds.”
Answer guide: pattern sentence cites both cards; reason links a feature (new-kind boxes, pictures) to more kinds found.
Frontiers for Young Minds, A Recipe for Plant Diversity in Subarctic Alaska · Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0)
Remember the plant ecologists? They count the kinds of plants in many small plots. They measure each plot in the same way. So they can compare plots. When they compared, they found a pattern.
High up on open mountain land, the plots had the most kinds of plants. One high plot had 45 kinds of plants. One low plot had only 11 kinds.
Why? Up high, the soil is often young and rocky. Many tough plants grow well there. Wind and cold keep out big bushes and trees. That leaves room for many small, low plants. Slopes that face south warm up early in the year. So plants there have a longer time to grow.
Down low, the soil is often frozen and full of old plant matter. Fewer kinds of plants grow there.
The scientists see a change, too. Trees and bushes are moving higher up the mountains. They may crowd out the many small plants.
Source: Frontiers for Young Minds, A Recipe for Plant Diversity in Subarctic Alaska (kids.frontiersin.org)