use our questions, observations and readings to describe the problem the garden club wants to solve with a new tool.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Back to the start. Look at the sidewalk sunflower picture again. Look at our Wonder Board. Which questions can we answer now?
Which question can we answer now?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers start with the problem. Before we build, we must describe the problem clearly. Who needs help? What do they want to change? What do they hope will happen?
What we know now. Plants need sunlight and water. Animals move seeds by carrying, burying or dropping them. Animals move pollen when it sticks to their bodies. Finches and small animals eat sunflower seeds.
Worked example 1: Diego’s problem statement. Diego wrote, “The garden club needs a way to spread wildflower seeds across the bare corner, because there are too many seeds to plant by hand.” He told who, what and why.
Worked example 2: Hana adds what she learned. Hana added, “Animals spread seeds in nature. A tool that works like an animal could help the club.” She used our science to describe what kind of tool is needed.
Questions to ask the club. Good engineers ask questions. How big is the bare corner? Is it sunny? Does it get water? These answers matter, because plants need sunlight and water.
Our problem statement. Together, we will write one class problem statement and post it on the wall all unit.
Build our problem statement together.
Write your own problem statement.
Write a problem statement. Tell who needs help, what they need, and why.
Write one question you would ask the garden club before you design.
Our problem is clear. Next time we decide what our Seed-Spreader Model should be like and what it must do.
Exit ticket: what does the garden club hope will happen when the problem is solved?
Materials: sunflower picture, Wonder Board, plant chart, model gallery, sentence strips for the class problem statement.
Pacing: 5 min Wonder Board, 8 min reading, 10 min mini lecture, 10 min guided practice, 7 min writing.
Setup: if possible, have the garden club leader answer the students’ questions (size, sun, water of the bare corner) in a short note.
Listen for: problem statements that name a solution (“we need a robot squirrel”) instead of the need. Ask, “What is the problem before we pick a tool?”
Support / stretch: frame: “___ needs ___ because ___.” Stretch: add who else is helped (bees, birds).
Answer guide: exit ticket: “They hope the bare corner fills with wildflowers and bees and birds come to visit.”
USDA Forest Service, Celebrating Wildflowers, Plant of the Week: Common Sunflower · U.S. government work, public domain
The U.S. Forest Service tells us more about the common sunflower.
Sunflowers grow all across the lower 48 states. They probably first grew in the middle and south of the country and in Mexico. Now people grow them in much of the world.
After a sunflower blooms, its flower head makes seeds. The seeds grow in spirals. The spirals curl in two directions, like a swirl.
Many animals like sunflower seeds. Finches eat them. Finches are small birds. Small mammals eat the seeds, too. So do insects.
Bees and beetles visit sunflower flowers. Sometimes butterflies do.
In a good spot, a sunflower can seed itself. That means new sunflowers come up from its seeds without anyone planting them.
Sunflowers grow in open places, often where the soil is a little wet. They grow in fields, at the edges of forests and beside roads.
Source: USDA Forest Service, Celebrating Wildflowers, Plant of the Week: Common Sunflower (fs.usda.gov)