review how we tested whether plants need sunlight and water, and explain what our results showed.
Phase 5: Prove It
Let’s remember. Before we built models, we grew bean plants. Some got light and water. Some did not.
What did we want to find out with our bean plants?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Review time, plant helpers! Our unit has two big ideas. Plants need things to grow. And plants need animals to move seeds and pollen. Today we review the first idea.
Our question. Do plants need sunlight and water to grow? To find out, we planned a test with four cups of the same kind of bean plant.
Our plan. Group 1 got light and water. Group 2 got water but sat in a dark box. Group 3 got light but no water. Group 4 got no light and no water. Each cup with water got the same amount, at the same time. We used the same window for light.
Why the plan works. We change light or water and keep everything else the same. So if a plant does poorly, we know why. That is how our results answer the question.
Worked example 1: Jada’s sample record. After two weeks, Jada wrote: Group 1, tall and green. Group 2, thin, pale and floppy. Group 3, dry and droopy. Group 4, dry and droopy. She said, “Only Group 1 grew well. It had both light and water.”
Worked example 2: Ravi’s question. Ravi asked, “Group 2 grew a little. Does that mean plants do not need light?” His team looked again. Group 2 was pale and weak. A seed can start to grow with food stored inside it, but the plant needs light to keep growing well.
| Sample data | Light? | Water? | After 2 weeks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Group 1 | yes | yes | tall and green |
| Group 2 | no | yes | thin, pale, floppy |
| Group 3 | yes | no | dry and droopy |
| Group 4 | no | no | dry and droopy |
Use the sample data table to answer.
Show what you remember.
Draw the four sample cups. Under each, write what it got and how it looked.
Write: Our results show plants need ____ and ____ because ____.
Great reviewing! Next time, we make our models even better.
Exit ticket: If you did the test again, what would you keep the same in every cup?
Pacing: warm-up 3 min, reading 7 min, mini lecture 8 min, guided practice 10 min, drawing and writing 10 min, exit 2 min.
Setup: if part 1’s real bean cups are still in the room, put them out and use your class data instead of the sample. Label the table SAMPLE if you use ours.
Misconceptions: “plants eat soil” and “the dark plant grew, so light is not needed.” A seed has stored food for a short start; it still needs light to keep growing well. Keep to light and water; photosynthesis is outside the grade 2 boundary.
Supports: picture cards: sun, water drop, dark box. Stretch: ask why the space garden needs a pillow that controls water.
Answer guide: “Our results show plants need light and water because only the cup with both grew tall and green.” Exit: same plant, same cup, same soil, same amount of water, same window.
NASA, Growing Plants in Space · U.S. government work, public domain
Astronauts live on the space station for a long time. They want fresh food. So NASA built a small garden called Veggie. It is about the size of a suitcase. It usually holds six plants.
There is no sunshine inside the station. So Veggie has bright lights called LEDs above the plants. Plants use red and blue light more than green. That makes the garden glow pink!
In space, plants cannot tell which way is up. They use the light as a clue to know which way to grow.
Each plant grows in a soft “pillow” filled with a clay soil and plant food. The pillow gives the roots just the right amount of water and air. Without it, roots could drown or dry out.
Astronauts have grown lettuce, cabbage, kale and even zinnia flowers. Fresh plants help astronauts stay healthy. Growing plants also helps the crew feel happy.
Source: NASA, Growing Plants in Space (nasa.gov)