practice counting kinds of living things, organizing them in a chart and explaining the pattern.
Phase 5: Prove It
Sort it out! Here are picture cards: 3 frogs, 1 duck, 2 lily pads and 1 fish.
How many kinds are on the cards?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Survey scientists, today we practice. We will sharpen two skills: counting kinds and reading charts.
Skill 1: count kinds. Group living things that are alike. Each group is one kind. Three frogs are one kind. A frog and a toad are two kinds.
Skill 2: organize and compare. Write the number of kinds for each place in a chart. Then look: which number is bigger? That place has more kinds.
Worked example 1: Mia sorts a big pond. Mia’s sample list: 2 herons, 4 ducks, 1 kingfisher, many lily pads and cattails. She grouped them: heron, duck, kingfisher, lily pad, cattail. She wrote “5 kinds”.
Worked example 2: Sam compares. Sam’s sample chart: big pond, 5 kinds; small pond, 4 kinds. He wrote, “The big pond had 1 more kind than the small pond in this sample.” He used both numbers.
Remember the ring. Counts only compare fairly when the patches are the same size. The ring’s stiff, round shape makes that happen.
| Place (sample) | Kinds | More or fewer? |
|---|---|---|
| Big pond | 5 | |
| Small pond | 4 |
Sort and answer with your group.
Show you can do it.
Sort your picture cards into kinds. Write how many kinds you have.
Make a small chart for two places from your cards. Write one sentence that compares them.
You are sharp survey scientists! Next time we make one last improvement to our guide.
Exit ticket: tell what a good survey tool must do to compare two places fairly.
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 7, mini lecture 7, sorting and checks 12, independent 8, exit 2 minutes.
Grouping: students who mixed up kinds and individuals in 2.25 work with the teacher on picture-card sorts. Others can pair up to quiz each other.
Misconceptions: counting individuals; thinking bigger animals count more.
Supports: sorting mats with circles to group cards.
Answer guide: exit ticket: “It must count kinds in same-size patches and put the numbers in a chart.”
National Park Service, Pond Ecosystem · U.S. government work, public domain
Let’s visit the pond again. A pond is still, fresh water. Near the shore the water is shallow and light shines in, so many kinds of water plants can grow.
Some pond plants grow all the way under the water. They have thin, narrow leaves. Some plants float, like lily pads and duckweed. Their flat leaves soak up lots of sunlight. Some plants, like cattails, stand tall with their roots in the mud. Trees and bushes grow along the shore.
Pond plants are very important. They give fish food and places to hide. They make oxygen, a gas that animals in the water need. Their roots hold the soil in place.
Big ponds and small ponds can have different animals. Big ponds can have herons, ducks and kingfishers. Small ponds can have newts, toads, frogs and small fish. What lives in a pond depends on how warm and clean the water is, how much oxygen it has and what is on the bottom.
Source: National Park Service, Pond Ecosystem (nps.gov)