compare the kinds of living things found in a land habitat and a water habitat, and use our data to answer the puzzle.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Remember the puzzle. A grass patch and a pond patch. Which has more kinds? Look at your first-day drawing.
Was your first guess the same as our data?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Compare means look at both. We look at the grass kinds and the pond kinds side by side.
Compare the number. Which habitat had more kinds? Which had fewer?
Compare the kinds. Were any kinds in both places? Which kinds were only in one place?
Worked example 1: Ivy’s claim (sample data). Grass: 6 kinds. Pond: 9 kinds. Ivy said, “In our survey, the pond patch had more kinds. 9 is more than 6.” She used numbers as evidence.
Worked example 2: Jamal’s same and different (sample data). Jamal said, “Spiders were in both places. Snails and duckweed were only in the pond. Clover and ants were only in the grass.”
Claim and evidence. A claim is our answer. Evidence is the data that shows it. “I think ____ because our data shows ____.”
Be careful. Our claim is about the places we surveyed. Another grass patch or pond might be different. More surveys would tell us more.
Use our class chart. Talk with a partner, then answer.
Write your claim.
Finish these: “In our survey, the ____ had more kinds. Our data shows ____ kinds in the grass and ____ kinds in the pond.” Draw one kind from each place.
We answered our puzzle for our places. Next time, we look for patterns in more places.
Exit ticket: would another pond have the very same number of kinds? Why or why not?
Pacing (40 min): warm-up 3, reading 7, mini lecture 8, guided practice 12, claim writing 8, exit 2.
Materials: class chart and picture graph from 2.09; Venn diagram (grass / both / pond); sentence frames.
Misconceptions: “Ponds always have more kinds.” Our result is for our places and days. Use your real data; if the grass won, the claim flips. Do not teach why one place has more; just compare.
Supports: claim frame, number line for comparing. Stretch: Venn diagram of shared kinds.
Answer guide: exit tickets: “Probably not. Every place is different, and things change. We would need to survey it.”
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, What is a Wetland? · U.S. government work, public domain
Some places are not all land and not all water. They are wetlands. In a wetland, water covers the soil for all or part of the year.
The water changes the soil. It also changes which plants and animals can live there. Wetland plants are special. They can grow with their roots in wet soil.
Swamps, marshes and bogs are kinds of wetlands. Some wetlands are near the ocean. Some are along rivers, lakes and ponds. Some are small pools that fill with water in spring. Some animals lay eggs only in those pools.
The page says wetlands are home to both water living things and land living things. Wetlands are found on every continent except Antarctica.
So different places have different living things. A grass patch has land kinds. A pond has water kinds. The edge of a pond might have some of both! Today we compare our land data and our water data.
Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, What is a Wetland? (epa.gov)