try another team’s guide, give kind feedback, and improve one part of our own guide.
Phase 4: Build
Which feedback helps more? “Your guide is bad.” Or: “I wonder where I mark a spider.”
Which feedback helps a team make its guide better?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Survey scientists, today we test and improve. The NASA groups tested, then made the changes their test showed. We will do the same.
Step 1: try a guide. Your team tries another team’s guide on the practice patch. Use their ring, their tally card and their chart.
Step 2: give feedback. Use three starters: “I like…”, “I wonder…” and “What if…”. Name one part each time.
Step 3: improve one part. Pick the one change that helps a must-have the most. Change only that part. Then test again.
Worked example 1: Zoe’s feedback. “I like your pictures. I wonder where I mark a spider. What if you add a box for animals with eight legs?” Her feedback named one part and one fix.
Worked example 2: Omar’s Version 2. Omar’s team heard that testers forgot to look at the pond edge. They made the edge box bigger and colored it green. On the retest, testers found 2 more kinds at the edge. These are sample numbers.
| Feedback | Which part? | Which must-have does it help? | Our change |
|---|---|---|---|
| I like… | |||
| I wonder… | |||
| What if… |
Trade guides. Then answer.
Plan Version 2.
Write the one part your team will change. Tell which must-have it will help.
Draw your Version 2 part. Label how its new shape or layout helps.
Version 2 is ready! Next time we meet real scientists who survey living things.
Exit ticket: what is one idea you borrowed from another team?
Pacing: warm-up 3, reading 6, mini lecture 6, trade and test 10, feedback 6, revise 7, exit 2 minutes.
Misconceptions: feedback about people instead of the design; changing everything at once.
Supports: sentence-starter cards with icons. Pair teams in advance.
Answer guide: a strong plan names one part (edge box, new-kind boxes, ring picture) and one must-have it helps, such as must-have 1 “count kinds”.
NASA, Explore to Flight: Educators Launch a Lunar Buggy Through the Engineering Design Process · U.S. government work, public domain
Engineers solve problems by following steps. NASA calls these steps the engineering design process. The steps are Ask, Imagine, Plan, Create, Test, Improve and Share.
At one NASA workshop, teachers tried the steps. Their job was to build a buggy, a small car, for the Moon. The buggy was meant to carry equipment and astronauts.
First, each group worked together to ask, imagine and plan. Then one team member got the supplies. The supplies were things like plastic bottles, straws, wheels and rubber bands. The groups built their buggies.
Next, each group tested its buggy on a ramp. They wanted to find the ramp slope that made the buggy go the farthest. A slope is how steep something is.
Then the groups improved their buggies. They made the changes their test showed they needed. At the end, each group shared its results.
Source: NASA, Explore to Flight: Educators Launch a Lunar Buggy Through the Engineering Design Process (nasa.gov)