
explain how Reconstruction changed the balance of power among the president, Congress and the courts, and evaluate how its labor and relief policies affected the economic recovery of the South, using Missouri as a border-state comparison.
Instruction
The Civil War settled that the Union would hold and that slavery would end. It did not settle two harder questions, and this lesson takes both. The first is who decides how the defeated states return to the Union, which is a question about the balance of powers in the Constitution. The second is what kind of economy replaces one built on enslaved labor, which is a question about regions and about what a government’s goals actually did to them.
A struggle over power. Abraham Lincoln had planned a lenient peace: pardon for most Confederates who swore loyalty, and a new state government once a tenth of the voters of 1860 had taken the oath. When Andrew Johnson became president he tried to carry that plan out. Radical Republicans in Congress wanted military governments and stricter terms, and neither side would compromise, according to the National Park Service. Congress answered with its own tools. In 1866 it proposed the Fourteenth Amendment, which made everyone born or naturalized in the United States a citizen, forbade any state to deny due process or equal protection, reduced a state’s representation if it kept adult male citizens from voting, and in section 5 gave Congress the power to enforce the article by legislation. Then, on March 2, 1867, it passed the first Reconstruction Act. The act divided ten former Confederate states into five military districts and set the price of readmission: a new constitution written by delegates elected by men “of whatever race, color, or previous condition,” and ratification of the Fourteenth Amendment. Notice the shift. Under Lincoln’s plan the president decided; under the act, Congress decided, with the army as its enforcement arm.
Checks and balances in action. In the same year Congress passed the Tenure of Office Act over Johnson’s veto. It said a president could not dismiss officials the Senate had confirmed without the Senate’s consent. Johnson removed Secretary of War Edwin Stanton, an ally of the Radicals, in part to test the law in court. The House impeached him and the Senate tried him from March to May 1868. The vote was 35 to convict and 19 to acquit, one vote short of the two-thirds needed, so Johnson stayed in office. In 1926 the Supreme Court ruled all Tenure of Office Acts unconstitutional. Every branch took part: Congress overrode a veto, passed statutes and impeached; the president vetoed and tested a law; the Court had the last word, decades later. The result was a Congress stronger than at almost any other point in the century, a weakened president, and proof that impeachment is a real but narrow check.
Missouri’s version. Missouri was a border state, yet its 1865 convention abolished slavery by ordinance on January 11, 1865, with only four delegates voting no, three weeks before Congress proposed the Thirteenth Amendment. The Drake Constitution, adopted April 10, 1865, banned slavery without exception but also required an “Ironclad Oath” of loyalty from teachers, clergy, judges and others, and limited the vote to white Union men. Missouri ratified the Fourteenth Amendment on January 25, 1867, the 17th state to do so, and Black Missourians organized the Missouri Equal Rights League that October to press for education and voting rights. A state can lead the nation on one right and restrict another in the same year.
The economy. The economic goals of Reconstruction were to replace slave labor with contract labor, relieve hunger and restart cotton production. The Freedmen’s Bureau, created in the War Department on March 3, 1865, issued rations and clothing, ran hospitals and refugee camps, supervised labor contracts between planters and freedpeople, and helped set up schools. The National Archives notes that most of its work was done between June 1865 and December 1868, and that it was not abolished until 1872. The historian Jacqueline Jones describes the contracts it supervised: a worker signed for a year on January 1, the landowner settled the accounts on December 31, and the worker’s share of the crop was usually one-third. Federal officials hoped the contracts would protect workers and revive cotton. Jones argues they were too optimistic, because the landowner kept the books and could dismiss a worker and keep that worker’s share. Sharecropping trapped many families in debt; she adds that many landless white families were sharecroppers too, and that by 1930 white sharecropping households in the South outnumbered Black ones.
How to evaluate. To judge how Reconstruction’s goals affected the economic recovery and growth of a region, separate four things: the goal, the tool, the result in that region, and the evidence. Goal: free labor and a restored cotton economy. Tool: the Bureau and the annual contract. Result: cotton farming resumed, but under a system of debt and tenancy that left many families poor. Evidence: the contract terms and the Jones account. Be careful about what you can show. These sources do not give cotton output or incomes, so a claim about total recovery needs more data than this lesson supplies. Say what the evidence supports and what it does not.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Missouri standard: 9-12.AH.2.GS.A
In May 1868 the Senate voted 35 to 19 on the charge against President Johnson. What was the result?
Missouri standard: 9-12.AH.2.GS.A
Under the Reconstruction Act of 1867, the president alone decided when a former Confederate state could return to the Union.
Missouri standard: 9-12.AH.2.GS.A
The Tenure of Office Act was passed over Johnson’s , and in 1926 the Supreme ruled all such acts unconstitutional.
Missouri standard: 9-12.AH.2.EC.A
Which description fits a typical labor contract supervised by the Freedmen’s Bureau?
Missouri standard: 9-12.AH.2.EC.A
A historian argues that Reconstruction labor contracts fell short of their goal of protecting workers. Which evidence best supports that claim?
How confident are you that you can explain how Reconstruction shifted power among the branches and evaluate its effect on the economic recovery of the South?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- In what year did Congress pass the first Reconstruction Act, and into how many military districts did it divide the ten former Confederate states?
Check your answer
Answer: 1867 (March 2); five districts. - Put in order: Tenure of Office Act passed; Senate vote on removing Johnson; Fourteenth Amendment proposed; Supreme Court rules all Tenure of Office Acts unconstitutional.
Check your answer
Answer: Fourteenth Amendment proposed (1866); Tenure of Office Act passed (1867); Senate vote (May 1868); Supreme Court ruling (1926). - A Senate vote on conviction is 35 to 19. Is the two-thirds needed to convict met? Show the arithmetic.
Check your answer
Answer: No. There are 35 + 19 = 54 votes, two-thirds of 54 is 36, and 35 is one short.54 × 2 ÷ 3 = 36. - Name two functions of the Freedmen’s Bureau.
Check your answer
Answer: Any two: issuing rations and clothing; operating hospitals and refugee camps; supervising labor contracts; helping establish schools. - When did Missouri’s 1865 convention abolish slavery, and how many delegates voted no?
Check your answer
Answer: January 11, 1865; four.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Illustrative numbers: a family raises a crop worth $900 under a contract giving the worker one-third. Find the worker’s share, then what remains after a $350 debt for supplies.
Check your answer
Answer: The share is $300; $300 − $350 = −$50, so the family ends the year owing $50.900 ÷ 3 = 300. - Explain how the Reconstruction Act shifted power from the president to Congress. Cite what section 5 requires before a state is readmitted.
Check your answer
Answer: Under Lincoln’s plan the president set terms; under the act Congress set them. Section 5 requires a constitution written by delegates elected by men of every race, ratification of the Fourteenth Amendment and approval by Congress, with army officers enforcing the process. - Missouri’s Drake Constitution banned slavery without exception but limited the vote to white Union men. In one sentence, explain why it shows a state moving forward on one right and restricting another.
Check your answer
Answer: It ended slavery before the Thirteenth Amendment took effect, yet it required the Ironclad Oath and denied the vote to Black men and to former Confederates. - Name the part each branch played in the Johnson impeachment episode and the check it used.
Check your answer
Answer: Congress passed the Tenure of Office Act over a veto and impeached; the president vetoed and tested the law by removing Stanton; the Senate tried the case and fell one vote short; the Supreme Court ruled such acts unconstitutional in 1926.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- In 120-150 words, evaluate how Reconstruction’s labor policy affected the Southern economy. Name the goal, the tool, the result and the evidence, and say what the sources cannot show.
Check your answer
Answer: Model answer: the goal was free labor and restored cotton; the tool was the Bureau and the annual contract; the result was a system of tenancy and debt in which the landowner kept the accounts; the evidence is the contract terms and the Jones account. The sources do not give output or income, so a claim about total recovery needs more data.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Which amendment abolished slavery, and which defined citizenship and equal protection?
Check your answer
Answer: The Thirteenth abolished slavery; the Fourteenth defined citizenship and equal protection. - What is the difference between impeachment and conviction?
Check your answer
Answer: The House impeaches (brings the charge); the Senate tries the case and convicts only with a two-thirds vote.
Rebuilding the Government and the Economy: The Fourteenth Amendment, the Reconstruction Act, the Johnson Impeachment, the Freedmen’s Bureau and Missouri, 1865-1867
14th Amendment text, National Archives milestone document; Reconstruction Act of 2 March 1867, 14 Stat. 428 (Wikisource transcription); National Park Service, Andrew Johnson National Historic Site, “The Impeachment of Andrew Johnson”; National Archives, “The Freedmen’s Bureau”; Missouri State Archives, Timeline of Historic Missouri 1861-1869; Jacqueline Jones, “The Freedmen’s Bureau: Work After Emancipation,” Not Even Past (summarized in our words); all retrieved 9 Nov. 2026 · Public domain (U.S. government works and Missouri State Archives); Jones essay summarized in our words
Why this reading. The lesson asks you to judge two things at once: how Reconstruction rearranged the powers of the national government, and what it did to the economies of the regions it touched. Here are the texts to judge them with — the Fourteenth Amendment, the first Reconstruction Act, the National Park Service’s account of the Johnson impeachment, the National Archives on the Freedmen’s Bureau, and three entries from the Missouri State Archives timeline. What to look for: which branch is acting in each text, and who is left to act on the freedpeople’s behalf once the law has been passed.
1. The Fourteenth Amendment (Congress, 1866)
The National Archives dates the proposal to 1866 and ratification to 1868. Three sections are printed here exactly as the Archives transcribes them.
All persons born or naturalized in the United States,” thereby granting citizenship to formerly enslaved people. Another equally important provision was the statement that “nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
Representatives shall be apportioned among the several States according to their respective numbers, counting the whole number of persons in each State, excluding Indians not taxed. But when the right to vote at any election for the choice of electors for President and Vice-President of the United States, Representatives in Congress, the Executive and Judicial officers of a State, or the members of the Legislature thereof, is denied to any of the male inhabitants of such State, being twenty-one years of age, and citizens of the United States, or in any way abridged, except for participation in rebellion, or other crime, the basis of representation therein shall be reduced in the proportion which the number of such male citizens shall bear to the whole number of male citizens twenty-one years of age in such State.
The Congress shall have power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article.
2. The Reconstruction Act of March 2, 1867
The act is printed in the Statutes at Large, volume 14, page 428. This transcription is the public-domain text of the statute as reproduced on Wikisource; check any phrase you plan to quote against the volume. Section 1 and part of section 5 follow.
That said rebel States shall be divided into military districts and made subject to the military authority of the United States as hereinafter prescribed, and for that purpose Virginia shall constitute the first district; North Carolina and South Carolina the second district; Georgia, Alabama and Florida the third district; Mississippi and Arkansas the fourth district; and Louisiana and Texas the fifth district.
That when the people of any one of said rebel States shall have formed a constitution of government in conformity with the Constitution of the United States in all respects, framed by a convention of delegates elected by the male citizens of said State, twenty-one years old and upward, of whatever race, color, or previous condition, who have been resident in said State for one year previous to the day of such election, except such as may be disfranchised for participation in the rebellion or for felony at common law, and when such constitution shall provide that the elective franchise shall be enjoyed by all such persons as have the qualifications herein stated for electors of delegates, and when such constitution shall be ratified by a majority of the persons voting on the question of ratification who are qualified as electors for delegates, and when such constitution shall have been submitted to Congress for examination and approval, and Congress shall have approved the same, and when said State, by a vote of its legislature elected under said constitution, shall have adopted the amendment to the Constitution of the United States, proposed by the Thirty-ninth Congress, and known as article fourteen, and when such article shall have become a part of the Constitution of the United States, said State shall be declared entitled to representation in Congress
3. A president, a statute and a trial
The National Park Service’s Andrew Johnson National Historic Site summarizes the struggle. Three sentences, exactly:
The Tenure of Office Act had been passed over Johnson’s veto in 1867 and stated that a President could not dismiss appointed officials without the consent of Congress.
In May, the Senate voted to acquit Andrew Johnson by a margin of 35 guilty to 19 not guilty – one vote short of the two-thirds needed to convict.
In 1926 the Supreme Court ruled all Tenure of Office Acts unconstitutional.
4. The Freedmen’s Bureau (National Archives)
The Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, and Abandoned Lands (Record Group 105), also known as the Freedmen’s Bureau, was established in the War Department by an act of Congress on March 3, 1865.
Bureau functions included issuing rations and clothing, operating hospitals and refugee camps, and supervising labor contracts between planters and freedpeople.
Although the Bureau was not abolished until 1872, the bulk of its work was conducted from June 1865 to December 1868. While a major part of the Bureau’s early activities included the supervision of abandoned and confiscated property, its mission was to provide relief and help formerly enslaved people become self-sufficient.
The Archives also lists a set of Freedmen’s Bureau field-office records for Missouri (microfilm publication M1908), so Missouri had its own Bureau files.
5. What the contracts looked like (a historian’s summary)
The historian Jacqueline Jones describes the labor contracts the Bureau supervised in an essay for the University of Texas history journal Not Even Past. In our words: a worker typically signed an agreement on January 1 for the whole year; on December 31 the landowner “reckoned” the account, subtracting what the worker owed for credit and supplies from the worker’s share of the crop, which was usually one-third. Federal officials expected these contracts to restart cotton production and protect the freedpeople from abuse. Jones argues that they were too optimistic, because the contract left the landowner in control of the accounts; in the South Carolina contract of January 1, 1868 that she prints, the planter kept the right to dismiss a worker and keep that worker’s share. She adds that many landless white families also became sharecroppers, and that by 1930 white sharecropping households in the South outnumbered Black ones.
6. Missouri entries from the State Archives timeline
Elected in the November 1864 election, delegates to the 1865 Constitutional Convention in St. Louis passed an ordinance abolishing slavery in Missouri on January 11, 1865 with only four delegates voting against it.
second Constitution known as the “Drake Constitution” was adopted on April 10, 1865. This Constitution banned enslavement without exception and limited the rights of former Confederates and Confederate sympathizers. One of the new provisions known as the “Ironclad Oath” required teachers, clergy, judges, and others to promise they had not committed “disloyal acts.” If not, the Constitution also forced removal of judges, court clerks and recorders, and sheriffs from their positions and the right to vote was restricted to only white Union men.
Missouri was the 17th state to ratify the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution addressing universal citizenship rights and equal protection under the law on January 25, 1867. The amendment went into effect on July 9, 1868.
Black Missouri leaders organized the Missouri Equal Rights League in October 1865. Considered Missouri’s first Black political activist organization, League members fought for legal equality, placing emphasis on education and voting.
Questions
- For each of the texts in sections 1, 2 and 3, name the branch of the national government that acts and the branch or level of government it limits.
- Section 5 of the Reconstruction Act ties readmission to the Fourteenth Amendment. Whose power over the former Confederate states grew, and whose shrank?
- Use sections 4 and 5 to write one goal of Reconstruction’s labor policy and one outcome that fell short of it. What further evidence would you need to say the shortfall slowed the region’s recovery?
- Missouri was a border state that abolished slavery by its own convention. List one way its choices in 1865-1867 matched the national program and one way they limited citizens’ rights.
Sources: 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, National Archives (archives.gov); Reconstruction Acts (transcription of 14 Stat. 428 and later acts), Wikisource (en.wikisource.org); The Impeachment of Andrew Johnson, National Park Service (nps.gov); The Freedmen’s Bureau, National Archives (archives.gov); Timeline of Historic Missouri: 1861-1869, Missouri State Archives (sos.mo.gov); Jacqueline Jones, The Freedmen’s Bureau: Work After Emancipation, Not Even Past (notevenpast.org)