THE VR SCHOOL
  • Schools & Districts
    • License the academy
    • Free program for your students
    • Request a demo
  • Catalog
    • AI & Data
    • Cybersecurity & Web
    • Programming
    • Health Science
    • All Guilds
    • All courses
  • Families
  • Accreditation
  • Log In
  • Request a demo
  • Home
  • Courses

RLP English 10A — Justice, Conscience and the Law

Curriculum

  • 4 Sections
  • 27 Lessons
  • Lifetime
Expand all sectionsCollapse all sections
  • Unit 1: Law and Conscience — Antigone
    8
    • 1.1
      The Shape of Tragedy — How Antigone Is Built
      50 mins
    • 1.2
      Creon’s Edict and “Wonders Are Many”: The First Episode and First Stasimon
      45 mins
    • 1.3
      Language Lab — The Balanced Sentence: Semicolons, Colons and Antithesis
      45 mins
    • 1.4
      Antigone Before Creon: The Second Episode
      45 mins
    • 1.5
      Seminar — Antigone or Creon: Whose Claim Is Stronger?
      50 mins
    • 1.6
      Writing Workshop — From Opinion to Arguable Thesis
      50 mins
    • 1.7
      Antigone’s Last Journey and Teiresias’s Warning
      45 mins
    • 1.8
      Key Assignment — Tragic Structure Analytical Essay
      150 mins
  • Unit 2: Creation and Responsibility — Frankenstein
    9
    • 2.1
      Three Narrators, One Story — Word Choice and the Nested Frame
      50 mins
    • 2.2
      Education and Ambition: Victor’s Path to the Creation
      45 mins
    • 2.3
      Language Lab — Point of View Beyond the United States: Shelley’s Europe
      45 mins
    • 2.4
      William, Justine, and the Failure of Justice
      45 mins
    • 2.5
      The Creature’s First World: Awakening and the De Laceys
      45 mins
    • 2.6
      Structured Disagreement — Who Is Responsible?
      50 mins
    • 2.7
      The Broken Promise: The Second Creature and Clerval
      45 mins
    • 2.8
      Writing Workshop — The Counterclaim With Its Own Evidence
      50 mins
    • 2.9
      Key Assignment — Responsibility Argument Essay
      150 mins
  • Unit 3: The Rhetoric of Resistance
    5
    • 3.1
      Thoreau and the Duty to Disobey — Purpose, Audience and Rhetoric
      50 mins
    • 3.2
      Language Lab — Borrowed Structure: The Declaration of Sentiments
      45 mins
    • 3.3
      Listening Lab — Anthony and Pankhurst: Evaluating Two Speakers
      50 mins
    • 3.4
      Writing Workshop — The Four-Sentence Rhetorical Precis
      50 mins
    • 3.5
      Key Assignment — Rhetorical Analysis and Audience Rewrite
      150 mins
  • Unit 4: Synthesis — Conscience, Creation and Their Sources
    5
    • 4.1
      The Modern Prometheus — How Shelley Transforms Her Sources
      50 mins
    • 4.2
      Research Lab — Finding, Assessing and Citing Sources
      50 mins
    • 4.3
      Media Lab — The Novel and the 1910 Film
      50 mins
    • 4.4
      Writing Workshop — Synthesis as Braiding
      50 mins
    • 4.5
      Key Assignment — Semester Research Paper and Digital Presentation
      200 mins

Writing Workshop — The Counterclaim With Its Own Evidence

Unit 2  ·  Recursive Writing Workshop  ·  Lesson 16 of 27

Writing Workshop — The Counterclaim With Its Own Evidence

9-10.W.2.ARLP-ENG10A
A balance scale holds evidence for abandonment and deliberate choice while a blank rebuttal sheet connects them.
By the end of this lesson I can…

introduce a precise claim that distinguishes itself from alternate claims, develop a counterclaim fairly with its own supporting evidence before answering it, and use transitions that make the relationships between claim, counterclaim and rebuttal clear.

Instruction

In English 9 you learned to acknowledge a counterclaim. In English 10 the bar rises: 9-10.W.2.A asks you to develop claims and counterclaims fairly, supplying evidence for each, while pointing out the strengths and limitations of both. A counterclaim with no evidence is a straw man. This workshop builds the real thing.

Step 1 — A precise claim (9-10.W.2.A). “Victor is responsible” is too broad to argue well. Precision comes from naming the mechanism: Victor’s responsibility lies less in creating life than in abandoning it; the novel’s deaths trace to three failures of care — at the creation, at Justine’s trial and at the promise of a companion. That claim tells the reader exactly what you will prove and in what order.

Step 2 — Distinguish it from alternate claims. In your introduction, name the other positions and say briefly how yours differs: Some readers blame the creature’s free choices; others blame a society that answers difference with violence. This essay argues that both are downstream of Victor’s first abandonment. This shows you know the debate.

Step 3 — Build the counterclaim at full strength. Choose the opposing argument a thoughtful reader would most likely make. Write it as its holder would: with a clear statement and at least one quotation that genuinely supports it. For the claim above, the strongest counterclaim is the creature’s own choices: his murder of William, his deliberate framing of Justine, and his vow of revenge after Victor destroys the female — free, deliberate acts. Quote them.

Step 4 — Answer it, don’t dismiss it. There are three honest ways. Refute: show the evidence is weaker or misread. Concede and outweigh: grant the point, then argue your evidence matters more. Concede and qualify: grant the point and narrow your claim to fit. Qualifying often produces the most convincing essays.

Step 5 — Name strengths and limitations of both. A sentence like “This reading cannot fully account for the creature’s pleasure in revenge” does not weaken your essay; it shows the reader you have seen the whole text.

Step 6 — Transitions that show the argument’s shape (9-10.W.3.A.d). 9-10.W.3.A.d asks you to use words, phrases and clauses to link the major sections of your essay and to clarify the relationships between claim and reasons, between reasons and evidence, and between claim and counterclaims. In a counterclaim paragraph the reader must always know whose argument they are reading, so mark every turn. From your claim to the opposing view: “The strongest case against this reading is…” or “A reader who blames the creature would point out that…” From the counterclaim to its evidence: “In support, the creature himself says…” From the counterclaim to your answer: “Even so,” “Granting this point,” “This objection has force; however,” From your answer back to your claim: “The evidence therefore points back to…” Avoid “Also” and “Another thing” at these joints: they add, but they do not say how one idea relates to the next. Wollstonecraft’s “This objection has, I grant, some force; but” is a map of the whole move in nine words: concession, then answer.

Evidence from all three narrators. Because the essay is about responsibility in a story told by people with stakes, you must use evidence from Walton, Victor and the creature, and at least once comment on how a narrator’s position affects the evidence (9-10.RL.1.A).

Revision (9-10.W.3.A). Draft the counterclaim paragraph today, underline the transition at each turn, and give it to a classmate who holds that position. If they would not sign it as their own argument, revise it until they would.

📖 Before this lesson, read: Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters through Volume 3, Chapter 4

The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.

  • Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters through Volume 3, Chapter 4Homer, The Odyssey, tr. Samuel Butler (1900); Robert Louis Stevenson, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1886)

Reading: Mentor passage, model counterclaim and criteria

Mary Shelley, Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (London: Lackington, Hughes, Harding, Mavor and Jones, 1818, three volumes), Project Gutenberg eBook 41445 (text from a photo-reprint of the 1818 edition), retrieved 2026-09-26; Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792), Project Gutenberg eBook 3420 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/3420) · SLS original framing, tables, models and keys; quoted passages are public domain (Shelley, 1818; Wollstonecraft, 1792)

Read the mentor for the three moves: state, concede, answer. Then study how the transitions mark each move.

What is hosted. A mentor passage in which a public-domain author states an opposing view and answers it, a model claim and counterclaim, a before-and-after revision, a guide to the transitions that link claim, counterclaim and rebuttal, and the criteria Stage 1 is scored against. Every passage from the novel comes from the part you have read, the Letters through Volume III, Chapter 4. Sources: Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792), Project Gutenberg eBook 3420; Mary Shelley, Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (London: Lackington, Hughes, Harding, Mavor and Jones, 1818, three volumes), Project Gutenberg eBook 41445 (text from a photo-reprint of the 1818 edition), retrieved 2026-09-26. Retrieved 2026-09-26. Models, revisions and criteria are SLS original.

Edition and references. Every passage from Frankenstein is from the 1818 first edition, in three volumes, and keeps its spelling and punctuation (for example “dæmon” and “Werter”). Passages are located by volume and chapter of that edition. The 1818 chapters restart in each volume (Vol. I has Chapters I–VII, Vol. II has I–IX, Vol. III has I–VII), so a Vol. II, Ch. II passage is not the same as Ch. II of a modern one-volume edition. Later editions (1831 and after) renumber chapters 1–24 and change some wording; if your copy differs, use the volume and chapter here to find the passage.

1. A mentor: an objection stated at full strength, then answered

Read for the moves: Wollstonecraft states the objection to her own view, concedes that it has force, and then answers it by widening the frame.

Wollstonecraft, Vindication (1792), Chapter 2

I foresee an obvious retort; whilst man remains such an imperfect being as he appears hitherto to have been, he will, more or less, be the slave of his appetites; and those women obtaining most power who gratify a predominant one, the sex is degraded by a physical, if not by a moral necessity. This objection has, I grant, some force; but while such a sublime precept exists, as, “be pure as your heavenly father is pure;” it would seem that the virtues of man are not limited by the Being who alone could limit them; and that he may press forward without considering whether he steps out of his sphere by indulging such a noble ambition. To the wild billows it has been said, “thus far shalt thou go, and no further; and here shall thy proud waves be stayed.” Vainly then do they beat and foam, restrained by the power that confines the struggling planets within their orbits, matter yields to the great governing Spirit. But an immortal soul, not restrained by mechanical laws, and struggling to free itself from the shackles of matter, contributes to, instead of disturbing, the order of creation,

Annotation (SLS original). Counterclaim: men are creatures of appetite, and women who satisfy them gain power. Concession: “This objection has, I grant, some force.” Answer: by concede-and-outweigh: the objection ignores that human virtue is not limited by appetite. Notice she does not call the objection foolish.

2. Evidence for a counterclaim, from the creature’s own mouth

If your claim is that Victor is primarily responsible, the strongest counterclaim is that the creature acts freely. These passages are the counterclaim’s evidence.

The creature over William’s body (Vol. II, Ch. VIII)

I gazed on my victim, and my heart swelled with exultation and hellish triumph: clapping my hands, I exclaimed, ‘I, too, can create desolation; my enemy is not impregnable; this death will carry despair to him, and a thousand other miseries shall torment and destroy him.

The creature to Victor, after the female is destroyed (Vol. III, Ch. III)

Slave, I before reasoned with you, but you have proved yourself unworthy of my condescension. Remember that I have power; you believe yourself miserable, but I can make you so wretched that the light of day will be hateful to you. You are my creator, but I am your master;—obey!

You can blast my other passions; but revenge remains—revenge, henceforth dearer than light or food!

The creature to Victor, threatening him (Vol. II, Ch. IX)

I am malicious because I am miserable; am I not shunned and hated by all mankind? You, my creator, would tear me to pieces, and triumph; remember that, and tell me why I should pity man more than he pities me? You would not call it murder, if you could precipitate me into one of those ice-rifts, and destroy my frame, the work of your own hands. Shall I respect man, when he contemns me? Let him live with me in the interchange of kindness, and, instead of injury, I would bestow every benefit upon him with tears of gratitude at his acceptance. But that cannot be; the human senses are insurmountable barriers to our union. Yet mine shall not be the submission of abject slavery. I will revenge my injuries: if I cannot inspire love, I will cause fear; and chiefly towards you my arch-enemy, because my creator, do I swear inextinguishable hatred. Have a care: I will work at your destruction, nor finish until I desolate your heart, so that you curse the hour of your birth.

3. A precise claim and its alternates (SLS original model)

Too broad: Victor is responsible for the deaths.

Precise: Victor’s responsibility lies less in creating life than in abandoning it; the novel’s deaths trace to three failures of care: at the creation, at Justine’s trial and over the promise of a companion.

Alternate claims it is distinguished from: some readers blame the creature’s free choices; others blame a society that answers difference with violence. This essay argues that both are downstream of Victor’s first abandonment.

4. A counterclaim paragraph with its own evidence, and the answer (SLS original model)

The strongest case against my claim is the creature’s own. He does not present his killing of William as an accident: over the child’s body he exclaims, “I, too, can create desolation” (Shelley, Vol. II, Ch. VIII), which sounds like a choice made in full knowledge. In support, his warning to Victor, “I am malicious because I am miserable” (Vol. II, Ch. IX), is a decision announced in advance, and after the female is destroyed he calls revenge “dearer than light or food” (Vol. III, Ch. III). A reader who holds this view can fairly say that misery does not explain everything, since Felix and his family are also ruined by injustice and do not kill. Granting this point, I concede that the creature chooses, and I narrow my claim to what Victor is answerable for: the conditions in which a free choice was made and a promise was broken. Even so, this reading cannot fully account for the creature’s pleasure in revenge, which suggests some responsibility that is his alone.

The underlined words are the transitions; section 6 explains the job each one does. Check on the quotations in that model: each is in the 1818 text at the volume and chapter given.

5. Before and after (SLS original)

Before. Some people say the creature is to blame because he killed people. But he had no choice.

After. The most serious case against my claim is that the creature acts freely. Over William’s body, he says, his heart “swelled with exultation and hellish triumph”; a reader who takes that at face value has to conclude that he chose. Even so, I answer by conceding the choice and narrowing my claim: Victor is answerable for the abandonment that shaped the choice, not for the choice itself.

What changed: the counterclaim is stated as its holder would state it, with a quotation; it is answered by concession and qualification, not dismissed; the transitions (“The most serious case against,” “Even so”) tell the reader where the opposing view ends and the answer begins; and the last sentence names a limit of my own claim.

6. Transitions that carry the argument (SLS original)

A counterclaim paragraph has four joints. At each one, choose a transition that names the relationship, not just the order.

JointWhat the reader needs to knowTransitions that do the job
Claim → counterclaimAn opposing view is starting, and it is not yours.The strongest case against this reading is… / A reader who blames the creature would argue that… / On the other side,
Counterclaim → its evidenceThe quotation supports the opposing view.In support, … / That reader can point to… / The creature himself says…
Counterclaim → rebuttalYou are about to concede, refute or qualify.Even so, / Granting this point, / This objection has force; however, / Yet this reading overlooks…
Rebuttal → claimThe answer brings the reader back to your thesis.The evidence therefore points back to… / In other words, / For this reason,

Weak joints to revise. “Also,” “Another thing,” and “Next” tell the reader only that more is coming. “But” on its own can signal a turn, but it does not say whether you are conceding or refuting. Wollstonecraft’s mentor sentence shows the stronger pattern: “This objection has, I grant, some force; but” concedes first and then announces the answer.

7. Criteria for Stage 1 (SLS original)

  1. Claim: precise (it names a mechanism), contestable, distinguished from two alternate claims.
  2. Counterclaim: stated fairly, with at least one supporting quotation, in words its holder would sign.
  3. Answer: refute, concede-and-outweigh or concede-and-qualify; strengths and limitations of both sides named.
  4. Evidence: at least once each from Walton, Victor and the creature; at least once a comment on how a narrator’s position affects the evidence.
  5. Transitions: each of the four joints in the counterclaim paragraph is marked by a transition that names the relationship (underline them).

Vocabulary in context

  • alternate claim — A different position on the same question, which a precise claim distinguishes itself from.
  • straw man — A weak version of an opposing argument set up only to be knocked down.
  • concession — Granting that part of an opposing argument is valid.
  • refutation — Showing that an opposing argument’s evidence or reasoning fails.
  • mechanism — The specific process by which a cause produces an effect.
  • transition — A word, phrase or clause that shows how one idea relates to the next, for example a turn from a counterclaim to the writer’s answer.

Formative check

Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.

+50 XP

What makes a counterclaim meet 9-10.W.2.A?

Evidence for each side, fairly presented, with strengths and limitations named.
Myth or Fact?

Naming alternate claims in your introduction weakens your argument.

Myth. Distinguishing your claim from others shows command of the debate and sharpens your position.
+50 XP

Which transition best signals the turn from a counterclaim to the writer’s answer?

It concedes the point and announces that an answer is coming. “Also” only adds; it hides the relationship.

Submit Stage 1: your precise claim, two alternate claims you distinguish it from, a full counterclaim paragraph with at least one supporting quotation, and your answer to it (refute, concede-and-outweigh, or concede-and-qualify). Underline the transition at each turn: claim to counterclaim, counterclaim to evidence, counterclaim to answer, and answer back to claim. Include evidence from all three narrators in your plan.

0 words
Quick self-check

How confident are you that you can write a counterclaim its holder would accept, supported with evidence, and answer it honestly?

Not yetVery confident

Missouri Learning Standards addressed in this lesson: 9-10.W.2.A, 9-10.W.3.A.d, 9-10.W.3.A, 9-10.RL.1.A

Instructional focus: Recursive argumentative writing

Reading

Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters through Volume 3, Chapter 4

Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, Letters through Volume 3, Chapter 4 so far Bridge summary — not the primary text

A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.

Walton’s letters frame the story of Victor Frankenstein, whose ambition leads him to create a living being and abandon it the night it wakes (Letters through Volume 1, Chapter 4). The creature strangles Victor’s young brother William, and Justine Moritz is tried, condemned on circumstantial evidence and executed while Victor, who knows the truth, stays silent (Volume 1, Chapters 5-7). On the glacier the creature tells his own story: rejected by every human he meets, he educates himself by secretly watching the De Lacey family, is driven off when he reveals himself, kills William, and demands that Victor make him a companion, and Victor agrees (Volume 2). Victor travels to Britain with Clerval, begins the female creature on a remote Orkney island, then destroys it in front of the creature, who vows to be with him on his wedding night; soon afterward Victor is charged in Ireland with the murder of Clerval, whom the creature has strangled, and he is freed only after months in prison (Volume 3, Chapters 1-4).

Up NextComplete & Continue →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

The Broken Promise: The Second Creature and Clerval
Prev
Key Assignment — Responsibility Argument Essay
Next

© 2026 The VR School | Career content by Wiley | Powered by Sejal Learning Systems.

Join free · Accreditation · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Modal title

Main Content