
write a 900-1,100 word analytical essay arguing how one structural element of Antigone shapes the audience’s judgment, and defend the thesis orally.
Instruction
This essay asks you to do what the unit has prepared: argue how Sophocles builds meaning through structure.
The last reading. Before you choose your element, read the Exodos in full. It follows a hymn of hope to Bacchus (summarized in the reading card), and a messenger breaks that hope at once. Notice how each death reaches the audience: Haemon’s through a long report, Eurydice’s through a silent exit and a second messenger, and Creon’s recognition on stage, in his own voice: “I, even I, was thy slayer, wretched that I am—I own the truth.” The play ends on the Chorus’s warning that “Great words of prideful men are ever punished with great blows.” Each of these is a structural choice you could write about.
Choose one structural element. The choral odes; the order of the episodes, especially who confronts Creon when; the timing of Creon’s reversal; the placement of Haemon’s scene at the play’s center; the offstage deaths reported by messengers; or the ending that belongs to Creon rather than Antigone. One element, explored in depth, beats a survey of all of them.
Develop a theme through it (9-10.RL.1.D). The element is your evidence; the theme is what it reveals — about law, conscience, pride, the limits of human knowledge, or the cost of certainty. Your conclusion should say what the play makes visible that a summary would miss.
Character as construction (9-10.RL.2.D). Treat Antigone and Creon as characters Sophocles built, not people you are judging. Ask how their development is paced and what the pacing does.
Evidence. At least five embedded quotations from across the play, cited by line, including the one passage that most complicates your reading. Answer it — explain why your reading survives, or refine your thesis in light of it.
Conventions. This essay is scored on whether your semicolons and colons do argumentative work, as practiced in Lesson 1.3, and on correct MLA citation of a translated play.
Length and rigor. 900-1,100 words — longer than the English 9 equivalent, because Grade 10 essays should develop a claim through more steps and handle counter-evidence more fully.
The defense. After the final, record 90 seconds: state your thesis, name the passage that most challenged it, and explain what you did with that challenge (9-10.SL.2.A / 9-10.SL.2.B / 9-10.SL.2.C).
Academic integrity. Summaries and essays about Antigone are everywhere online. The stages exist so your thinking is visible as it develops; a final that does not grow from your organizer and draft will be discussed with you, not simply graded.
A checklist before you submit. Does every body paragraph open with a step in the argument rather than a plot event? Does each quotation have a sentence of analysis after it? Does the complicating passage appear, and do you answer it? Is the translator named in your Works Cited?
📖 Before this lesson, read: Antigone, Fifth Stasimon and Exodos (lines 1115-1353)
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: Key assignment packet: prompt, passages, rubric and model
Sophocles, Antigone, translated by R. C. Jebb (Cambridge University Press; translation first published 1888, text here from the 1917 edition, The Tragedies of Sophocles), Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Antigone_%28Jebb%29, retrieved 2026-09-26 · SLS original framing, tables, models and keys; quoted passages are public domain (Sophocles, tr. Jebb, 1888/1917)
Choose your structural element before you read the rubric.
What is hosted. The full prompt, the key passages the essay draws on that are not hosted in Lessons 1.1 and 1.5, a four-level rubric, a model thesis and outline, and a short exemplar. Sources: Sophocles, Antigone, tr. R. C. Jebb (Wikisource, 1917 edition of the 1888 translation), retrieved 2026-09-26. Passages hosted in Lessons 1.1 (prologue, first ode, Antigone before Creon, Teiresias and Creon’s turn, the ending) and 1.5 (Antigone’s and Creon’s cases, Haemon) remain available in those lessons’ readings.
How the text is marked. Speakers are named as Jebb prints them: An. (Antigone), Is. (Ismene), Cr. (Creon), Ch. (the Chorus), Gu. (the Guard), Hae. (Haemon), Te. (Teiresias), Me. (the Messenger). Jebb translates into prose. The numbers in square brackets, such as [450], are the Greek line numbers Jebb prints in the margin at every tenth line; each sits at the place in the prose where that Greek line falls, so a passage can be located to within a few lines but not exactly. Cite the ten-line stretch it falls in. Spelling and wording are Jebb’s. Stage directions are in his brackets.
1. The prompt
Write a 900–1,100 word analytical essay arguing how one structural element of Antigone shapes the audience’s judgment of Antigone and Creon, and what theme that reveals. Choose one: the choral odes; the order of the episodes and who confronts Creon when; the timing of Creon’s reversal; the placement of Haemon’s scene at the play’s center; the offstage deaths reported by messengers; or the ending that belongs to Creon rather than Antigone. Use at least five embedded quotations from across the play, cited by line range, including the one passage that most complicates your reading, and answer it. Name the translator in your Works Cited. Then record a 90-second defense.
2. Key passages not hosted elsewhere
Creon states his principles (Episode 1)
Cr. Sirs, the vessel of our State, after being tossed on wild waves, hath once more been safely steadied by the gods: and ye, out of all the folk, have been called apart by my summons, because I knew, first of all, how true and constant was your reverence for the royal power of Laïus; how, again, when Oedipus was ruler of our land, and when he had perished, your steadfast loyalty still upheld their children. [170] Since, then, his sons have fallen in one day by a twofold doom,—each smitten by the other, each stained with a brother’s blood,—I now possess the throne and all its powers, by nearness of kinship to the dead. No man can be fully known, in soul and spirit and mind, until he hath been seen versed in rule and law-giving. For if any, being supreme guide of the State, cleaves not to the best counsels, but, through some fear, [180] keeps his lips locked, I hold, and have ever held, him most base; and if any makes a friend of more account than his fatherland, that man hath no place in my regard. For I—be Zeus my witness, who sees all things always—would not be silent if I saw ruin, instead of safety, coming to the citizens; nor would I ever deem the country’s foe a friend to myself; remembering this, that our country is the ship that bears us safe, and that only while she prospers in our voyage can we make true friends. [190] Such are the rules by which I guard this city’s greatness. And in accord with them is the edict which I have now published to the folk touching the sons of Oedipus;—that Eteocles, who hath fallen fighting for our city, in all renown of arms, shall be entombed, and crowned with every rite that follows the noblest dead to their rest. But for his brother, Polyneices,—who came back from exile, [200] and sought to consume utterly with fire the city of his fathers and the shrines of his fathers’ gods,—sought to taste of kindred blood, and to lead the remnant into slavery;—touching this man, it hath been proclaimed to our people that none shall grace him with sepulture or lament, but leave him unburied, a corpse for birds and dogs to eat, a ghastly sight of shame. Such the spirit of my dealing; and never, by deed of mine, shall the wicked stand in honour before the just; but whoso hath good will to Thebes, he shall be honoured of me, [210] in his life and in his death.
Antigone at the tomb’s threshold (the lament)
An. Tomb, bridal-chamber, eternal prison in the caverned rock, whither I go to find mine own, those many who have perished, and whom Persephone hath received among the dead! Last of all shall I pass thither, and far most miserably of all, before the term of my life is spent. But I cherish good hope that my coming will be welcome to my father, and pleasant to thee, my mother, and welcome, brother, to thee; [900] for, when ye died, with mine own hands I washed and dressed you, and poured drink-offerings at your graves; and now, Polyneices, ’tis for tending thy corpse that I win such recompense as this. [And yet I honoured thee, as the wise will deem, rightly. Never, had I been a mother of children, or if a husband had been mouldering in death, would I have taken this task upon me in the city’s despite. What law, ye ask, is my warrant for that word? The husband lost, another might have been found, and child from another, to replace the first-born; [910] but, father and mother hidden with Hades, no brother’s life could ever bloom for me again. Such was the law whereby I held thee first in honour; but Creon deemed me guilty of error therein, and of outrage, ah brother mine! And now he leads me thus, a captive in his hands; no bridal bed, no bridal song hath been mine, no joy of marriage, no portion in the nurture of children; but thus, forlorn of friends, unhappy one, I go living to the vaults of death.]
Jebb prints the lines that begin “And yet I” in square brackets because some editors have doubted that Sophocles wrote them. Say so if you quote from them.
The first messenger reports Haemon’s death (Exodos)
Me. Dear lady, I will witness of what I saw, and will leave no word of the truth untold. Why, indeed, should I soothe thee with words in which I must presently be found false? Truth is ever best.—I attended thy lord as his guide to the furthest part of the plain, where the body of Polyneices, torn by dogs, still lay unpitied. We prayed the goddess of the roads, and Pluto, in mercy to restrain their wrath; [1200] we washed the dead with holy washing; and with freshly-plucked boughs we solemnly burned such relics as there were. We raised a high mound of his native earth; and then we turned away to enter the maiden’s nuptial chamber with rocky couch, the caverned mansion of the bride of Death. And, from afar off, one of us heard a voice of loud wailing at that bride’s unhallowed bower; and came to tell our master Creon.
And as the king drew nearer, doubtful sounds of [1210] a bitter cry floated around him; he groaned, and said in accents of anguish, ‘Wretched that I am, can my foreboding be true? Am I going on the wofullest way that ever I went? My son’s voice greets me.—Go, my servants,—haste ye nearer, and when ye have reached the tomb, pass through the gap, where the stones have been wrenched away, to the cell’s very mouth,—and look, and see if ’tis Haemon’s voice that I know, or if mine ear is cheated by the gods.’ This search, at our despairing master’s word, we went to make; and in the furthest part of the tomb [1220] we descried her hanging by the neck, slung by a thread-wrought halter of fine linen; while he was embracing her with arms thrown around her waist,—bewailing the loss of his bride who is with the dead, and his father’s deeds, and his own ill-starred love. But his father, when he saw him, cried aloud with a dread cry and went in, and called to him with a voice of wailing:—’Unhappy, what a deed hast thou done! What thought hath come to thee? What manner of mischance hath marred thy reason? [1230] Come forth, my child! I pray thee—I implore!’ But the boy glared at him with fierce eyes, spat in his face, and, without a word of answer, drew his cross-hilted sword:—as his father rushed forth in flight, he missed his aim;—then, hapless one, wroth with himself, he straightway leaned with all his weight against his sword, and drove it, half its length, into his side; and, while sense lingered, he clasped the maiden to his faint embrace, and, as he gasped, sent forth on her pale cheek the swift stream of the oozing blood. Corpse enfolding corpse he lies; [1240] he hath won his nuptial rites, poor youth, not here, yet in the halls of Death; and he hath witnessed to mankind that, of all curses which cleave to man, ill counsel is the sovereign curse.
3. Rubric (SLS original, four levels)
| Criterion | 4 Exemplary | 3 Proficient | 2 Developing | 1 Beginning |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thesis (9-10.W.2.A) | Arguable and precise; Sophocles is the subject; names one structural choice and its effect on the audience’s judgment; holds and deepens across the essay. | Arguable; names a choice and an effect; sometimes drifts to the characters. | Names a choice but no effect, or is a judgment of a character. | Retells the plot or announces a topic. |
| Theme and character (9-10.RL.1.D, 9-10.RL.2.D) | Shows how the structure reveals a theme; treats both characters as constructions whose development is paced by the author. | Connects structure to a theme; characters mostly analyzed as constructions. | Names a theme without connecting it to structure. | Theme missing or a moral lesson unconnected to the text. |
| Evidence (9-10.RL.1.A) | Five or more embedded quotations from across the play, each with analysis that adds something the quotation does not say. | Five quotations, embedded, mostly analyzed. | Fewer than five, or clustered in one scene, or dropped in. | Little or no quotation. |
| Counter-evidence | The most complicating passage engaged and answered in a way that refines the thesis. | A complicating passage engaged and answered. | Mentioned but not answered. | Absent. |
| Conventions (9-10.W.3.A.c, 9-10.W.3.A.b) | Semicolons and colons do argumentative work throughout; MLA citation of a translated play correct, translator named. | Semicolons and colons mostly correct; citation mostly correct. | Frequent punctuation errors; citation incomplete. | Pervasive errors that block meaning. |
| Defense (9-10.SL.2.A / 9-10.SL.2.B / 9-10.SL.2.C) | Thesis, the passage that most challenged it, and the response, delivered clearly and briefly. | Thesis and challenge delivered clearly. | Thesis only, or unclear. | Not delivered. |
4. Model thesis and outline (SLS original)
Thesis. By placing Haemon’s scene at the center of the play, in a sequence of encounters that runs from the Guard and Ismene to Teiresias, and letting each one offer Creon a chance to reconsider, Sophocles makes Creon’s refusal look less like strength than like a habit, so that the audience judges his certainty by what it costs.
- Introduction: the two laws and the claim that the structure, not the argument, decides whom the audience trusts.
- Paragraph 1: the first ode (“Wonders are many”) as a warning placed before the trial.
- Paragraph 2: Haemon at the center: the strongest argument against Creon comes from the person Creon trusts most.
- Paragraph 3: the sequence of warnings, ending with Teiresias, and Creon’s late reversal.
- Counter-evidence paragraph: Antigone’s own harshness to Ismene, and the lament, which complicate any reading that makes her simply the wronged party.
- Conclusion: what the structure makes visible that a plot summary would not: the cost of certainty.
5. A short exemplar paragraph (SLS original)
The order of the warnings is an argument in itself. Haemon speaks for the city (“Our Theban folk, with one voice, denies it”), and Creon asks, “Shall Thebes prescribe to me how I must rule?” (Sophocles, lines 730–40). By the time Teiresias arrives, the audience has watched Creon turn away a son, a Chorus and the very idea of counsel; his answer to the prophet, “the prophet-tribe was ever fond of money” (lines 1050–60), is therefore not a new mistake but the same one made again. Sophocles ranks the warnings by their authority, from son to prophet, so that the reversal, when it comes, feels both inevitable and too late.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
peripeteia
Tap to revealReversal of fortune.
anagnorisis
Tap to revealRecognition, often too late.
stasimon
Tap to revealA choral ode between episodes.
antithesis
Tap to revealContrasting ideas in balanced form.
civil disobedience
Tap to revealOpen, principled refusal to obey a law, accepting the penalty.
A peer says your essay ‘retells the plot in order.’ What is the best revision?
How confident are you that you can argue how a structural choice in a play shapes meaning, with evidence from across the text?
Submit: Tragic Structure Analytical Essay (900-1,100 words) + 90-second defense
Task: Argue how one structural element of Antigone shapes the audience’s judgment of Antigone and Creon, and what theme that reveals.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Organizer. Thesis, advancing topic sentences, five quotations with line numbers (from Lesson 1.6).
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed draft. A partner tests arguability and the handling of the complicating passage; submit a revision note naming one change and the feedback behind it.
- Stage 3 — Final essay. 900-1,100 words, MLA, Works Cited naming the translator.
- Stage 4 — 90-second recorded defense. A scheduled live defense is an equal-credit alternative.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Thesis (9-10.W.2.A) | Arguable; Sophocles is the subject; names a structural choice and its effect; holds across the essay. |
| Theme and character (9-10.RL.1.D, 9-10.RL.2.D) | Structure connected to a theme; characters analyzed as constructions. |
| Evidence (9-10.RL.1.A) | Five or more embedded quotations from across the play, each analyzed. |
| Counter-evidence | The most complicating passage engaged and answered. |
| Conventions (9-10.W.3.A.c, 9-10.W.3.A.b) | Semicolons and colons do argumentative work; MLA citation of a translated play correct. |
| Defense (9-10.SL.2.A / 9-10.SL.2.B / 9-10.SL.2.C) | Thesis, challenge and response delivered clearly. |
Antigone, Fifth Stasimon and Exodos (lines 1115-1353)
Antigone, Fifth Stasimon (lines 1115-1154) Bridge summary — not the primary text
This is a short recap written for this course, not Sophocles’s own words, so you can follow the story between close-reading lessons.
{summary}Antigone, Exodos (lines 1155-1353)
Source: Sophocles, Antigone, translated by R. C. Jebb (The Tragedies of Sophocles, Cambridge University Press, 1917), Wikisource (en.wikisource.org) · Public domain
Enter Messenger, on the spectators’ left hand.
Me. Dwellers by the house of Cadmus and of Amphion, there is no estate of mortal life that I would ever praise or blame as settled. Fortune raises and Fortune humbles the lucky or unlucky from day to day, and no one can prophesy to men concerning those things which are established. For Creon was blest once, as I count bliss; he had saved this land of Cadmus from its foes; he was clothed with sole dominion in the land; he reigned, the glorious sire of princely children. And now all hath been lost. For when a man hath forfeited his pleasures, I count him not as living,—I hold him but a breathing corpse. Heap up riches in thy house, if thou wilt; live in kingly state; yet, if there be no gladness therewith, I would not give the shadow of a vapour for all the rest, compared with joy.
Ch. And what is this new grief that thou hast to tell for our princes?
Me. Death; and the living are guilty for the dead.
Ch. And who is the slayer? Who the stricken? Speak.
Me. Haemon hath perished; his blood hath been shed by no stranger.
Ch. By his father’s hand, or by his own?
Me. By his own, in wrath with his sire for the murder.
Ch. O prophet, how true, then, hast thou proved thy word!
Me. These things stand thus; ye must consider of the rest.
Ch. Lo, I see the hapless Eurydicè, Creon’s wife, approaching; she comes from the house by chance, haply,—or because she knows the tidings of her son.
Enter Eurydicè.
Eu. People of Thebes, I heard your words as I was going forth, to salute the goddess Pallas with my prayers. Even as I was loosing the fastenings of the gate, to open it, the message of a household woe smote on mine ear: I sank back, terror-stricken, into the arms of my handmaids, and my senses fled. But say again what the tidings were; I shall hear them as one who is no stranger to sorrow.
Me. Dear lady, I will witness of what I saw, and will leave no word of the truth untold. Why, indeed, should I soothe thee with words in which I must presently be found false? Truth is ever best.—I attended thy lord as his guide to the furthest part of the plain, where the body of Polyneices, torn by dogs, still lay unpitied. We prayed the goddess of the roads, and Pluto, in mercy to restrain their wrath; we washed the dead with holy washing; and with freshly-plucked boughs we solemnly burned such relics as there were. We raised a high mound of his native earth; and then we turned away to enter the maiden’s nuptial chamber with rocky couch, the caverned mansion of the bride of Death. And, from afar off, one of us heard a voice of loud wailing at that bride’s unhallowed bower; and came to tell our master Creon.
And as the king drew nearer, doubtful sounds of a bitter cry floated around him; he groaned, and said in accents of anguish, ‘Wretched that I am, can my foreboding be true? Am I going on the wofullest way that ever I went? My son’s voice greets me.—Go, my servants,—haste ye nearer, and when ye have reached the tomb, pass through the gap, where the stones have been wrenched away, to the cell’s very mouth,—and look, and see if ’tis Haemon’s voice that I know, or if mine ear is cheated by the gods.’
This search, at our despairing master’s word, we went to make; and in the furthest part of the tomb we descried her hanging by the neck, slung by a thread-wrought halter of fine linen; while he was embracing her with arms thrown around her waist,—bewailing the loss of his bride who is with the dead, and his father’s deeds, and his own ill-starred love.
But his father, when he saw him, cried aloud with a dread cry and went in, and called to him with a voice of wailing:—’Unhappy, what a deed hast thou done! What thought hath come to thee? What manner of mischance hath marred thy reason? Come forth, my child! I pray thee—I implore!’ But the boy glared at him with fierce eyes, spat in his face, and, without a word of answer, drew his cross-hilted sword:—as his father rushed forth in flight, he missed his aim;—then, hapless one, wroth with himself, he straightway leaned with all his weight against his sword, and drove it, half its length, into his side; and, while sense lingered, he clasped the maiden to his faint embrace, and, as he gasped, sent forth on her pale cheek the swift stream of the oozing blood.
Corpse enfolding corpse he lies; he hath won his nuptial rites, poor youth, not here, yet in the halls of Death; and he hath witnessed to mankind that, of all curses which cleave to man, ill counsel is the sovereign curse.
Eurydicè retires into the house.
Ch. What wouldst thou augur from this? The lady hath turned back, and is gone, without a word, good or evil.
Me. I, too, am startled; yet I nourish the hope that, at these sore tidings of her son, she cannot deign to give her sorrow public vent, but in the privacy of the house will set her handmaids to mourn the household grief. For she is not untaught of discretion, that she should err.
Ch. I know not; but to me, at least, a strained silence seems to portend peril, no less than vain abundance of lament.
Me. Well, I will enter the house, and learn whether indeed she is not hiding some repressed purpose in the depths of a passionate heart. Yea, thou sayest well: excess of silence, too, may have a perilous meaning.
Exit Messenger.
Enter Creon, on the spectators’ left, with attendants, carrying the shrouded body of Haemon on a bier.
Ch. Lo, yonder the king himself draws near, bearing that which tells too clear a tale,—the work of no stranger’s madness,—if we may say it,—but of his own misdeeds.
str. 1. Cr. Woe for the sins of a darkened soul, stubborn sins, fraught with death! Ah, ye behold us, the sire who hath slain, the son who hath perished! Woe is me, for the wretched blindness of my counsels! Alas, my son, thou hast died in thy youth, by a timeless doom, woe is me!—thy spirit hath fled,—not by thy folly, but by mine own!
str. 2. Ch. Ah me, how all too late thou seemest to see the right!
Cr. Ah me, I have learned the bitter lesson! But then, methinks, oh then, some god smote me from above with crushing weight, and hurled me into ways of cruelty, woe is me,—overthrowing and trampling on my joy! Woe, woe, for the troublous toils of men!
Enter Messenger from the house.
Me. Sire, thou hast come, methinks, as one whose hands are not empty, but who hath store laid up besides; thou bearest yonder burden with thee; and thou art soon to look upon the woes within thy house.
Cr. And what worse ill is yet to follow upon ills?
Me. Thy queen hath died, true mother of yon corpse—ah, hapless lady!—by blows newly dealt.
ant. 1. Cr. Oh Hades, all-receiving, whom no sacrifice can appease! Hast thou, then, no mercy for me? O thou herald of evil, bitter tidings, what word dost thou utter? Alas, I was already as dead, and thou hast smitten me anew! What sayest thou, my son? What is this new message that thou bringest—woe, woe is me!—of a wife’s doom,—of slaughter heaped on slaughter?
Ch. Thou canst behold: ’tis no longer hidden within.
The doors of the palace are opened, and the corpse of Eurydicè is disclosed.
ant. 2. Cr. Ah me,—yonder I behold a new, a second woe! What destiny, ah what, can yet await me? I have but now raised my son in my arms,—and there, again, I see a corpse before me! Alas, alas, unhappy mother! Alas, my child!
Me. There, at the altar, self-stabbed with a keen knife, she suffered her darkening eyes to close, when she had wailed for the noble fate of Megareus who died before, and then for his fate who lies there,—and when, with her last breath, she had invoked evil fortunes upon thee, the slayer of thy sons.
str. 3. Cr. Woe, woe! I thrill with dread. Is there none to strike me to the heart with two-edged sword?—O miserable that I am, and steeped in miserable anguish!
Me. Yea, both this son’s doom, and that other’s, were laid to thy charge by her whose corpse thou seest.
Cr. And what was the manner of the violent deed by which she passed away?
Me. Her own hand struck her to the heart, when she had learned her son’s sorely lamented fate.
str. 4. Cr. Ah me, this guilt can never be fixed on any other of mortal kind, for my acquittal! I, even I, was thy slayer, wretched that I am—I own the truth. Lead me away, O my servants, lead me hence with all speed, whose life is but as death!
Ch. Thy counsels are good, if there can be good with ills; briefest is best, when trouble is in our path.
ant. 3. Cr. Oh, let it come, let it appear, that fairest of fates for me, that brings my last day,—aye, best fate of all! Oh, let it come, that I may never look upon to-morrow’s light.
Ch. These things are in the future; present tasks claim our care: the ordering of the future rests where it should rest.
Cr. All my desires, at least, were summed in that prayer.
Ch. Pray thou no more; for mortals have no escape from destined woe.
ant. 4. Cr. Lead me away, I pray you; a rash, foolish man; who have slain thee, ah my son, unwittingly, and thee, too, my wife—unhappy that I am! I know not which way I should bend my gaze, or where I should seek support; for all is amiss with that which is in my hands,—and yonder, again, a crushing fate hath leapt upon my head.
As Creon is being conducted into the house, the Coryphaeus speaks the closing verses.
Ch. Wisdom is the supreme part of happiness; and reverence towards the gods must be inviolate. Great words of prideful men are ever punished with great blows, and, in old age, teach the chastened to be wise.