
gather relevant information from authoritative print and digital sources, assess each source’s usefulness, integrate it selectively and cite it in MLA without plagiarism.
Instruction
A research paper is only as good as its sources. This lab teaches you to find sources worth using, judge them, and use them honestly (9-10.W.1.A.b).
Where to look. Start with your school library’s databases, which index scholarly articles and reference works. Use Google Scholar for academic sources, and university and museum sites for reliable open material. Public-domain archives — Project Gutenberg, the Internet Archive, the Library of Congress — hold primary sources, including early reviews of Frankenstein and the 1910 film. Open-access journals publish peer-reviewed scholarship freely.
Assessing usefulness: four questions. Who wrote it, and what qualifies them? A literature professor, a science historian or a museum curator has standing a random blogger lacks. Where was it published, and does that place check its work? Peer-reviewed journals, university presses and established publications have editorial review. When was it written? An 1818 review is a primary source about the novel’s reception; a 2018 essay is a secondary source about its meaning. Both are useful for different claims. What is it for? Study-guide summary sites exist to replace reading the book; they cannot support an argument, because they only repeat the plot.
Integrating information selectively. Use a source only where it advances your claim. Introduce it with a signal phrase that names the author and why they matter: Literary historian Anne Mellor argues that… Then quote, paraphrase or summarize, and follow with your own analysis. A paragraph that is mostly borrowed material is not yet yours.
Plagiarism is presenting someone else’s words or ideas as your own. It includes copying without quotation marks, paraphrasing too closely, and using an idea without credit. Paraphrase means restating in your own words and structure, and it still requires citation. AI tools that generate text raise the same issue: text you did not write, or ideas you did not originate, must be acknowledged according to your school’s policy.
MLA citation (9-10.W.3.A.b). In-text: author’s last name and page number in parentheses — (Mellor 45). Works Cited: author, title, container (journal or website), other contributors, version, number, publisher, date, location (page range or URL). For the novel: Shelley, Mary Wollstonecraft. Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus. Lackington, Hughes, Harding, Mavor and Jones, 1818.
Spelling (9-10.W.3.A.c). Spell names correctly every time: Wollstonecraft, Aeschylus, Prometheus, Sophocles, Pankhurst.
Your proposal and bibliography. A 150-word proposal stating your research question and working thesis, and an annotated bibliography of at least five sources: full MLA citation, two sentences summarizing the source, and one sentence assessing its usefulness for your argument.
Reading: A source to assess, citation models and a worked key
[Walter Scott, attributed], Remarks on Frankenstein, Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine, vol. 2, no. 12 (March 1818), Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=Blackwood%27s_Magazine/Volume_2/Issue_12/Remarks_on_Frankenstein&action=render; Mary Shelley, Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (1818 text), Project Gutenberg eBook 41445 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/41445); Frankenstein (Edison Manufacturing Company, 1910, directed by J. Searle Dawley), title cards as transcribed on Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=Frankenstein_%281910_film%29&action=render. Retrieved 2026-09-26. · SLS original framing, tables, models and key; quoted passages are public domain (review in Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine, 1818; Shelley, 1818; Edison title cards, 1910)
Apply the four questions to the review before you read the assessments.
What is hosted. A real 1818 review of the novel, used as a source to assess; three worked source assessments; signal-phrase and citation models; a paraphrase and plagiarism worked key; and a model proposal and annotated bibliography entries. Sources: [Walter Scott, attributed], Remarks on Frankenstein, Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine, vol. 2, no. 12 (March 1818), Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=Blackwood%27s_Magazine/Volume_2/Issue_12/Remarks_on_Frankenstein&action=render; Mary Shelley, Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (1818 text), Project Gutenberg eBook 41445 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/41445) (for the second assessment); Frankenstein (Edison Manufacturing Company, 1910, directed by J. Searle Dawley), title cards as transcribed on Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=Frankenstein_%281910_film%29&action=render. Retrieved 2026-09-26. The review is unsigned in the printed magazine and is generally attributed to Walter Scott; treat the attribution as probable, not certain. Everything outside the block quotations is SLS original.
1. A source to assess: a review published the year the novel appeared
Read these three passages, then use the four questions in section 2.
The result is, this monster, who was at first, according to his own account, but a harmless monster, becomes ferocious and malignant, in consequence of finding all his approaches to human society repelled with injurious violence and offensive marks of disgust.
— Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine, March 1818, review of Frankenstein (unsigned; generally attributed to Walter Scott)
The self-education of the monster, considering the slender opportunities of acquiring knowledge that he possessed, we have already noticed as improbable and overstrained. That he should have not only learned to speak, but to read, and, for aught we know, to write—that he should have become acquainted with Werter, with Plutarch’s Lives, and with Paradise Lost, by listening through a hole in a wall, seems as unlikely as that he should have acquired
— Same review
Upon the whole, the work impresses us with a high idea of the author’s original genius and happy power of expression. We shall be delighted to hear that he has aspired to the paullo majora; and, in the meantime, congratulate our readers upon a novel which excites new reflections and untried sources of emotion.
— Same review, near the end
2. Assessing usefulness: four questions applied to real sources (SLS original)
| Source | Who wrote it? | Where published? | When? | What for? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The review above | Unsigned; generally attributed to Walter Scott, a novelist and critic of the day. Attribution is uncertain. | A monthly magazine with editors, but not peer-reviewed in the modern sense. | March 1818: a primary source about how the novel was first received. | To judge a new book for readers. Good for a claim about early reception; not evidence of what the novel means. |
| The 1818 text of the novel (Project Gutenberg 41445) | Mary Shelley. | Reprint of the first edition, with the Gutenberg project’s own front matter. | 1818. | The primary text you are analyzing. Cite it by volume and chapter. |
| The 1910 film’s title cards (Wikisource) | The Edison company; the transcription is by volunteers. | Transcription of the film’s own cards on a volunteer-edited library. | 1910. | A primary source for how the story was retold on film; check the transcription against the film if you quote it. |
A plot-summary or study-guide site belongs in none of these rows. It exists to stand in for reading the book, so it can repeat the plot but cannot support an argument.
3. Signal phrases and MLA in-text citations (SLS original)
- The reviewer argues that the creature “becomes ferocious and malignant” because “all his approaches to human society” are “repelled with injurious violence” (“Remarks”). Signal phrase names the source, verb tells the reader what the source does, a title stands in for the missing author.
- According to the same review, the creature’s learning of language from a hidden hole is “as unlikely as” learning Euclid the same way (“Remarks”). Short quotation woven into your sentence.
- Then follow every source with your own sentence: “That view puts the cause of the violence in society, which is the same pattern the creature describes in his own account.”
Page numbers. A printed magazine gives a page range; take it from the printed page numbers shown on the Wikisource transcription. Where a source has no pages (a web text), cite the section or volume and chapter instead.
4. Paraphrase, quotation and plagiarism, with a worked key (SLS original)
Source sentence (quoted above): the monster “becomes ferocious and malignant, in consequence of finding all his approaches to human society repelled with injurious violence and offensive marks of disgust.”
| Version | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| The reviewer says the monster becomes ferocious and malignant, in consequence of finding all his approaches to human society repelled. | Plagiarism | Copied wording without quotation marks and no citation. |
| The reviewer says the creature turns violent because everyone he tries to befriend drives him away. | Acceptable paraphrase, needs a citation | Own words and structure; still needs (“Remarks”). |
| The creature turns violent because everyone he tries to befriend drives him away. | Plagiarism of an idea | The idea is the reviewer’s, and it has no credit. |
Text generated by an AI tool that you did not write, or ideas you did not originate, must be acknowledged according to your school’s policy, exactly as any source would be.
5. Works Cited patterns (SLS original)
- Shelley, Mary Wollstonecraft. Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus. Lackington, Hughes, Harding, Mavor and Jones, 1818. Project Gutenberg, www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/41445.
- [Scott, Walter, attributed.] “Remarks on Frankenstein.” Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine, vol. 2, no. 12, Mar. 1818, pp. [page range from the source]. Wikisource, en.wikisource.org.
6. A model proposal and annotated entry (SLS original)
Question and working thesis (about 60 words). Does Frankenstein suggest that a maker’s obligation depends on intention? Working thesis: the novel argues that responsibility follows from the act of creating, not from the maker’s feelings about the result; the 1818 reception and the 1910 film are evidence for how readers and viewers have resisted that idea.
Annotated entry. [Scott, Walter, attributed.] “Remarks on Frankenstein.” Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine, vol. 2, no. 12, Mar. 1818. Summary: The reviewer praises the novel’s originality and its descriptions but finds the creature’s self-education improbable, and says the creature becomes violent because human society repels him. Usefulness: A primary source for early reception and an early reading that blames society, so it can serve as the opposing view in the disagreement paragraph; not evidence for what Shelley intended.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which source is most useful for an argument about how Frankenstein was received in 1818?
If you paraphrase a source in your own words, you do not need to cite it.
An MLA in-text citation gives the author’s last name and the number; a phrase introducing a source is a phrase; Shelley’s mother was Mary .
Submit your research proposal (question and working thesis, 150 words) and an annotated bibliography of five sources, each with full MLA citation, a two-sentence summary and a one-sentence usefulness assessment.
How confident are you that you can find authoritative sources, judge their usefulness and cite them honestly?