
synthesize multiple sources into paragraphs governed by my own claim, and conduct a research project that narrows or broadens its inquiry as evidence requires.
Instruction
The weakest research papers report sources one after another: “Mellor says… Smith says… The novel says…” The reader is left to do the thinking. Synthesis means the opposite: you control each paragraph, and sources enter to support, complicate or challenge your claim. Think of braiding — separate strands woven into one line that is yours.
A reported paragraph (weak). Anne Mellor writes that Victor fails as a parent. Another critic argues that the creature is responsible for his crimes. In the novel, Victor flees the creature. Three facts, no argument.
A braided paragraph (strong). Victor’s failure is not ignorance but refusal. In the moment of creation he names his work “the miserable monster” before it has acted (Shelley, vol. 1, ch. 4), a judgment the critic Anne K. Mellor, in Mary Shelley: Her Life, Her Fiction, Her Monsters (1988), reads as a parent’s rejection of a child. Yet Mellor’s reading may be too kind to Victor: a parent overwhelmed by a newborn is not the same as a scientist who chose his experiment for glory. Antigone, by contrast, accepts an obligation she did not choose; Victor rejects one he created. The difference suggests that responsibility follows from the act of creating, not from the creator’s feelings about the result.
Notice the pattern. The paragraph opens with the writer’s claim. Each source — the novel, the critic, Antigone — enters to do a job. The writer’s analysis comes between every piece of borrowed material. The critic is used, then questioned. And the paragraph ends with the writer’s own step forward.
The highlighter test. Highlight every sentence taken from a source (including paraphrase) in one color and your own analysis in another. If two source sentences touch with nothing of yours between them, add analysis. If the source color dominates, rewrite the paragraph’s first sentence as your claim.
Narrowing and broadening (9-10.W.1.A). Research questions change. “When is it right to defy authority?” is too broad for 1,500 words; “Does Frankenstein suggest that a creator’s obligation depends on intention?” may be right-sized. If your sources are thin, broaden; if they are overwhelming, narrow. Revise your research question today and record why.
The disagreement paragraph. Your paper must include one paragraph that represents a secondary source fairly and then disagrees with it. Scholars are not authorities to obey; they are arguments to test. You have read the same novel.
Revision (9-10.W.3.A). Draft two braided paragraphs, run the highlighter test, and revise. Bring both to peer review.
Reading: Synthesis as braiding: a mentor paragraph, a review and models
Henry David Thoreau, Resistance to Civil Government (1849), Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Resistance_to_Civil_Government; [Walter Scott, attributed], Remarks on Frankenstein, Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine, vol. 2, no. 12 (March 1818), Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=Blackwood%27s_Magazine/Volume_2/Issue_12/Remarks_on_Frankenstein&action=render; Mary Shelley, Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (1818 text), Project Gutenberg eBook 41445 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/41445); Sophocles, Antigone, translated by R. C. Jebb, Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Antigone_%28Jebb%29. Retrieved 2026-09-26. · SLS original framing, models and criteria; quoted passages are public domain (Thoreau, 1849; review in Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine, 1818; Shelley, 1818; Sophocles, tr. Jebb, 1888)
Run the highlighter test on the braided paragraph before you draft your own.
What is hosted. A mentor paragraph from a public-domain essay in which the author reports a source fairly and then disagrees with it, a review to use as a secondary source, a reported paragraph beside a braided one, the highlighter test, a research-question revision, a disagreement paragraph and the criteria. Sources: Henry David Thoreau, Resistance to Civil Government (1849), Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Resistance_to_Civil_Government; [Walter Scott, attributed], Remarks on Frankenstein, Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine, vol. 2, no. 12 (March 1818), Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=Blackwood%27s_Magazine/Volume_2/Issue_12/Remarks_on_Frankenstein&action=render; Mary Shelley, Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (1818 text), Project Gutenberg eBook 41445 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/41445); Sophocles, Antigone, translated by R. C. Jebb, Wikisource https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Antigone_%28Jebb%29. Retrieved 2026-09-26. Everything outside the block quotations is SLS original.
1. A mentor paragraph: a source used, then tested
Thoreau introduces an authority, gives his argument in the authority’s own words, and then says where it fails.
Paley, a common authority with many on moral questions, in his chapter on the “Duty of Submission to Civil Government,” resolves all civil obligation into expediency; and he proceeds to say, “that so long as the interest of the whole society requires it, that is, so long as the established government cannot be resisted or changed without public inconveniency, it is the will of God that the established government be obeyed, and no longer.”—“This principle being admitted, the justice of every particular case of resistance is reduced to a computation of the quantity of the danger and grievance on the one side, and of the probability and expense of redressing it on the other.” Of this, he says, every man shall judge for himself. But Paley appears never to have contemplated those cases to which the rule of expediency does not apply, in which a people, as well as an individual, must do justice, cost what it may. If I have unjustly wrested a plank from a drowning man, I must restore it to him though I drown myself. This, according to Paley, would be inconvenient. But he that would save his life, in such a case, shall lose it. This people must cease to hold slaves, and to make war on Mexico, though it cost them their existence as a people.
— Thoreau, Resistance to Civil Government (1849)
Annotation (SLS original). Report: Paley “resolves all civil obligation into expediency.” Quotation: two sentences of Paley are quoted. Test: “Paley appears never to have contemplated those cases to which the rule of expediency does not apply.” Own step forward: the plank example and the final sentence. Notice that the source is quoted fairly before it is disagreed with.
2. Passages for your braid
The three sources below are enough to do the workshop. Paragraph 3 of the task asks for the novel, one other semester text and one secondary source.
I was benevolent and good; misery made me a fiend. Make me happy, and I shall again be virtuous.
— The creature to Victor, Vol. II, Ch. II
The result is, this monster, who was at first, according to his own account, but a harmless monster, becomes ferocious and malignant, in consequence of finding all his approaches to human society repelled with injurious violence and offensive marks of disgust.
— Secondary source: the 1818 review in Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine
No, whomsoever the city may appoint, that man must be obeyed, in little things and great, in just things and unjust
— Sophocles, Antigone, Creon, tr. Jebb, about lines 666–68
3. A reported paragraph (weak) and a braided one (strong) (SLS original)
Reported (weak). The 1818 reviewer writes that the creature becomes violent because society repels him. Another view is that the creature chooses to kill. In the novel the creature says he was benevolent. Three facts, no argument.
Braided (strong). Victor’s failure is not ignorance but refusal, and the creature’s own account says what the refusal cost: “I was benevolent and good; misery made me a fiend.” The 1818 reviewer reads this the way the novel invites, saying the creature “becomes ferocious and malignant, in consequence of finding all his approaches to human society repelled,” and puts the cause in the world that rejects him. That reading is fair, but it is too kind to Victor, because it hands the cause to everyone who fled the creature and lets the maker who fled first disappear into the crowd. Creon, by contrast, argues that whoever the city appoints “must be obeyed”; the creature was never given a place in any city, so no such rule binds him, and the only authority over him is the one that made him. The contrast suggests that responsibility follows the act of making, not the feelings of the maker.
4. The highlighter test (SLS original)
Highlight every sentence taken from a source (including paraphrase) in one color and your own analysis in another. If two source sentences touch with nothing of yours between them, add analysis. If the source color dominates, rewrite the paragraph’s first sentence as your claim. In the braided paragraph above, the pattern is: claim, novel, reviewer, your test of the reviewer, the second text, your step forward.
5. Narrowing and broadening a research question (SLS original)
| Question | Problem | Revision |
|---|---|---|
| When is it right to defy authority? | Too broad for 1,500 words. | Does Frankenstein suggest that a maker’s obligation depends on intention? |
| Does Victor love the creature? | Too narrow; one answer, no debate. | Does the novel blame Victor’s failure to care, or the creature’s choices, more? |
6. A disagreement paragraph (SLS original)
The 1818 reviewer says the creature is made violent by finding “all his approaches to human society repelled with injurious violence.” That is a fair reading of the cottage scene, where Felix beats the creature and drives him out. But it does not account for the creature’s later choices: after he has been rejected, he still decides to strangle a child to hurt Victor. A reader who gives society all the blame has to explain that decision, and the reviewer does not.
7. Criteria (SLS original)
- Every body paragraph opens with your claim.
- Each source has a job: support, complicate or challenge.
- Your analysis stands between every two pieces of borrowed material.
- One paragraph represents a secondary source fairly and disagrees with it.
- Your revised research question says whether you narrowed or broadened and why.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
What distinguishes a braided paragraph from a reported one?
Changing your research question during research is a sign of poor planning.
Draft two braided body paragraphs using the novel, one other semester text and one secondary source. Run the highlighter test and revise. Then submit your revised research question with one sentence explaining why you narrowed or broadened it.
How confident are you that you can braid sources into paragraphs that my own claim governs?