
describe a system at dynamic equilibrium and argue from evidence how changes in concentration, pressure and temperature shift it, applying the reasoning to making ammonia.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A sealed bottle of carbonated water shows almost no bubbles. Open it and it fizzes. Write where the gas was hiding and why opening the cap changes things.
Two sealed bottles of the same carbonated water, one cold and one warm, are opened slowly. Which hisses and bubbles more?
Quick observation. Your teacher sets out two sealed bottles of the same carbonated water, one from the refrigerator and one that has sat in a warm room, and three observations follow. (1) The sealed bottles show almost no bubbles. (2) Opening the warm bottle releases a bigger hiss and more bubbling than the cold one. (3) Squeezing air out and re-capping an opened bottle makes the fizz slow down. What is happening in the bottle?
Dynamic equilibrium. In a sealed bottle, carbon dioxide moves both ways: CO2(gas) ⇌ CO2(dissolved). Molecules leave the liquid and others dissolve back, all the time. When the two rates are equal, the amounts stop changing. That state is dynamic equilibrium: not stopped, but balanced. Many reactions work the same way, running forward and backward at once.
Changing the conditions. If you disturb a system at equilibrium, it shifts in the direction that partly counteracts the change. This pattern is called Le Chatelier’s principle, and it is a prediction tool, not an explanation by itself; the explanation is always in rates of forward and reverse processes.
Worked example 1: the big application, ammonia. Crops need nitrogen. The air is 78% nitrogen, but N2 has a triple bond so strong (about 946 kJ/mol) that plants cannot use it directly. Industrial fertilizer starts with the Haber-Bosch process: N2(g) + 3H2(g) ⇌ 2NH3(g), energy change −92 kJ (exothermic). That −92 kJ is the value your bond-energy model gave in Unit 3. Apply the reasoning: Pressure: 4 molecules of gas on the left, 2 on the right, so high pressure shifts toward ammonia. Temperature: the forward reaction releases energy, so a low temperature favors ammonia at equilibrium. Concentration: cooling the gas mixture so ammonia condenses to a liquid removes product, and the system keeps making more.
Worked example 2: the trade-off that makes this an argument. Low temperature gives more ammonia at equilibrium, but, as you measured with antacid tablets, low temperature makes reactions slow. At a low temperature the plant would wait a very long time to get there. Real plants compromise: a moderately high temperature (typically a few hundred degrees Celsius) with an iron-based catalyst to speed both directions, high pressure (typically on the order of 100–300 times atmospheric pressure, varying by plant), and continuous removal of ammonia. A catalyst does not change how much ammonia is present at equilibrium; it only gets there faster. High pressure costs energy and demands strong, safe equipment. Every choice is a trade-off between yield, rate, cost and safety.
Arguing well. In today’s argument, each claim about a condition must name the direction of the shift, the evidence (the equation’s gas-molecule count or energy change, or your soda observations), and the rate consequence. “A catalyst increases the yield” is a common, unsupported claim you should be ready to rebut.
Reading. OpenStax Chemistry 2e, chapter 13 (fundamental equilibrium concepts and shifting equilibria), CC BY 4.0.
Use your soda observations and the ammonia equation.
Apply the reasoning to a new system.
The reaction 2SO2(g) + O2(g) ⇌ 2SO3(g) is exothermic and is used to make sulfuric acid. Predict the effect on the amount of SO3 of (a) raising the pressure, (b) raising the temperature, (c) removing SO3. Explain each with forward and reverse rates.
Equilibrium is a balance of rates that we can push. Next phase, we go inside the nucleus.
Exit ticket: a classmate says “at equilibrium the reaction has stopped.” Correct them in two sentences using the soda bottle.
Materials: two identical sealed bottles of carbonated water, one refrigerated and one at room temperature; a third bottle for the squeeze-and-recap demo; goggles; towels.
Setup: run the demo in the first 10 minutes. The argument piece is the lab product; collect it.
Listen for: “equilibrium means equal amounts”; “the catalyst makes more product”; Le Chatelier used as the explanation instead of rates.
Support / stretch: a shift table (change, direction, reason, rate consequence). Stretch: explain why adding an unreactive gas at constant volume does not shift the ammonia equilibrium.