
use ionization-energy data from NIST and the pattern of outer electrons to argue which element in a pair is more reactive.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Yesterday magnesium beat zinc, iron and copper. Today’s question: within group 1, which is more reactive, lithium, sodium or potassium? Write your guess and what kind of evidence would settle it.
Going down group 1 from lithium to potassium, how does the energy needed to remove the outer electron change?
A number that measures grip. The first ionization energy is the energy needed to remove the outermost electron from a neutral atom in the gas phase. It measures how tightly an atom holds its outer electron. NIST publishes these values, in electron-volts (eV), for every element. A small value means the electron is easy to remove, so a metal with a small ionization energy reacts readily.
Data down group 1 (alkali metals), NIST: lithium 5.39 eV, sodium 5.14 eV, potassium 4.34 eV, rubidium 4.18 eV, cesium 3.89 eV. The values fall steadily down the group. The observations match: lithium fizzes steadily in water, sodium skates and hisses, and potassium reacts violently enough to ignite the hydrogen it produces. (Those reactions are shown only on video; they are never done in our lab.)
Why the trend? Each alkali metal has one outer electron. Going down the group, each atom has one more filled shell between the nucleus and that electron. The outer electron is farther away and is shielded by the inner electrons, so the attraction it feels from the nucleus is weaker. The electrical force between charges gets weaker with distance, so a farther electron is easier to remove. This is the core reasoning of the whole unit: patterns of outer electrons, and their distance from the nucleus, explain patterns of properties.
Across a period. From sodium (5.14 eV) across period 3 to argon (15.76 eV), ionization energy generally rises. Each step adds a proton to the nucleus while the new electron goes into the same outer shell, so the outer electrons are pulled in more strongly, and the atoms get smaller. There are small dips (aluminum 5.99 eV is below magnesium 7.65 eV; sulfur 10.36 eV is below phosphorus 10.49 eV). A good argument does not hide exceptions; it notes them and says whether they change the overall claim. They do not.
Nonmetals run the other way. Halogens (group 17) react by gaining an electron. Fluorine, the smallest, pulls hardest on an incoming electron and is the most reactive nonmetal; reactivity falls down the group to iodine. Their ionization energies also fall (F 17.42, Cl 12.97, Br 11.81, I 10.45 eV), but for halogens a high value means the atom holds on to electrons, which fits their tendency to gain rather than lose them. The same pull explains electronegativity, which rises across a period and falls down a group.
Building the argument. A scientific argument has a claim (potassium is more reactive than sodium), evidence (NIST: K 4.34 eV, Na 5.14 eV, a difference of 0.80 eV; observed reactions with water), and reasoning that connects them with a scientific principle (the outer electron of potassium is one shell farther from the nucleus, more shielded, so less tightly held). In today’s discourse lab you present an argument, hear a counter-claim and respond. A strong rebuttal uses evidence, not volume.
Data task. Graph first ionization energy (y) against atomic number (x) for Z = 1–20 from the NIST table your teacher provides. Mark each group 1 element and each noble gas. Describe the repeating pattern in two sentences.
Use the NIST values in the lecture and your graph.
Write the argument for the co-op.
Claim, evidence, reasoning: is lithium more or less reactive than sodium and potassium? Use two NIST values and the shell models. Then add one sentence on what this means for handling lithium metal.
Trends explain reactivity. Next phase, we model shells, ions and isotopes to predict formulas and lithium’s atomic mass.
Exit ticket: cesium (3.89 eV) sits below potassium. Predict its reactivity with water compared with potassium, and explain with distance and shielding.
Materials: NIST first-ionization-energy table for Z = 1–20 (printed), graph paper or a spreadsheet, short teacher-chosen videos of alkali metals in water (never performed live).
Discourse protocol: pairs present a 60-second argument, another pair offers a counter-claim, the first pair rebuts with data. Post the norm “evidence, not volume.”
Listen for: “bigger atoms have more electrons so they hold them tighter”; confusing high ionization energy with high reactivity for metals.
Support / stretch: give a two-column “distance / shielding” organizer. Stretch: explain the Mg–Al dip using the idea of a new, slightly higher-energy sublevel.