
write a claim-evidence-reasoning explanation that uses electrical attraction, distance and outer electrons to explain the unit’s phenomena, and brainstorm ways the co-op could separate ions in its brine.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at your first model of the atom from 1.01. Draw one arrow or label you would now add to explain why iron rusts and gold does not.
The force between two charges gets stronger as the charges get farther apart.
One rule under every pattern. Everything this unit has shown comes from one force: opposite charges attract, like charges repel. Coulomb’s law says the force is proportional to the product of the charges and inversely proportional to the square of the distance: F ∝ q1q2 / r2. Double the distance and the force drops to one quarter. Double one charge and the force doubles.
Worked example 1: applying the rule down a group. Lithium’s outer electron sits in shell 2; potassium’s sits in shell 4. Treat the inner electrons as cancelling most of the nuclear charge, so each outer electron feels roughly the same net pull from the core (about +1). Then distance decides: the farther electron feels a much weaker force, so potassium loses it more easily (NIST 4.34 eV against 5.39 eV) and reacts more vigorously. Claim, evidence, reasoning: complete.
Worked example 2: applying it to ions. Mg2+ carries twice the charge of Na+, and it is also a smaller ion, so negative ions and water molecules can get closer to it. At the same distance a 2+ ion attracts them about twice as strongly, and the shorter distance adds even more pull. That is a separation clue for the co-op: 2+ ions (Ca2+, Mg2+) can be pulled out of brine by charge in ways that +1 ions are not.
Revising the model. Our class model began as “atoms are balls with protons and electrons.” It now has: a nucleus whose proton count sets the element and its place in the table; shells whose outer electrons repeat in a pattern down each group; a pull on those outer electrons that falls with distance and shielding; and ions whose charges follow the group. Each piece earned its place from evidence: the particle table, the vinegar lab, the NIST data and the shell diagrams.
CER with sentence starters. Claim: “Lithium is found in the brine as ___ because ___.” Evidence: “Our vinegar lab showed ___; NIST lists ___.” Reasoning: “Because the outer electron is ___ from the nucleus and shielded by ___, the attraction is ___, so ___.”
Ideate. Now the co-op’s sub-problem (b): remove Ca2+ and Mg2+ from a model brine. Brainstorm at least five ideas, wild ones welcome, then tag each with the property it uses: charge, ion size, solubility of a compound the ion forms, or boiling and evaporation. Example seeds: let water evaporate and collect what crystallizes first; add a substance that makes the 2+ ions form a solid that settles out; pass the brine through beads that grab ions by charge. Defer judgment until the list is long.
| Idea | Property it uses | Why it might work (science) | One worry |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | |||
| 2 | |||
| 3 | |||
| 4 | |||
| 5 |
Use the class model poster and your notebook data.
Ideate brainstorm, then narrow.
Fill your five-idea table. Star the two ideas your team will develop and explain each one's science in two sentences.
The science is in place and the idea list is long. Next phase, we design and prototype the brine cleanup step.
Exit ticket: which Wonder Board question can you now answer? Write the question and a two-sentence answer.
How confident are you that you can I can use the periodic table to predict how elements behave from attraction and outer-electron patterns.
Materials: the class model poster from 1.01, sticky notes in two colors (new evidence, model change), ideation table copies.
Setup: run a 10-minute model-revision gallery first, then the CER, then the brainstorm. Keep Coulomb’s law qualitative and proportional; no constants or calculations of force are needed.
Listen for: “more electrons means a stronger hold”; brainstorms that judge ideas too early.
Support / stretch: provide the CER starters on a card. Stretch: compare Li+ and K+ ion sizes and predict which one a size-selective trap could catch.