
explain rusting from outer electrons and bond energy, use mole calculations to predict the mass of rust and show mass is conserved, and evaluate strategies for protecting steel against prioritized criteria.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. List the three strongest pieces of evidence you have collected this unit (a mass change, a temperature change, a scratch-test score, a calculation). Next to each, write the claim it supports.
Why does a zinc coating protect steel even where it is scratched?
The context. A suspension bridge is a machine for resisting forces, but in a salty fog belt its biggest long-term enemy is chemistry. Every square meter of the bridge’s steel must be protected from rust, and every protection method costs money, time, energy and materials. Your report is the kind of technical explanation an engineer writes before recommending a maintenance plan.
Part 1: Explain the reaction (HS-PS1-2, HS-PS1-4). Write the balanced equation 4Fe + 3O2 → 2Fe2O3, show the atom count, and explain the product from outer electrons: iron loses electrons to become Fe3+, oxygen gains them to become O2−, and the charges set the formula. Explain why salty fog speeds the process (dissolved ions let charge move between the places where iron gives up electrons and where oxygen accepts them). Then explain the energy: which bonds break, which form, why the reaction releases about 824 kJ per mole of Fe2O3, and where that energy goes. Include an energy diagram.
Part 2: Calculate (HS-PS1-7). Choose one of three sample masses of iron. All three earn full credit and take the same three steps; pick the one whose scale interests you. Option A: 25.0 g, about a handful of bolts. Option B: 250 g, about one large bridge rivet. Option C: 1.50 kg, a short length of suspender cable. For the mass you chose, predict the mass of Fe2O3 it would form and the mass of oxygen it would take from the air, using the three-step path (grams of iron → moles of iron → moles of product → grams of product), with Fe 55.845, O2 31.998 and Fe2O3 159.688 g/mol. Also give the number of iron atoms in your sample. Check yourself: Option A gives about 35.7 g of rust from 25.0 g of iron plus 10.7 g of oxygen; Option B is ten times that; Option C gives about 2,145 g of rust from 1,500 g of iron plus 645 g of oxygen. Show every step, because the rubric scores the path, not the answer. Show that iron plus oxygen equals rust. Then connect to your sealed-bag data: explain why the bag’s mass stayed nearly constant and why a rusting bolt gains mass, using the same principle.
Part 3: Evaluate protection strategies (HS-ETS1-3). Compare at least three: (a) paint systems, which keep water and oxygen away from the steel; (b) zinc galvanizing, where a zinc coating corrodes first because zinc gives up electrons more easily than iron (recall Unit 1’s reactivity series), protecting the steel even where scratched; (c) stainless or weathering steel, alloys that form a thin protective oxide layer; and, if you tested it, (d) a sacrificial strip. Rank at least three criteria (for example, service life, cost, ease of repair in place, and environmental impact of maintenance) and build a table scoring each strategy. Use your team’s heat-test and scratch-test data as evidence, and say how your version 1 explanation changed after the tests. State the trade-offs and say which strategy fits which part of a bridge. You do not need real costs; describe them as higher or lower and cite where you found any figure you use.
Worked example: a strong calculation paragraph. “25.0 g Fe ÷ 55.845 g/mol = 0.4477 mol Fe, or 2.70 × 1023 atoms. The equation’s ratio Fe2O3 : Fe is 2 : 4, so 0.2238 mol Fe2O3 × 159.688 g/mol = 35.7 g of rust. Oxygen used: 0.4477 × 3/4 = 0.3358 mol × 31.998 = 10.7 g. 25.0 + 10.7 = 35.7 g, so mass is conserved.” Every number has a unit and a source.
Quality bar. Every number is calculated and shown with units. Every mechanism is explained with electrons or bond energies. Every recommendation names its trade-off. Cite at least three sources, such as OpenStax Chemistry 2e, a bridge authority’s public maintenance information, and a federal source on corrosion such as the Federal Highway Administration.
Stages. Plan, draft, peer review (a partner re-does your calculation independently), revise, and defend in four minutes, answering one question.
Plan and peer-review checks.
Write and revise the report across the work sessions.
Write Parts 1 and 2 of your report (about 500 words), with the energy diagram and the full calculation.
Write Part 3: the criteria table, your bench-test evidence, the recommendation with trade-offs, and one limitation of the bench tests, with sources cited.
Task: For the bridge authority, explain why the bridge’s steel rusts, from the balanced equation, the outer electrons of iron and oxygen and the bond-energy model; predict the mass of rust, the mass of oxygen and the number of iron atoms for whichever of the three iron masses you chose, and show that mass is conserved; connect to your sealed-bag lab data; and evaluate at least three protection strategies in a prioritized criteria table with trade-offs, using your team’s bench-test data. Cite at least three sources.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Conservation calculation (HS-PS1-7) | Correct mole path with units; finds the number of atoms; shows iron + oxygen = rust; connects to lab data. |
| Reaction explanation (HS-PS1-2) | Explains the product and the role of salt water from outer electrons and charges; describes how bench evidence revised the team’s explanation. |
| Energy model (HS-PS1-4) | Energy diagram and bond-energy reasoning correctly show energy released to the surroundings. |
| Evaluation (HS-ETS1-3) | At least three strategies scored against ranked criteria with honest trade-offs and bench data. |
| Communication and sources | Clear flow of matter and energy through the system; at least three sources cited; the defense answers a question with evidence. |
Your report turns a unit of evidence into advice. Next: the unit checkpoint.
Exit ticket: what question did the authority's panel ask your team, and how did you answer it with evidence?
Timing: the report runs across about three sessions: this lesson launches it and covers planning and peer review; drafting and the presentations need further work time.
Materials: peer-review checklist, molar mass table, bond-energy table, OpenStax links, the teams’ bench-test data, rubric copies for visiting “authority engineers.”
Answers: A: 0.4477 mol, 2.70 × 1023 atoms, 35.7 g rust, 10.7 g O2. B: 4.477 mol, 2.70 × 1024 atoms, 357 g rust, 107 g O2. C: 26.86 mol, 1.62 × 1025 atoms, 2,145 g rust, 645 g O2.
Listen for: numbers with no units or source; “paint is always best” with no trade-off.
Support / stretch: give a paragraph frame for each part. Stretch: estimate the energy released as your chosen mass of iron rusts completely, using 824 kJ per mole of Fe2O3.