
give and use evidence-based critique, test my team’s protection method against every criterion, and justify the changes in version 2 with the revised rust model and a mole calculation.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Collect your 48-hour scratch-test nails. Score your treated nail and the control from 0 to 4 with your partner, separately, then compare. Write both scores and any disagreement.
A painted nail shows no rust except a bright orange X along the scratch. What does that show?
Gallery critique protocol. Each team posts its design sketch, decision matrix, heat-test graph and scratch-test nails. Visitors leave three sticky notes: I like… (a strength tied to a criterion), I wonder… (a question about evidence or the science), and What if… (one specific change). Notes must cite a number or a reason from the rust model; “looks good” does not count.
Class criteria and constraints (sample values set by the class). A protection method for the new bolts and brackets must (1) keep the temperature rise of a treated steel-wool sample in the 10-minute heat test to 1.0 °C or less (less heat means slower rusting); (2) keep a scratched treated nail at a rust score of 1 or less (0 none to 4 heavy) after 48 hours on a salt-water towel; (3) cost no more than 10 sample budget points per sample; (4) be repairable in place by the painting crew with hand tools; and (5) create as little hazardous waste as possible.
Worked example 1: turning critique into a change (sample data). Ava’s team (concept C, wax) got the note: “I wonder if the wax held up where you scratched it. Your nail scored 3.” Their heat test had passed (0.6 °C rise against 3.8 °C for the control), but the scratch let salt water in. Their first explanation was “wax stops rust everywhere.” Revised with the new evidence: “wax stops rust only where it covers the steel, because it works by keeping out water and oxygen; it cannot protect bare steel.” Version 2 put a zinc washer in contact with the nail under the wax. Result (sample data): rust score 1 at the scratch, 4 budget points.
Worked example 2: a trade-off made visible (sample data). Jamal’s team (concept D, magnesium strip) scored 0 at the scratch, but their magnesium was heavily corroded after 48 hours. They calculated what was at stake: magnesium is used up as it protects, so a real strip must be inspected and replaced. Version 2 kept the strip and added a paint coat over the steel so the strip has less bare steel to protect and lasts longer.
| Criterion | Version 1 | Change made | Version 2 | Met? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Heat test (°C rise) | ||||
| Scratch test (0–4) | ||||
| Budget | ||||
| Repair in place | ||||
| Waste |
Putting numbers on the benefit. If version 2 cuts the rusted fraction of a 2.40 kg bracket from 5% to 1% before the next inspection, the rust formed drops from about 172 g to about 34 g (24 g of iron → 0.430 mol → 0.215 mol Fe2O3 → 34.3 g). Stating the benefit in grams makes a recommendation concrete.
What our bench test cannot show. A real bridge sees years of sunlight, wind-blown grit, temperature swings and salt spray. A 48-hour test is a fast screen, not a lifetime. Your recommendation must name at least one limit of the model.
Use your version 1 data and the sticky notes you received.
Run version 2 and complete the comparison table.
Compare version 1 and version 2 on every criterion. Which criterion improved most, and what did you give up to get it?
The Statue of Liberty, dedicated in 1886, has a thin skin of copper fastened to an inner frame of iron bars. Its designers knew copper and iron touching in damp, salty harbor air would cause trouble, so they separated them with an insulating layer of cloth soaked in shellac.
Over the following decades the insulation broke down and moisture got in. Where iron touched copper, the iron corroded much faster than it would on its own: copper holds its electrons more tightly, so the iron gave up electrons to it. The swelling iron oxide pushed on the copper skin and pulled at its fastenings. During a major restoration in the mid-1980s, engineers replaced nearly all of the iron frame bars with stainless-steel bars and new insulating material, choosing a metal and a separation method suited to a salty harbor.
Think about it: Which of our class criteria match the problem in this case, and what should the bridge authority check wherever two different metals touch on the bridge?
Version 2 is tested and justified. Next phase, you write the corrosion report and present it to the bridge authority.
Exit ticket: name one piece of evidence from this week that made you change your explanation of how a protection method works, and state your old and new explanation.
Materials: the 48-hour scratch-test cups, sticky notes in three colors, the same materials as 3.07 for version 2, rust-score reference photos (0–4).
Timing: scoring 5 minutes, critique 15 minutes, version 2 setup and heat test 20 minutes, comparison write-up 10 minutes. Version 2 scratch nails can be read during 3.09 for the report.
Listen for: “more coating is always better”; changes with no reason; “the magnesium failed.”
Support / stretch: provide critique sentence starters and a rust-score photo card. Stretch: estimate how many grams of zinc are oxidized while protecting a bolt if 0.10 mol of electrons flow (Zn → Zn2+: 0.050 mol × 65.38 = 3.3 g).