
Lithium From Hot Brine: An Element Brief for a Geothermal Co-op
How can the periodic table explain why some elements rust, fizz or dissolve while others stay unchanged for centuries, and how can that help a geothermal co-op plan to recover lithium from its brine?
The mystery: Gold flakes recovered from an old mining camp still shine, while the iron picks and pans buried beside them have rusted away. Not far from many such camps, hot brine pumped up by geothermal power plants carries dissolved lithium, the metal in rechargeable batteries.
describe an atom in terms of protons, neutrons and electrons, use atomic number and mass number to find each, and ask testable questions about why elements behave differently.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Two objects sit side by side in a museum case: a gold flake and an iron pick, both dug from the same wet ground at an old mining camp after well over a century. Write what you expect each to look like today, and one question the pair raises for you.
Gold and iron tools sat in the same wet ground for more than a century. Which statement best predicts what you would find today?
The phenomenon. Prospectors at an old gold-mining camp pulled gold out of streams by hand. Gold nuggets and flakes from that era, now in museum cases, still shine. The iron picks, pans and shovels the miners used are brown with rust, and many have crumbled. Both metals sat in the same wet ground for the same years. Why does one element react with air and water while another does not? That question organizes this unit. To answer it we need a model of what an element is made of.
The nuclear atom. Every atom has a tiny, dense nucleus made of protons (charge +1) and neutrons (no charge), surrounded by much lighter electrons (charge −1). Protons and neutrons each have a mass of about 1 atomic mass unit (u); an electron has about 1/1,836 of that. So almost all of an atom’s mass is in the nucleus, but almost all of its volume is the space where its electrons are found. If the nucleus of a gold atom were the size of a marble, the atom would be the size of a football stadium.
Atomic number defines the element. The number of protons is the atomic number, Z. Every gold atom has 79 protons; an atom with 78 protons is platinum, not gold. In a neutral atom the number of electrons equals the number of protons, because the charges must balance. The mass number, A, counts protons plus neutrons. So neutrons = A − Z.
Worked example 1. Gold-197: Z = 79, so 79 protons and 79 electrons; neutrons = 197 − 79 = 118. Iron-56: Z = 26, so 26 protons and 26 electrons, and 56 − 26 = 30 neutrons. Gold has about three times as many protons as iron. Size of the nucleus is not what makes gold unreactive, though; the explanation lies in how its electrons are arranged, which we develop over the next lessons.
Isotopes. Atoms of one element can have different numbers of neutrons. Carbon-12 has 6 protons and 6 neutrons; carbon-14 has 6 protons and 8 neutrons. They are isotopes of carbon: same element, same chemistry, different mass. The atomic mass printed on the periodic table (12.011 for carbon) is an average over the isotopes found in nature, weighted by how common each is.
Ions. When an atom gains or loses electrons it becomes an ion. A sodium atom that loses one electron has 11 protons and 10 electrons, a net charge of +1 (Na+). A chlorine atom that gains one has 17 protons and 18 electrons, charge −1 (Cl−). Chemical reactions change electrons, never protons: that is why reactions cannot turn iron into gold.
Worked example 2: reading a symbol. The notation 7Li+ means lithium (Z = 3) with mass number 7 and a charge of +1. Protons 3; neutrons 7 − 3 = 4; electrons 3 − 1 = 2. Lithium is the element our client cares about, so you will meet this ion all unit.
Asking good questions. A scientific question can be tested with evidence. “Why is gold pretty?” cannot. “Does iron rust faster in salt water than in fresh water?” can. As you build the question board today, sort questions into ones we can investigate in the lab, ones we can answer with published data (NIST, OpenStax), and ones that need a model before they can be answered.
Reading. OpenStax Chemistry 2e, chapter 2 (atoms, isotopes and ions), CC BY 4.0.
Work with a partner. Show the subtraction for every neutron count.
Complete the particle table for eight atoms and ions in your notebook. Use the periodic table for Z.
| Symbol | Z | A | Protons | Neutrons | Electrons | Charge |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Li-7 | ||||||
| Li-6 | ||||||
| Na+ (A = 23) | ||||||
| Cl− (A = 35) | ||||||
| Fe-56 | ||||||
| Au-197 | ||||||
| O2− (A = 16) | ||||||
| Ca2+ (A = 40) |
Pick two rows of your table. For each, explain in one sentence how you found the neutron count and the electron count.
We have a phenomenon and a model of the atom. Next class, you meet the client who needs this model, and we build the Wonder Board.
Exit ticket: a reaction can turn shiny iron into rust, but no reaction can turn iron into gold. Use the words proton and electron to explain why.
Materials: a periodic table per student, images of a gold nugget and a rusted iron tool (generic museum photos), chart paper for the question board, devices for the PhET sim or paper particle tables.
Listen for: “neutrons have a negative charge”; mass number confused with atomic mass; ions explained as gaining or losing protons.
Support / stretch: give the formula card “neutrons = A − Z; electrons = Z − charge.” Stretch: estimate what fraction of a gold-197 atom’s mass its 79 electrons contribute (about 79 ÷ (197 × 1,836), well under 0.1%).