
plan and carry out a fair test of how water temperature and tablet surface area change the rate of an effervescent reaction, graph the results and explain them with collision theory.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Write the independent, dependent and two controlled variables you would use to test whether water temperature changes how fast an antacid tablet fizzes.
Rank the reaction times from shortest to longest: whole tablet in warm water, whole tablet in ice water, crushed tablet in room-temperature water.
The reaction. An effervescent antacid tablet contains sodium hydrogen carbonate (baking soda) and citric acid, pressed together dry. Nothing happens while the tablet is dry, because the particles cannot move to collide. Drop it in water and the acid and the hydrogen carbonate dissolve, collide and react, producing carbon dioxide bubbles, the same kind of acid-carbonate reaction you used in the sealed bag in Unit 3. When the fizzing stops, the reaction is complete. That makes it a safe, inexpensive way to measure a reaction rate. This lab runs two 50-minute periods.
Measuring rate. Record the time from when the tablet touches the water until the last fizzing stops. A shorter time means a faster reaction. To turn time into a rate, use rate = 1 ÷ time; multiply by 100 so the numbers are easier to read. Worked example 1. A tablet that takes 48 s has a relative rate of 100 ÷ 48 = 2.1, and one that takes 24 s has a rate of 4.2, twice as fast.
Two experiments. Experiment 1 changes temperature: ice water (about 5 °C), room-temperature water (about 20 °C) and warm tap water (about 40 °C), always with a whole tablet. Experiment 2 changes surface area at room temperature: a whole tablet, a tablet broken into quarters, and a tablet crushed to powder in a folded paper. Each experiment changes one variable only.
Controlled variables. Same brand and size of tablet, same volume of water (150 mL), same cup, no stirring, and the same person calling “stop.” Measure the actual water temperature with a thermometer right before each drop; do not assume. Run each condition at least twice and average the times, because judging the exact end of fizzing is the largest source of uncertainty.
Procedure. (1) Measure 150 mL of ice water (remove the ice), record its temperature, drop in one whole tablet and start the timer; stop when fizzing ends. Repeat once. (2) Repeat with room-temperature and warm tap water, recording the temperature each time. (3) At room temperature, time one whole tablet, one broken into four pieces, and one crushed to powder (tip all the powder in at once). Repeat each once. (4) Average the two times for each condition and calculate relative rate = 100 ÷ average time. (5) Graph relative rate against temperature (line graph) and relative rate for the three surface areas (bar graph). (6) Add your averages to the class table.
| Condition | Water temp (°C) | Time trial 1 (s) | Time trial 2 (s) | Average time (s) | Relative rate (100 ÷ avg) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cold, whole | |||||
| Room, whole | |||||
| Warm, whole | |||||
| Room, quartered | |||||
| Room, crushed |
Worked example 2: what to expect (sample data). Illustrative results from a trial run: 5 °C took about 92 s, 20 °C about 48 s and 40 °C about 24 s, so the rate at 40 °C was almost four times the rate at 5 °C (92 ÷ 24 = 3.8). Your numbers will differ with the brand and the water, and that is fine: the pattern is the evidence. Crushed tablets typically finish in a fraction of the whole-tablet time.
Graphing. For Experiment 1, put temperature on the x-axis (the independent variable) and relative rate on the y-axis (dependent). Plot the averages and draw a smooth curve, not dot-to-dot lines. For Experiment 2, surface area is a category, so use a bar graph. A graph lets you describe a trend (“rate increases as temperature increases, and the increase gets steeper”) and compare it with the rule of thumb from Lesson 4.01.
Connecting to collision theory. In warm water the dissolved acid and carbonate particles move faster, and more of their collisions have at least the activation energy needed to break bonds. A crushed tablet exposes far more surface, so more particles dissolve and meet at once. Your explanation should name the particle-level cause for each variable, not just the trend.
Answer as you collect data; return to the cards after clean-up.
Lab analysis, in your Rates Notebook.
Compare your warm-to-cold rate ratio with the ‘doubles every 10 °C’ rule of thumb. Does your data roughly agree? Suggest why it might not match exactly, and name one change to the procedure that would reduce uncertainty (for example, measuring gas volume).
Use your results to explain why strawberries are cooled within hours of picking and why cut fruit spoils faster than whole fruit.
Your graphs show how temperature and surface area change rate. Next class: what happens when a reaction runs both ways at once?
Exit ticket: predict the time for a whole tablet in 30 °C water from your graph, and explain your prediction with collisions.
Materials (per group): 8–10 effervescent antacid tablets of one brand, three clear 250 mL cups, a 250 mL graduated cylinder, ice water, room-temperature water and warm tap water (below about 45 °C), thermometer, timer, folded paper and spoon for crushing, goggles, paper towels.
Two periods: day 1 both experiments; day 2 graphing, class data and the CER. No-lab alternative: recorded trials with an on-screen timer and thermometer and the sample data set, plus the PhET Gas Properties sim.
Listen for: “warm water has more energy so the tablet melts”; dot-to-dot graphs; rate and time confused.
Support / stretch: pre-labeled graph axes and a CER frame. Stretch: collect CO2 in an inverted graduated cylinder over water and plot volume against time to find the initial rate.