use a system of equations to solve our unit puzzle, connect it to the driving question, and reflect on how my thinking changed.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. In Part 1, Maya (4 meters per second) caught Theo (3 meters per second, 30 meters ahead) after 30 seconds, 120 meters from the start. Now they race again, and Theo gets a bigger head start.
Maya starts at the start line and runs 4 meters per second. Theo starts 60 meters ahead and runs 3 meters per second. When will Maya catch Theo?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Back to the puzzle. In Part 1 we found where Maya and Theo meet by making tables and graphs. Now we can answer exactly with a system of equations, the same math we used for every plan in our guide.
Worked example 1: Ruby solves the rematch. Let t be seconds and d be meters from the start line. Maya: d = 4t. Theo: d = 3t + 60. Substitute: 4t = 3t + 60, so t = 60. Then d = 4(60) = 240. Check: 3(60) + 60 = 240. The runners meet after 60 seconds, 240 meters from the start line. On a graph, Maya’s line is proportional, with a unit rate of 4 meters per second as its slope, and Theo’s line starts at 60 on the d-axis.
Worked example 2: Jordan changes the race. What if Theo also runs 4 meters per second? Then 4t = 4t + 60 gives 0 = 60, which is false. No solution: the lines are parallel and Maya never catches Theo. If Theo also started at the start line, 4t = 4t would be true for every t: infinitely many solutions, because they run side by side the whole time.
The same story as our plans. Theo’s head start is like a plan’s lower starting cost. Maya’s faster speed is like a plan’s greater rate. The faster one always catches up at the intersection point, the break-even.
Our driving question. When does one plan become cheaper than another? At the break-even point, where the plan with the smaller rate catches the plan with the smaller starting amount. After that, the smaller rate keeps winning.
Reflect like a mathematician. Think about what you could not do at the start of the unit and what you can do now.
Solve, then reflect.
One more race, then your reflection.
Their friend Kai starts 75 meters ahead of the start line and runs 2.5 meters per second. Maya starts at the line at 4 meters per second. Write a system, solve it, check it, and sketch both lines.
Reflection: write a short letter to next year's 8th graders. Tell them one mistake you learned to avoid, one strategy that helped you solve systems, and why comparing plans matters for real families.
Lines, rates and decisions: you can now find exactly when one choice catches up with another.
Exit ticket: how did your thinking about the runner puzzle change from the first week of the unit to today?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 8, guided practice 12, independent 10, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: adding the speeds (7 meters per second gives 60/7 ≈ 8.57 s); reporting only the time and not the place; thinking the runner with the head start always stays ahead.
Supports: a table of both runners’ positions every 10 seconds; letter frame with sentence starters. Stretch: find the head start that makes Maya catch Kai at exactly 300 meters (4t = 300 gives t = 75; 300 − 2.5 × 75 = 112.5 meters).
Answer guide: predict 60 seconds; t = 60 s; 240 m; no solution; true; 4 meters per second; y = 3x + 60. Kai: d = 4t and d = 2.5t + 75; 1.5t = 75, t = 50 s, d = 200 m; check 2.5(50) + 75 = 200. Driving question: a sample strong answer says the plan with the smaller rate becomes cheaper after the intersection of the two cost lines, for example Plan A after 2 lines in Mei’s comparison. Commute numbers come from the Census Bureau release of March 18, 2021 (opened 2026-11-20); the runners are the unit phenomenon from Part 1 (2.01 and 2.14), with invented speeds.
U.S. Census Bureau, Census Bureau Estimates Show Average One-Way Travel Time to Work Rises to All-Time High (March 18, 2021) · U.S. government work, public domain
The U.S. Census Bureau asks people in the American Community Survey how long it takes them to get to work. In a March 2021 news release, it reported that the average one-way commute in the United States rose to a new high of 27.6 minutes in 2019.
In 2006, the average was 25.0 minutes. The bureau described the rise of about 2.6 minutes as an increase of about 10 percent.
Short commutes became less common. In 2006, 14.8 percent of commuters traveled less than 10 minutes; by 2019, only 11.9 percent did. Commutes of 60 minutes or longer grew from 7.9 percent to 9.8 percent of workers.
About 57 percent of workers left for work between 6:00 and 8:29 a.m. Those who left between 6:00 and 6:29 a.m. had the longest average trip, 32.8 minutes. Trips on public transportation were longest of all: workers who rode a bus averaged 46.6 minutes.
The averages do not include people who worked from home. The 2019 data come from survey interviews held from January 1 through December 31, 2019.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Census Bureau Estimates Show Average One-Way Travel Time to Work Rises to All-Time High (March 18, 2021) (census.gov)