Science in Numbers
How do scientists write and compare numbers too big or too small to imagine?
The mystery: Is the square root of 2 a “real” length? Draw a 1-by-1 square’s diagonal and find out.
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
tell whether a number can be written as a fraction of two integers, and plan what our library placards must show visitors about pi and other numbers.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Write each number as a fraction if you can: 0.5, 3, −4, 0.25 and 3.14. Is there any number you think can never be written as a fraction?
Pi Day is March 14 because pi starts 3.14. Is pi exactly 3.14?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Who our placards are for. Our Science in Numbers placards will stand in the public library, where children, parents, grandparents and teens walk by. A placard has only a few seconds to grab a visitor. It needs one big idea, one picture and numbers that are exactly right.
Two families of numbers. A rational number is any number that can be written as a fraction a/b, where a and b are integers and b is not 0. An irrational number is a number that cannot. The word comes from “ratio”: rational numbers are ratio numbers.
Worked example 1: proving numbers are rational. Jamal sorts four numbers. Step 1: 0.5 = 5/10 = 1/2. Step 2: 3 = 3/1. Step 3: −4 = −4/1. Step 4: 3.14 = 314/100. Each one is an integer over an integer, so all four are rational. Even the short version of pi, 3.14, is rational.
Worked example 2: why pi is different. Sofia reads that pi’s digits never end and never repeat. Step 1: 3.14 = 314/100, but 3.14 is not pi; pi is a bit more (3.14159…). Step 2: 3.1416 = 31,416/10,000, but that is not pi either. Step 3: any decimal that stops can be written over 10, 100, 1,000 and so on, so a decimal that stops is always rational. Step 4: pi never stops, so none of these fractions is exactly pi. Mathematicians have proved that no fraction of integers equals pi.
Where √2 fits. Last lesson, √2 was between 1.4 and 1.5. If its digits also never end or repeat, it is irrational too. We will investigate that, and we will place both numbers on a number line for visitors.
Placard criteria. Every placard will (1) give one big idea in plain words, (2) show a number line or picture, (3) use correct, checked numbers and (4) name the source of every real fact.
For each number, try to write it as an integer over an integer.
Plan our audience and our questions.
Write 1.5, −2, 0.75 and 10 each as an integer over an integer.
List three kinds of library visitors. For each, write one thing a number placard should do so that visitor understands it.
Add two new Wonder Board questions about pi or √2.
We know our audience and the two families of numbers. Next we investigate what happens when we turn fractions into decimals.
Exit ticket: in your own words, what makes a number rational? Give one example and show why it fits.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 12, guided practice 10, placard planning and exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: facts on pi (often shortened to 3.14, infinite digits, trillions calculated, irrational: digits do not repeat or show a pattern and cannot be written as a ratio of two integers; JPL uses pi for round bodies and orbits; the Pi in the Sky challenge) are from the NASA page (last updated 2024-11-06). The circle definition of pi in the summary’s first sentence is basic established knowledge. The proof that pi is irrational is beyond grade 8; state it as a proven fact.
Likely misconceptions: “a fraction must have whole-number parts, so negatives are not rational”; “3.14/2 is a fraction, so it shows rationality” (it is, but it does not use integers; 314/200 does); “pi = 3.14.”
Supports: a sorting mat with two columns, “integer over integer” and “not yet sure.” Stretch: is 0 rational? (Yes, 0 = 0/1.)
Answer guide: 1.5 = 3/2, −2 = −2/1, 0.75 = 3/4, 10 = 10/1. The pi placard should say 3.14 is a close, rational estimate and pi’s digits go on forever without a pattern. Exit ticket: a rational number can be written as an integer over a nonzero integer, for example 0.2 = 1/5.
NASA Science, Celebrate Pi Day the NASA Way · NASA content, generally not subject to U.S. copyright (NASA media usage guidelines)
Pi is the number you get when you divide a circle’s distance around by its distance across. People often shorten pi to 3.14, which is why Pi Day is March 14, written 3/14. But pi really has an infinite number of digits. Using computer programs, mathematicians have found trillions of them so far.
Scientists and engineers at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) in California use pi often. It helps them learn about round objects such as moons, planets and stars, and it helps them track the orbits of satellites and spacecraft. JPL even writes a yearly “Pi in the Sky” challenge of real problems its scientists solve with pi.
The page explains that pi belongs to a special group called irrational numbers. Their digits go on forever, never repeat and show no pattern. An irrational number also cannot be written as a ratio (a fraction) of two integers. Integers are the whole numbers and their negatives, like −1, −2 and −3. Because the digits have no pattern, pi fans use Pi Day to test how many digits they can memorize.
Source: NASA Science, Celebrate Pi Day the NASA Way (science.nasa.gov)