check placards for correct roots, exponents, scientific notation, rational and irrational labels and number-line placement, and give specific feedback.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. In 1999, NASA lost a spacecraft at Mars. Read today’s reading. Then predict.
What do you think caused the Mars Climate Orbiter to be lost?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Critique like a scientist. Today every team visits other placards and checks them. Use three stems: I notice, I wonder and Try. Be kind, be specific and give one next step.
Checklist. (1) Is each root, power and product correct? Check it a second way. (2) Is scientific notation written with a number from 1 to less than 10? (3) Does every number have a unit? (4) Are irrational numbers labeled “about”? (5) On The Root Number Line, is every point in the right order and close to the right place?
Rational or irrational? A rational number can be written as a fraction of integers, and its decimal ends or repeats: 0.125 = 1/8 and 0.333… = 1/3. √49 = 7 is rational. √2, √50 and π are irrational: their decimals never end and never repeat.
Worked example 1: Hana checks √2. A placard says “√2 = 1.41.” Hana squares it: 1.41 × 1.41 = 1.9881, not 2. Her feedback: “I notice 1.41 squared is 1.9881. Try writing √2 ≈ 1.41, because √2 is irrational and 1.41 is only an estimate.”
Worked example 2: Ravi checks a repeating decimal. A card says 0.666… = 6/10. Ravi lets x = 0.666… Then 10x = 6.666… Subtract: 10x − x = 6.666… − 0.666…, so 9x = 6 and x = 6/9 = 2/3. Since 6/10 = 0.6 exactly, the card is wrong. The same method shows 0.4545… (45 repeating) = 45/99 = 5/11, using 100x because two digits repeat.
Ordering on the number line. Compare decimals to the same place. √10 ≈ 3.16 because 3.16 × 3.16 = 9.9856. So from least to greatest: 3.1, π (3.14159…), 22/7 (3.142857…), √10 (3.162…).
Practice checking before the gallery walk.
Gallery walk. Visit at least two other placards.
For each placard you visit, check two numbers a second way, check every unit, and write one I notice, one I wonder and one Try note.
At The Root Number Line, place √30, 5.4, 17/3 and √25 in order and estimate √30 to the nearest tenth without a calculator. Say which are rational.
Back at your own placard, list the feedback you received. Circle the two changes you will make first and explain why.
NASA’s Mars Climate Orbiter traveled to Mars for about nine months. The math of its path depended on numbers passed from software on the ground to software on the spacecraft. The ground software used English units and the spacecraft’s software used metric units, and the difference was not translated.
Each number looked fine on its own. But a number in one unit system read as if it were in the other is a wrong number. The errors added up in the path calculations, and the orbiter came too close to Mars. NASA’s last contact was September 23, 1999, and an investigation found the spacecraft burned up in the Martian atmosphere.
Our placards are much smaller projects, but the lesson is the same: every number needs a unit, and every number deserves a second check.
Think about it: Which placard numbers in our gallery could be misread if the unit were missing? What check would catch the problem?
Checking is not about catching people. It is about getting it right for our visitors.
Exit ticket: what is one unit or label mistake you caught today, and how would a visitor have misread it?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 7, case study 6, guided practice 10, gallery walk 8, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: calling every long or repeating decimal irrational; writing 0.666… as 6/10; using 10x when two digits repeat; ordering by the number of digits; treating a rounded root as exact. This lesson revisits Part 1’s rational and irrational work (CC.2.1.8.E.1, CC.2.1.8.E.4) and assesses it formatively with the guided quiz and the Root Number Line task.
Supports: feedback cards printed with the three stems; a number line from 3 to 6 marked in tenths; a perfect-squares chart. Stretch: convert 0.272727… (27/99 = 3/11) and 0.1666… (1/6).
Answer guide: √12; 5/11; 9; false (4/33); 3.1, π, 22/7, √10; about 30 times. 0.125 card: it ends, so it is rational, 125/1000 = 1/8. Root Number Line: √25 = 5, 5.4, √30 ≈ 5.5 (5.42 = 29.16, 5.52 = 30.25; more exactly about 5.48), 17/3 = 5.666…; √25, 5.4 and 17/3 are rational. The case study uses only facts from the NASA page in the reading.
NASA Science, Mars Climate Orbiter · NASA content, generally not subject to U.S. copyright (NASA media usage guidelines)
NASA built the Mars Climate Orbiter to study Mars from orbit. It was also supposed to relay messages for the Mars Polar Lander and other probes.
The mission failed because of a navigation error. NASA explains that the error came from a failure to translate English units into metric units. Software on the ground used English units, while the software on the spacecraft worked in metric units. Because the two did not match, the calculations of the spacecraft’s path were wrong.
Those wrong calculations sent the orbiter too close to Mars. NASA’s last contact with it was on September 23, 1999, nine months after launch. An investigation found that the spacecraft burned up in Mars’ atmosphere.
English units, also called U.S. customary units, include inches, feet, miles and pounds. Metric units include centimeters, meters, kilometers and kilograms. Both systems are fine on their own. The trouble comes when a number in one system is read as if it were in the other. Every number needs its unit, and someone needs to check it.
Source: NASA Science, Mars Climate Orbiter (science.nasa.gov)