estimate √2 and √3 to the hundredth by squaring decimals, and explain why the decimal for √2 can never stop.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Without a calculator, find 1.41 × 1.41 and 1.42 × 1.42. Is √2 between them? Use an area model if it helps.
If we keep adding decimal places, will some decimal times itself equal exactly 2?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
The squeeze. To estimate a square root without a calculator, trap it between two numbers, then make the trap smaller one decimal place at a time.
Worked example 1: √2 to the hundredth. Zoe already knows 1.4² = 1.96 and 1.5² = 2.25, so √2 is between 1.4 and 1.5. Step 1: try 1.41: 1.41 × 1.41 = 1.9881, still under 2. Step 2: try 1.42: 1.42 × 1.42 = 2.0164, over 2. Step 3: so 1.41 < √2 < 1.42. Step 4: 2 − 1.9881 = 0.0119 and 2.0164 − 2 = 0.0164, so √2 is closer to 1.41. To the nearest hundredth, √2 ≈ 1.41.
Worked example 2: √3. Isaiah estimates √3. Step 1: 1² = 1 and 2² = 4, so it is between 1 and 2. Step 2: 1.7² = 2.89 and 1.8² = 3.24, so it is between 1.7 and 1.8. Step 3: 1.73² = 2.9929 and 1.74² = 3.0276. Step 4: 3 − 2.9929 = 0.0071 and 3.0276 − 3 = 0.0276, so √3 ≈ 1.73.
One more squeeze. 1.414² = 1.999396 and 1.415² = 2.002225. The tablet’s 1.41421296 squared is about 1.9999983. Closer and closer, but never exactly 2.
Why it never stops. Look at the last digit of a decimal and the last digit of its square: 1 gives 1, 2 gives 4, 3 gives 9, 4 gives 6, 5 gives 5, 6 gives 6, 7 gives 9, 8 gives 4, 9 gives 1. The square of a decimal that stops always ends in one of these nonzero digits, so it can never be exactly 2.000. That means √2 is not a terminating decimal. Mathematicians in ancient Greece proved more: √2 cannot be any fraction at all, so its digits never end and never repeat. √2 is irrational.
For our placards. We will write √2 ≈ 1.41 and pi ≈ 3.14, using the ≈ sign, which means “is about equal to.” Using = would be a false statement.
Make a squeeze table: guess, guess squared, too small or too big.
Squeeze two more square roots.
Estimate √5 to the nearest hundredth. Show your squeeze table. (Hint: start with 2.23 and 2.24.)
Which statement is true?
The Babylonian value was 1.41421296. Is it a little too big or a little too small? How do you know?
√2 never stops and never repeats: it is irrational. Next we meet pi by measuring real circles.
Exit ticket: estimate √3 to the nearest tenth and show the two squares that prove it.
Pacing: Do Now 6 min, reading 6, mini lesson 12, guided practice 11, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: tablet facts (digits 1, 24, 51, 10; 1.41421296…; 305,470/216,000; greatest known computational accuracy in the ancient world; six decimal digits; less than one part in 2 million; general procedure; BM 96957 + VAT 6598; Neugebauer and Sachs, 1945; Yale 3D model) are from the Wikipedia article opened 2026-11-20 and retold without quotation (CC BY-SA). Squares checked with Python: 1.41² = 1.9881, 1.42² = 2.0164, 1.414² = 1.999396, 1.415² = 2.002225, 1.41421296² = 1.99999830; 1.7² = 2.89, 1.8² = 3.24, 1.73² = 2.9929, 1.74² = 3.0276; 2.2² = 4.84, 2.3² = 5.29, 2.23² = 4.9729, 2.24² = 5.0176. The last-digit argument proves only that √2 does not terminate; the full proof that it is not a fraction is stated, not shown.
Likely misconceptions: 1.41 × 1.41 = 1.1681 (squaring the parts on their own, 1 × 1 + 0.41 × 0.41, and dropping the middle terms); choosing the upper value whenever the square is “over”; writing √2 = 1.41 with an equals sign.
Supports: an area model for squaring a decimal: (1 + 0.4 + 0.01)² split into parts; a printed squeeze table. Stretch: estimate √2 to the thousandth (1.414, since 2 − 1.999396 = 0.000604 is less than 2.002225 − 2 = 0.002225).
Answer guide: placard: “Square any decimal that stops and its last digit is never 0, so the answer is never exactly 2.” √5: 2.23² = 4.9729 (0.0271 under) and 2.24² = 5.0176 (0.0176 over), so √5 ≈ 2.24. Babylonian value: its square 1.9999983 is under 2, so it is a little too small. Exit ticket: 1.7² = 2.89 and 1.8² = 3.24; 3 is 0.11 from 2.89 and 0.24 from 3.24, so √3 ≈ 1.7.
Wikipedia, YBC 7289 · Source text by Wikipedia contributors, “YBC 7289,” Wikipedia, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0 (creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0). Our summary is adapted from it in our own words, with nothing quoted, and is shared under the same license
The value of the square root of 2 on tablet YBC 7289 is given as four base-60 digits: 1, 24, 51 and 10. In our decimals it is 1.41421296…. The exact fraction it stands for is 305,470/216,000.
The article describes this as the most accurate calculation known from anywhere in the ancient world. It is correct to about six decimal places and is off by less than one part in 2 million.
How could anyone be so accurate about 3,700 years ago? Experts say a number this precise must come from a general method, not just a rough estimate. Another Babylonian tablet, known as BM 96957 + VAT 6598, shows an iterative procedure: a set of steps you repeat, where each round gives a closer answer than the last.
The importance of YBC 7289 was first recognized by the scholars Otto Neugebauer and Abraham Sachs in 1945. Today Yale has even made a digital 3D model of the tablet that can be printed.
Source: Wikipedia, YBC 7289 (en.wikipedia.org)