revise our guide pages using feedback and extend a comparison to three plans by finding every break-even point.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Sample Plan C costs $60 a month plus $5 per line. Compare it with Plan A, $35 a month plus $10 per line.
Plans A (35 + 10x) and C (60 + 5x) tie at how many lines?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revision makes a guide trustworthy. Start with the two changes you circled in the gallery walk. Fix any equation that fails a check, then make sure the page tells a family which plan to choose for every amount.
Worked example 1: Mei adds a third plan. Plans A = 35 + 10x, B = 15 + 20x and C = 60 + 5x. Find every pair’s break-even point. A and B: x = 2, $55. A and C: x = 5, $85. B and C: 15 + 20x = 60 + 5x, so 15x = 45 and x = 3, $75. Now test whole numbers of lines. 1 line: A $45, B $35, C $65, so B. 3 lines: A $65, B $75, C $75, so A. 6 lines: A $95, B $135, C $90, so C. The guide says: B for 1 line, A for 2 to 5 lines (with ties at 2 and 5), C for 6 or more.
Worked example 2: Zara’s time-of-day plan. A sample flat plan costs 17 cents per kWh. A sample time-of-day plan costs 25 cents per kWh at peak hours and 10 cents at other times. Zara’s family uses 600 kWh a month, and p of those are at peak. Flat: 0.17(600) = $102. Time-of-day: 0.25p + 0.10(600 − p) = 0.25p + 60 − 0.10p = 0.15p + 60. Set equal: 0.15p + 60 = 102, so 0.15p = 42 and p = 280. Check: 0.25(280) + 0.10(320) = 70 + 32 = 102. The time-of-day plan is cheaper if fewer than 280 kWh are used at peak.
Before and after. A weak card says “Plan C is best.” A revised card says “Plan C is cheapest for 6 or more lines; here is the equation, the table, the graph and the check.”
Check the slopes. Each plan’s line should rise by its rate. Pick two points on your graph and draw a slope triangle to confirm m, and make sure the line crosses the y-axis at b.
Work on the three-plan comparison, then revise your own page.
Revise, then extend.
Make your revisions. Then add a “Which plan for which family?” box that names the best plan for a small, medium and large amount of use, with the break-even points that separate them.
Extension: add a sample third plan to your page. Find all three break-even points, make a table, and explain the cheapest plan in each range.
Three plans need three checks. A careful guide does them all.
Exit ticket: why can a plan be the cheapest for some amounts but not for others? Use slopes and y-intercepts in your answer.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 8, guided practice 10, revision and extension 13, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: assuming the plan with the lowest starting amount is always cheapest; finding only one of the three break-even points; forgetting to distribute 0.10 to both 600 and p; swapping m and b on a card.
Supports: a three-row table template for x = 0 to 7; color one line per plan. Stretch: find the peak usage that makes Zara’s two plans tie if her family uses 800 kWh (0.15p + 80 = 136, p = 373.33, so about 373 kWh).
Answer guide: warm-up 5 lines; Plan A at $75; 3 lines; true; p = 280; change to y = 20x + 15; $20 per line. Exit ticket: lines with different slopes cross, so the plan with the smaller rate wins after the break-even and the plan with the smaller starting amount wins before it. The time-of-day rates are sample; the EIA page describes time-of-day pricing in general (opened 2026-11-20).
U.S. Energy Information Administration, Electricity Explained: Prices and Factors Affecting Prices · U.S. government work, public domain
The EIA’s page on electricity prices also explains why the cost of electricity changes over a day and over a year.
The cost to supply electricity changes minute by minute. The wholesale price on the power grid reflects the real-time cost of supplying it. Demand is usually highest in the afternoon and early evening, called peak hours, so costs are usually higher then.
Most consumers do not see these daily changes. They pay prices based on the seasonal average cost of providing electricity. Prices are usually highest in the summer, when total demand is high and more expensive power plants are added to meet it.
Some utilities offer customers time-of-day pricing. The EIA says these plans encourage people to save electricity and to reduce peak demand. With such a plan, using power at the right time can lower a bill.
For comparison, the EIA reports that the average U.S. residential price in 2025 was about 17.30 cents per kWh. A family deciding between a flat price and a time-of-day plan needs to know how much of its electricity it uses at peak hours.
Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration, Electricity Explained: Prices and Factors Affecting Prices (eia.gov)