compare two plans given in different forms by their slopes and intercepts, and use a table or graph to find where they cost the same.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Gym A (sample) shows a price table: 1 visit $12, 2 visits $24, 3 visits $36. Gym B (sample) says: $20 to join, then $8 a visit. Which would you pick for 2 visits? For 10?
Is there a number of visits where the two gyms cost the same?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Compare the parts. To compare two linear plans, compare their slopes (the cost of each use) and their y-intercepts (the cost at the start). A plan with a lower start and a higher slope begins cheaper but grows faster, so at some point it becomes more expensive.
Worked example 1: the two gyms. Maria compares them. Step 1: Gym A’s table is proportional: 12 ÷ 1 = 24 ÷ 2 = 12, so y = 12x (m = 12, b = 0). Step 2: Gym B’s words give y = 8x + 20 (m = 8, b = 20). Step 3: table: at 4 visits A = $48 and B = $52; at 5 visits A = $60 and B = $60; at 6 visits A = $72 and B = $68. Step 4: the plans cost the same at 5 visits. Gym A is cheaper below 5 visits, and Gym B is cheaper above 5.
On a graph. Both lines on one grid cross at (5, 60). Left of the crossing, A’s line is lower; right of it, B’s line is lower. The crossing point is the break-even point for our guide.
Worked example 2: park plans. Ben’s family pays $30 per park visit with standard car passes (sample price, like Shenandoah’s), or $80 a year for America the Beautiful. Step 1: plan 1 is y = 30x; plan 2 is y = 80 (slope 0). Step 2: table: 2 visits $60, 3 visits $90. Step 3: plan 2 is cheaper from 3 visits on. Step 4: the graph of y = 30x crosses the horizontal line y = 80 between x = 2 and x = 3.
Comparing two proportional plans. If both plans have b = 0, they only meet at (0, 0), and the one with the smaller slope is always cheaper.
For our guide. Each comparison needs three things: each plan’s rate, each plan’s start, and the break-even point, with a sentence telling families which plan wins on each side of it. In Part 2 we will find break-even points with algebra.
Use the gym plans and the park plans from the mini lesson.
Write one comparison for our guide.
Phones (sample): Plan X, $15 per GB; Plan Y, y = 10x + 20. Make a table for 0 to 6 GB, graph both, find the break-even point, and write a two-sentence tip for families.
A senior pays $20 a year for the pass. With $30 car passes, how many visits make the pass the cheaper plan?
Which pieces of the NPS reading should our guide include for a family, and which would you leave out? Explain.
Slopes, intercepts and a crossing point tell the whole story of two plans. Next we hunt for common slope mistakes before they reach our guide.
Exit ticket: Plan P is y = 6x + 10 and Plan Q is y = 8x. Which is cheaper for 3 uses? For 8 uses? Where do they cost the same?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lesson 10, guided practice 12, guide tip and exit ticket 6.
Accuracy: pass types, agencies covered, one vehicle or four people, $80 resident, $250 non-resident, $20 and $80 senior, free passes, 250 volunteer hours, non-refundable and photo ID are from the NPS Entrance Passes page read 2026-11-20. The $30 car pass matches Shenandoah’s page (2.02). Gyms and phones are sample data. Break-even points here are found with tables and graphs only; solving systems is Part 2 (CC.2.2.8.B.3).
Likely misconceptions: treating the joining fee as a per-visit price; thinking the plan that starts cheaper is always cheaper.
Supports: pre-made tables with both plans side by side. Stretch: a third gym, y = 10x + 6 (sample): where does it meet Gym A? (3 visits, $36.)
Answer guide: phones: X = Y at 4 GB ($60); X is cheaper below 4 GB, Y above. From equations: the smaller b wins for very small use, the smaller m wins for heavy use. Exit ticket: 3 uses P $28, Q $24 (Q cheaper); 8 uses P $58, Q $64 (P cheaper); same at 5 uses, $40.
National Park Service, Entrance Passes · U.S. government work, public domain
The National Park Service explains that most of its sites are free, but some charge an entrance fee. Visitors to those parks need one of three passes: a standard pass for one park for 1 to 7 days, an annual pass for one park, or an America the Beautiful pass.
The America the Beautiful pass covers entrance fees and standard day-use fees at federal recreation sites. These include lands run by the National Park Service, the U.S. Forest Service, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the Bureau of Land Management, the Bureau of Reclamation and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. Where a site charges per car, it covers one private vehicle; where it charges per person, it covers four people.
Prices depend on who buys it. The annual pass costs $80 for U.S. citizens and residents and $250 for non-residents. People 62 and older pay $20 a year or $80 for life. Passes are free for current military members, people with a permanent disability, U.S. fourth graders, and volunteers with 250 service hours.
Passes cannot be refunded, shared or replaced if lost, and pass holders must show a photo ID.
Source: National Park Service, Entrance Passes (nps.gov)