find and fix common errors in classifying, converting, estimating and ordering numbers, and explain why each wrong answer happened.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A sample placard draft says: “Pi = 3.14. The square root of 50 is about 25.” Find both mistakes and write a fix for each.
Which mistake would mislead a library visitor more?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Why a clinic? Library visitors will trust our placards. Before we write them, we hunt for the errors people make most and learn to explain the fix. For each error: name it, show why it happens, fix it and check.
Worked example 1: a repeating decimal written as a tenth. A sample student wrote 0.3 (the 3 repeats) = 3/10. Step 1: check: 3/10 = 0.3, which stops. Step 2: 0.3 (the 3 repeats) = 0.333… is bigger than 0.3, so the answer is wrong. Step 3: fix: let x = 0.333…; 10x = 3.333…; 9x = 3; x = 3/9 = 1/3. Step 4: check: 1 ÷ 3 = 0.3 (the 3 repeats).
Worked example 2: the wrong repeating block. Another sample student wrote 0.16 (the 6 repeats) = 16/99. Step 1: 16/99 = 0.16 (the 16 repeats) = 0.161616…, but 0.16 (the 6 repeats) = 0.1666…. They differ in the thousandths. Step 2: the student treated 16 as the repeating block, but only the 6 repeats. Step 3: fix: 100x − 10x = 16.666… − 1.666… = 15, so 90x = 15 and x = 1/6. Step 4: check: 1 ÷ 6 = 0.16 (the 6 repeats).
Estimating errors. Halving: √50 is not 25, because 25² = 625. Fix: 7² = 49, so √50 ≈ 7.1. Middle-guessing: √80 is not 8.5 just because it is between 8 and 9. Fix: 80 is next to 81, so it is about 8.9 (8.95² = 80.1025 > 80).
Classifying errors. “22/7 = π” is false: 22/7 is a rational approximation. “Every decimal that goes on forever is irrational” is false: 0.3 (the 3 repeats) goes on forever and equals 1/3. “0.1010010001… has a pattern, so it repeats” is false: no block repeats.
Ordering errors. With negatives, the number farther from 0 is smaller: −√5 ≈ −2.24 < −2.
For each sample error, decide if it is right or wrong. If it is wrong, write the fix.
Write your own error card for the placard team.
Fix this sample work: “0.8<span style="text-decoration: overline">3</span> (the 3 repeats) = 83/99.” Show the correct fraction and a check.
Which is a correct statement for a placard?
Write a mistake card: one wrong statement a library visitor might believe, the fix, and a one-line check.
Errors are clues. Next time we check everything we know and plan our number line placards.
Exit ticket: which error from today are you most likely to make? Write the check you will use to catch it.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 5, mini lesson 12, guided practice 13, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: pi facts (shortened to 3.14, Pi Day on 3/14, infinite digits, trillions calculated, used for circumference and surface area, JPL uses for moons, planets, stars, satellites and spacecraft; irrational; memorizing digits; sharing Pi Day photos and stories) are from the NASA page (updated 2024-11-06). The cake sentence is our own example. All sample errors re-derived: 3/10 = 0.3 ≠ 0.3 (the 3 repeats); 16/99 = 0.16 (the 16 repeats) ≠ 0.16 (the 6 repeats) (they differ in the thousandths, 0.161 vs 0.166); 45/100 = 0.45 ≠ 0.45 (the 45 repeats); 83/99 = 0.83 (the 83 repeats) ≠ 0.83 (the 3 repeats) = 5/6; 25² = 625; √80 ≈ 8.944; −√5 ≈ −2.236.
Likely misconceptions: the ones in the clinic; also thinking an estimate must be “wrong” because it is not exact. An estimate with ≈ is a true statement.
Supports: error cards with a sentence frame: “The mistake is… It happened because… The fix is… Check:…” Stretch: is 0.9 (the 9 repeats) < 1? (No, they are equal.)
Answer guide: 0.83 (the 3 repeats): 100x − 10x = 83.333… − 8.333… = 75, 90x = 75, x = 5/6; check 5 ÷ 6 = 0.83 (the 3 repeats). Explanations should name the cause, for example halving because the √ sign looks like an operation that shrinks a number.
NASA Science, Celebrate Pi Day the NASA Way · NASA content, generally not subject to U.S. copyright (NASA media usage guidelines)
NASA explains that pi is often shortened to 3.14. That short version is why people celebrate Pi Day on March 14, written 3/14. But 3.14 is only a nickname. Pi actually has an infinite number of digits, and mathematicians using computer programs have found trillions of them.
The page says pi is used to work out facts about circles and spheres, such as their circumference or surface area. Scientists and engineers at JPL use it to study moons, planets and stars and to track satellites and spacecraft.
Pi is an irrational number. Its digits never repeat and show no pattern, and it cannot be written as a ratio of two integers. Because its digits look random, pi fans like to test their memories on Pi Day by reciting as many digits as they can.
NASA encourages people to share photos and stories of their Pi Day activities. So a 3.14 cake is a fine way to celebrate. It just is not exactly pi.
Source: NASA Science, Celebrate Pi Day the NASA Way (science.nasa.gov)