Which Plan Is Better?
When does one plan become cheaper than another?
The mystery: Two runners start at different places and speeds. Where and when do they meet?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
use a table of times and distances to find where and when two runners meet, and tell which runner’s distance is proportional to time.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Sample race: Maya starts at the starting line and runs 4 meters every second. Theo gets a 30-meter head start and runs 3 meters every second. Both start when the whistle blows.
Will Maya ever catch Theo?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Welcome to Unit 2. This unit has a real job for you. You will make a Which Plan Is Better? consumer guide that helps East Allegheny families compare plans for park passes, gyms, phones and rides. Our driving question: When does one plan become cheaper than another? Surprisingly, a race between two runners holds the same math.
A rate in motion. A speed such as 4 meters per second is a rate. It tells how many meters are added for each second. The CDC uses rates too: brisk walking is 2.5 miles per hour or faster.
Worked example 1: Maya’s table. Aaliyah makes a table for Maya. Step 1: at 0 seconds Maya is at 0 meters. Step 2: each second adds 4 meters, so at 10 seconds she is at 4 × 10 = 40 meters. Step 3: at 20 seconds, 80 meters; at 30 seconds, 120 meters. Step 4: she checks the ratio distance ÷ time: 40 ÷ 10 = 4, 80 ÷ 20 = 4, 120 ÷ 30 = 4. The ratio never changes. Maya’s distance is proportional to time.
Worked example 2: Theo’s table and the meeting point. Marcus makes Theo’s table. Step 1: at 0 seconds Theo is already at 30 meters. Step 2: at 10 seconds he is at 30 + 3 × 10 = 60 meters. Step 3: at 20 seconds, 30 + 60 = 90 meters; at 30 seconds, 30 + 90 = 120 meters. Step 4: at 30 seconds both runners are at 120 meters, so they meet 120 meters from the start line, 30 seconds after the whistle.
Is Theo’s distance proportional? Check the ratios: 60 ÷ 10 = 6 and 90 ÷ 20 = 4.5. They are not equal, and at 0 seconds his distance is not 0. His head start breaks the pattern. Both runners still add a constant amount each second.
From races to plans. A plan with a sign-up fee is like a head start, and a price per visit is like a speed. When two plans “meet,” they cost the same. In this part we learn to graph these patterns and read their slopes.
Use the race tables from the mini lesson. Make your own table if it helps.
Walk test (sample data from your class). In pairs, one person walks 20 meters in the hallway while the other times it.
Record your partner's time for 20 meters. Find the walking rate in meters per second (round to the tenth). Then make a table of distance for 0, 10, 20 and 30 seconds.
A second sample race: Ivy runs 5 meters per second from the start line. Sam starts 20 meters ahead and runs 4 meters per second. When does Ivy catch Sam?
Write one question about plans, prices or races that you could answer with math. Put it on a sticky note for the Wonder Board.
We met our puzzle: two runners with different starts and speeds. Next we meet the families who will use our guide and the first plans they must compare.
Exit ticket: which runner's distance is proportional to time? Give one piece of evidence from the tables.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lesson 10, guided practice 8, hallway walk test 7, exit ticket 3.
Accuracy: the race is sample data. The CDC numbers (2.5 mph, 10 mph, 0-10 effort scale, 5-6 moderate, 7-8 vigorous) are from the page dated Dec. 4, 2025, opened 2026-11-20. Systems of equations are Part 2; here students find the meeting point only with tables.
Likely misconceptions: “the person ahead always wins”; “both runners are proportional because both add the same amount each second.” A constant rate is not enough: a proportional relationship also starts at 0 and keeps the same ratio.
Supports: a two-column table template with time counting by 5s. Stretch: if Theo had a 45-meter head start, when would Maya catch him? (45 s, at 180 m.)
Answer guide: Theo is ahead by 30 m at the start, but Maya gains 1 m each second, so after 30 s they are tied, and after that Maya leads. Exit ticket: Maya, because distance ÷ time is always 4 and 0 s matches 0 m. Walk test: a partner who walks 20 m in 16 s has a rate of 1.25, about 1.3 m/s.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, How to Measure Physical Activity Intensity · U.S. government work, public domain
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, or CDC, is the nation’s public health agency. This page explains intensity, which means how hard your body works during an activity. Intensity changes your heart rate and your breathing.
The CDC sorts activities into two levels. Moderate activities include brisk walking at 2.5 miles per hour or faster, biking slower than 10 miles per hour on level ground, and doubles tennis. Vigorous activities include jogging or running, jumping rope, singles tennis and biking faster than 10 miles per hour.
Notice that some examples are defined by a speed, which is a rate: miles for each hour. A rate tells how much one amount changes for each unit of another.
The page also gives a quick check called the talk test. During moderate activity, a person can talk but cannot sing. During vigorous activity, a person can say only a few words before stopping for a breath. People can also rate their effort from 0, sitting, to 10, the hardest they can work. Moderate is about 5 or 6, and vigorous starts at about 7 or 8.
Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, How to Measure Physical Activity Intensity (cdc.gov)